Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

QUESTION ?�?

Posts

QUESTION ?�?

#1

QUESTION ?�?

Jim King

>Has anyone ever used a router and a jig to cut out perfectly round bowl blanks ? I need to round a lot of blanks up to six inches thick. Or for that matter any other form of rounding blanks except band saws.

Re: QUESTION ?�?

#2

Bandsaw Circle Jig - Here's How with *PICS*

Garrett in Victoria

>Hi Jim

I don't think any router could cut material "up to 6" thick".

OTOH, a simple bandsaw jig should do the job easily and well. Here's one I made a few years ago, and that was published in Canadian Woodworking magazine.

Bandsaw Circle Jig

This is a project that uses scrap. Dimensions aren't important, except in fitting the jig to your bandsaw. The platen is plastic laminate on particle board, a top from an old computer desk. (Which explains the extra hole you might see in it.)

Step one was to position the platen on the bandsaw table, set the fence, and feed it half way into the saw. With the saw turned off, I clamped it in position, and used an awl to scribe the table edges on the bottom.


With the platen now on my bench, I routed a dovetail slot 5/8" across its opening in 2 passes using a standard dovetail bit, and then routed a 1/4" slot in the dovetail slot to accept a carriage bolt.


With the platen flipped over, I machined and screwed on 2 pieces of hardwood using the previously scribed lines as references. (The notch accommodates the bandsaw table levelling pin and its "keeper" screw.)


Lying on the platen is a piece of scrap walnut that was cut just slightly oversize on the tablesaw to make the sliding dovetail. A pass or two with a sanding block took off the sharp edges, and a block plane eased the fit for easy sliding. A hole in the centre of the slider is countersunk with a 5/8� Forstner bit and then drilled through with a �� bit to take the carriage bolt. The bolt is fastened underneath the platen with a washer and a wing nut.


A 5/16" blind hole drilled in one end takes a steel pin for cutting heavy, awkward turning rounds, while right beside it is a removable 18 gauge 3/4" finishing nail - a real nail not a brad - cut down as a pin for small work. Pins of any size can be inserted in various locations on the end of the slider. As is the jig will cut up to 20" circles. Flip the slide end for end, and it will cut up to 40" diameter.


A Kwik-Klamp locks the jig securely onto the bandsaw table.

The one very important setup requirement is that the centre of the pin be exactly in line with the teeth on the band.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: QUESTION ?�?

#3

Re: QUESTION ?�?

Pete in Holland, MI

>Carefull using a router to make a disk round. My neighbor made a jig with a pin to pivot the board on and turn it into the cutter sticking above his router table. The cutter bit spun & sucked the disk into itself, along with his pinky.

Re: QUESTION ?�?

#4

Re: QUESTION ?�?

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Jim, this doesn't sound like an efficient or quick way to cut out blanks. When you're doing a 6" thick blank, you'd need a 3" long cutter and cut the piece from both sides. I kind of doubt you can get a 6" long cutter, could be wrong--maybe a spiral-flute machinist's end mill?

Are you wanting to mill the perimeter of a piece that's already rough-cut to round, or actually cut it out of a larger chunk?

The only reason I can think of where a router would be better than a lathe or bandsaw, is when the piece is beyond the lathe's capacity, and you don't have a bandsaw--or the bandsaw doesn't make the wood as perfectly round as needed.

Why not a bandsaw?

Re: QUESTION ?�?

#5

Re: QUESTION ?�?

Jim King

>Ken: Twenty plus years working with wood and either I still havn�t learned to operate a band saw or there is not one made for dense woods. We have tried different sets, different blade manufacturers and about every band saw in town. It is certainly possible to cut a blank if you have the patience but we need to cut hundreds and I am looking for a way to do them perfect and fast. I think I am looking for something that does not exist but someone here should know if such a thing is out there.

Re: QUESTION ?�?

#6

Re: QUESTION ?�?

Stephen Mushinski

>Jim,

Not sure what your setup is but it might not be the blade but the HP of your bandsaw. I have cut lots of exotic wood with a bandsaw but the setup has to be right. For steady cutting you will want a saw with 3 - 5 HP motor. The simple jigs also work well once setup.

Re: QUESTION ?�?

#7

Re: QUESTION ?�?

Eduardo Sarmiento Hall,lima peru

>hi jim i cut up to 12" in my band saw with no problem ,3/4 blade and 3hp motor single phase no problem just call me and will give you the info to get one but is pricey aroun $2000 dollars here in lima second hand

Re: QUESTION ?�?

#8

Yup... *LINK*

Peter Teubel

>Check out the video clips on the lower right of the page. They have one of a router rounding out a good sized bowl blank.


The SpinDoctor

Re: QUESTION ?�?

#9

Re: QUESTION ?�?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>How "perfect" does it need to be? Do your customers need to be able to see the figure and grain and color of the wood? Does this tool have to be something you can purchase, or can you build it yourself, from some half-baked ideas? I know a lot of people down there are pretty resourceful at adapting and building new tools and processes from salvaged and modified equipment.

The first question that occurred to me was "If not a bandaw, why not a lathe? Even with someone with a turning muscle like Bill Grumbine's that would still take a lot of time. So, my next question was, what cuts wood faster than a bandsaw? I was thinking about a chainsaw mill, but it doesn't cut curves, because of the depth of the bar. Then I thought about a much wider bar, with a hole in it that the offcuts would pass through, just like on a bandsaw. You'd have to build a platform that the blank would rotate on. Probably a horizontal platform, with lazy susan bearings underneath, and with a tailstock coming down from above would provide better support, and would be easier to load and unload. Then I thought, why do it all in one operation? Maybe start with a pivoting chain saw set up like a chop saw, that would cut it square in four cuts, rotating 90� after each cut, then an an octagon in four more, and then bring up the chain bandsaw to knock off off the bumps. Now, all you need is something to make the face smooth, if that's necessary. Maybe you could finish it up the lathe? You might find chainsaw blades easier and less expensive to maintain than bandsaw blades.

Re: QUESTION ?�?

#10

Don Pencil

Re: QUESTION ?�?

Don Pencil

>Jim,

I cut about 2000 blanks per year for myself and others. I have tried to use jigs but the bandsaw blade will follow the grain and a jig does not allow for the flexiblity need to made modest adjustments as you go. I would go with the bandsaw and just work with it as best you can.

I started with a Jet 14" style bandsaw. Moved up to an 18" Jet when I started producing in mass and now use a 24" Aggazini.

E-mail me your telephone number. I will call you and better relate what I have learn over the years.

Be Well,

Don Pencil

don@donpencil.com

Re: QUESTION ?�?

#11

Corrected Link  *LINK*

Peter Teubel

>


The SpinDoctor

Re: QUESTION ?�?

#12

Re: QUESTION ?�?

Jim King

>Thanks everybody for the ideas, it looks like the band saw wins and we will try another one once again. To the question about the grain the answer is yes, the grain shows much better on the round blank and many people like the blanks rounded as they dont have a band saw. I am still thinking about some type of holder that could rotate the blank over the jointer until it is round but we dont have time right now to play with that.