Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Beginner pen turning tools?

Posts

Beginner pen turning tools?

#1

Beginner pen turning tools?

ScottS

>So, I've had a hankering to try pen turning for quite a while and, after participating in a demo at the local Woodcraft, have decided to give it a go. Think I've figured out that the Jet Mini is the lathe of choice, which kits I'm interested in trying (probably the Americana or European from Craft Supplies USA), and that finishing for pens is just as confusing as finishing for flatwork ;-)

My big question at this point is what to buy in terms of pen turning tools. Any favorite brands or sets? I see lots of no-name sets with 3-5 tools for $40-60. Rockler has a 3-piece set from Crown on sale for $70 that seems interesting. Craft Supplies USA seems to have a number of different options (Henry Taylor, Robert Sorby, etc) in the $70-120 range.

I'd like to keep the budget around $100, if possible. That said, I'd rather spend a bit more and get decent tools than cut corners and end up frustrated. I don't have any experience sharpening turning tools, so having tools that are reasonably well setup "out of the box" would be a plus, I think.

I'd appreciate any advice you might have!

-- Scott

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

#2

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

Arw01

>I'm in the same boat, not bought the lathe yet, but informed my wife that is what I want for birthday at end of month. She will get with the inlaws and combine up for a Jet mini lathe.

In doing the research you are doing, I've seen a pattern where only 1 or 2 tools are normally used, so they, the turners, recommmend buying those two in good ones if you know what they are.

If you do not know, the more expensive set at Harbor Freight is a good place to learn which tools will work, and you will not cringe too bad if you don't sharpen real well!

Alan

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

#3

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

Dave Bonde

>Hello Scott, I use Benjamin's Best 3pc. Pen Turning set for making pens. Penn State has the set for $29.95 They are shorter that a full size tool and do a nice job for pen turning. You can spend more but any tool you buy will dull and need to be sharpened. Sharpening your lathe tools is just part of turning. I do most of my turning with a skew but others may use different tools. The set I mentioned has a 3/8" gouge (I think it is 3/8) a skew and a parting tool. I have a lot of other tools but am pleased with the value of this set. Dave

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

#4

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Scott,

I use a skew, standard sized 3/4". I don't think the sets will be as useful as many set contain tools I would never use. I bought my skew from Lee Valley...Henry Taylor.

take care,

Jim

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

#5

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

ScottS

>I have to say, I'm more than a bit hesitant to follow your advice about purchasing Harbor Freight turning tools. I haven't really been impressed with anything I've seen at or purchased from HF. For edge tools in particular, my past experience suggests that cheap tools usually lead to frustration: they're typically not sharp/usable when purchased, may require hours of work (by someone with more skills than I currently have) before they are sharp/usable, and even then they don't hold an edge well.

Can anyone else confirm the quality of Harbor Freight turning tools? FYI, the only tools I could find on their website were an 8-piece set for $36, that doesn't really seem appropriate for pen turning...

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

#6

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

Scott Greaves, Blackfoot Idaho

>Hi Scott! (Good Name!)

One thing you need to know is that even the best tools are not ready to go right out of the box. Oh, some may be sharp, but any of them can use some work. No matter what you buy, look them over closely, clean and polish them and make sure they're right. That includes sharpening them. Even if they were sharp, lathe tools are something you have to sharpen often.

Another misconception that many people have is that you need small tools to turn small items. Not true! Something along the lines of a 3/4" skew and a 3/8" spindle gouge are good basic tools for a lot of turning, including pens. A parting tool is also handy.

You should be looking for tools that are High Speed Steel (HSS). These will retain an edge longer. Although I like the features of some of the better tools, you will do just fine with a cheaper set of tools. One that keeps coming up is the HSS set from Harbor Freight. So I bought one of these sets about two years ago. No, I don't use them all the time, but I do use them, and they are just fine. You would be just fine with this set, and that would leave you a little more of your budget for some other things, like a better mandrel, a nice barrel trimmer, or more kits!

I hope this helps.

Scott.

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

#7

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

ScottS

>Do you use an oval skew? Or the straight one?

