Re: another oil finishing question
RussFairfield
>The short answer to a complex question is that there is no difference.
In the broader definition, all oil finishes are alike because their liquid molecules polymerize into larger solid molecules to form a "finish". We call this "drying", and these oils "drying oils". The resins can be those in the oil itself, or they can be added in the form of either natural or manufactured compounds, that will form a harder surface film than the oil itself. With those definitions, Watco Danish, Waterlox, and the Minwax "Tung Oil", Wipe-On Poly, and "Old Fashioned", are all the same. And, they are no different from any other oil finish that is mixed together as a commercial product, or something we brew up ourselves.
The devil is in the details. Different oils have different properties. There are differences in how they react to light and air, UV resistance, resistance to moisture in the air, resistance to acids, chemical resistance, color change with age, how they change the color of the wood, abrasion resistance, hardness (durability), repairability, cure time, useability, just to name a few.
The common "drying oils" used in finishes are Tung Oil, Linseed Oil, Boiled Linseed Oil, Soybean Oil, Walnut Oil. Tung Oil is naturaly a drying oil. Walnut Oil can be either drying or non-drying, depending on how it was extracted from the nut. Raw Linseed is a surface drying oil that seals the liquid under it from the oxygen it needs to "dry". Boiled Linseed Oil has drying agents added to solve the surface drying problem. Soybean Oil is a non-drying oil that will polymerize in a thin film when exposed to air whith the addition of metallic salts.
Similarly, the different resins will have differences in the same properties as the oils. The resins may be natural resins and gums that are extracted from trees and plants, or they may be a mineral. They may be alaphatic resins that are extracted from animal fat. Then there are the synthetics, the 3 most common being alkyd, polyurethane, and phenolic. Add to that the definition that consideres the solids in the oils themselves as being resins, and the topic of resins starts getting complicated.
This is not a simple topic and there is no simple answer. All are oils, all are different, and those differences will appeal to defferent people. You will have to determine which of the different oils will give you the properties and workability that you want. All we can do is give you our personal preferences.
Here is my view of the products mentioned. There will be those who will argue with every one of them.
I prefer Tung Oil because it doesn't get as dark as fast as Boiled Linseed Oil or Soybean Oil, and it changes the color of the wood the least. And I prefer the phenolic resins for their softer and warmer appearance and feel than the polyurethanes, and they are more durable than the alkyds.
That means I would prefer Waterlox because it is the only one of the finishes listed that contains only Tung Oil, and it is the only one that contains phenolic resins. The finish that I blend myself is as close as I can get to Waterlox, and I make my own because it has the advantages of lower cost, more solids (resins) anmd that means the same results with fewer coats, longer shelf life because I can mix it in smaller quantities as needed, and I have control of how much thinner is used.
Watco Danish is and has always been the finish of choice for a lot of woodworkers and woodturners. It has gone through so many different ownerships and formulations in the last 15 years that it is impossible to tell you what is in it. It started as Boiled Linseed Oil and Mineral Spirits, transitioned through Soybean Oil, went through various blends, and I understand that it has returned to its roots.
Minwax "Tung Oil" finish is the poster-child for the finishing products that have made "Tung Oil" a generic term because the closest they ever got to a Tung Nut was the name on the label. It is possible that the label is not a total falsehood because there might be some resins added that were extracted from the Tung nut. There is nothing wrong with it as a finish, and a lot of people are using it. Just don't get the notion that you are using Tung Oil.
Minwax Poly. The oil used to be soybean, but I have no idea what it is now; and the resins that are added are polyurethane with all of the properties that go with it. I personally don't like polyurethane resins, so this wouldn't be a finish that I would use. There are a lot of woodturners who disagree with me.
Minwax "Old Fashioned Oil Finish" (in the red can). This the only one that lives up to its name. It is, and has always been, a high quality Boiled Linseed finish; and that's not at all a bad thing. This is the most under-rated of all the commercial finish among woodturners.
Whew.
Sorry it got so long.