Hollow Form
Scott Greaves
>This is a piece of Boxelder burl. I have been messing with this one off and on over that past year. The shape turned out OK. I don't care for the finial on it - too bulky. Probably about 8" across.
Scott.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Hollow Form
Scott Greaves
>This is a piece of Boxelder burl. I have been messing with this one off and on over that past year. The shape turned out OK. I don't care for the finial on it - too bulky. Probably about 8" across.
Scott.
Another Picture
Scott Greaves
>
I agree with you- finial has to go...
steve antonucci
>but the form under it is great. Tall and thin,maybe with a small ball at the top that mirror the shape of the form?
I hope that you post it again with the new finial.
steve
Re: Hollow Form
RevDoug
>I'll second it. The form is great. The wood is great. The finish is great. Finial is not so great. I vote for just loosing it. I'm not the greatest fan of finials in hollow-forms anyway.
Turn 'em round,
I've got to agree..
Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin
>with the others. Nice shape on the hollow form and nice wood. A small collar would be OK, but the finial doesn't work for me.
Re: Hollow Form
Keith Tompkins
>HI Scott, welcome to the world of finials! Here is my take: The form itself is very attractive; my only small critique is that the emphasis point is very near the center. Raising or lowering it just a touch will give a boost to the form. It's obvious that you spent some time and effort on the form.
The finial is a good learning opportunity....It does not appear you gave the finial as much consideration as the form. I think it needs more contrast against the form....black would be best, I think. Then, it would be good to tie the shape of the finial to the shape of the form. For instance, you could mimic the shape of the form somewhere in the finial. A long, slender spire would give the finial a balanced appearance. (check out Cindy Drozda's pieces)
I would draw your form on a sketch pad, then draw different finials to see the effect they have on the overall appearance. Then apply coves, beads, and fillets...the finishing touch to a finial. I think it is far more difficult to create a good spindle turning than it is to create a good hollow form.
Re: Another Picture
RussFairfield
>I agree with everyone else. Take the finial off. This is a fins hollow form and either a collar or finial would add a lot to it. Finials are all the rage among woodturners these days, but I still prefer a simple collar ot nothing on most of the things that people are putting the finials on top of.
This is a good one to use your computer as a design tool. Go through the archives, websites, and magazines for photos of things with finials and collars. Make copies and crop the finials and collars out of the photos and put them on top of the hollow form. It is a better visual way to do it than making sketches.
Re: Hollow Form
Scott Greaves
>Thanks everybody! I appreciate the ideas. I will incorporate them on my next piece.
Scott.