The technique I saw was to use a gouge (not sure what type; it looked fairly shallow to me, but I forgot to ask the name) to make a square blank cylindrical, then use a skew chisel for the majority of the work. I think the guy said that some pen kits (maybe the "European"?) require a "step" that was best done with a parting tool?

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

#8

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

Bill Howatt

>It probably was a spindle gouge. That is what I start with and then switch to the skew although you could probably do the whole operation with the skew. A parting tool is handy for cutting a step but it isn't the only way.

If you are going to do turning you will need these three tools to do just about any spindle work. Always buy High-Speed Steel (HSS) tools since they are much more tolerant of overheating when sharpening. I can't comment on the HF set.

I agree with Scott Greaves about using full size tools. They may seem rather big for the job but they aren't. Miniature tools are only needed for very, very small items.

Bill

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

#9

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

Jorge Castaneda

>Scott,

You don't use parting tools when making pens, you use a barrel trimmer on the drll press.

An oval skew will be fina, the gouge you mentioned is a spindle gouge, if all you want is a cilinder, you could do it all with the gouge, but the skew is better and leaves a nicer surface, all you need is the skew really.

Take my advice, I never made a pen!, yet, but very soon I will be turning a batch, following Jim Shaver's method.

take care

Jorge

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

#10

Re: Beginner pen turning tools? *LINK*

RussFairfield

>The instructions on my Website might be helpful to get you started.


Making a pen

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

#11

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

Kent in Emmaus, PA

>As a novice / learning turner, I've beeen using the HF 8 pc set for a year or so, and I think it's been a great starter set to try out the different tools, learn techniques, practice sharpening, and most imporantly, make some things. The high speed steel is good quality, and while I share your skepticism about cheap edge tools, the manufacturs seems to have gotten these right. I've noticed that a numebr of he more "upscale" vendors are now selling very similar Chinese HSS tools.

The set has a decent rangle of profiles for spindle work. As a beginner, I'd rather have a variety of cheap tools to experiment with, rather than try to guess which profiles I'll use.

With all due respect, your concerns about sharpening are off the mark. The drill for turning is turn for a bit, hit the grinder for a few seconds, and get back to turning. Repeat as needed. We're not talking about hours spent flattening the backs of tools or lapping edges to a mirror polish. It does help a lot to have a good sharpening setup (e.g., grinder, decent wheels, and a Wolverine jig or the like).

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

#12

Hi Scott

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Scott,

I use a full sized skew for all the of the process, it's a simple method to use it to make the blank a cylinder and then shape the pen to final. I ferquently hone the skew now as I approach my final shape.

I know of very good pen turners who use a variety of tools including a roughning gouge, a spindle gouge, a round nose scraper and even a parting tool for the shaping. Bottom line is to use what ever you feel comfortable with. I use the skew, I like the high angle shear cut I get with it, it took practice on many pens to get it right for me.

I like the suface finish I get from the skew as well, when things are going right it requires no real sanding to clean up tool marks, only wet sanding to refine the surface to a polished finish.

I will say that to refine your tool work takes practice and patience, give your self a chance and take your time.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

#13

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

Kent in Emmaus, PA

>Oh, yeah - about tool size. As others have said, you can use full size tools for small scale work. Because you're using the tool rest as a fulcrum, a longer tool actually gives finer control at the cutting edge. I have a mini turning tool set (also from HF), but I haven't really found it useful.

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

#14

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

Richard Gillespie

>I bought the less expensive 4 piece HF set and have been pleased with it so far. I did regrind the skew chisel to a scraper because I already a skew I inherited from my father. I've only used the scraper and gouge from the set. In addition to those I've been using My father's spindle gouge and skew. These all have worked well on pens. My only regret is the skew is flat and I'd rather it was oval.

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

#15

Re: Beginner pen turning tools?

Bruce Wiseman

>I've probabily taught a 100 or so people to make pens, I always have them use a good 3/8 spindel gouge. If you buy one locally you might be able to talk them into putting and edge on it for you. With care and a hone you should be able to make quite a few pens before you have to sharpen it on the grinder. The other tool you will need for the Parker style or Euro pens is a parting tool. I highly recommend Russ' link on pen making. Good luck, have fun, follow the assemble instructions.

Bruce