Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Ebony identification?

Posts

Ebony identification?

#1

Ebony identification?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>I've been turning some small pieces of ebony I got in a "grab bag" from WoodCraft. It turns easily, leaving only fine dust, no shavings, and finishes to a very high polish. It is mostly black, with a few light cream colored streaks running through it. Does anyone know which species of Diospyros I have here? They guys at the WoodCraft retail store don't know. See the top and third examples in this photo. (The other two are cocobolo, Dalbergia retusa.) The pic is about .6 megabytes, so I'm just providing its url, instead of forcing everyone with a dialup modem who reads this post to download it. The turnings average about 4" long and about 7/8" dia.

http://members.aol.com/cohanseystudio/burnishers.jpg

Re: Ebony identification?

#2

Re: Ebony identification?

Jim King

>This will not help but will give you an idea of where tropical wood ID stands and why the guys at Woodcraft could not answer your question.. The person who sent me the note below is :

Mihaly Czako, Ph.D.

Senior Research Associate

Department of Biological Sciences

University of South Carolina

We are working with him and Regis Miller the retired head of the USDA Tropical Forestry Lab.

7. We discussed ebony and I told you that the proper identification of

African

ebony is currently impossible for Regis Miller and me, and possible the

European experts because these institutional collections do not have

properly

collected wood. There is no way to verify the identity of the specimens

housed in USDA because there is no pressed leaves and flowers deposited

along

with the wood sample. I am sitting atop a pile of wonderful ebonies

that I can

distinguish and classify into neat chemical categories but precious few

of them

can be assigned to a particular species with certainty. As soon as I

locate a

good specimen of Gabon ebony I will be able to tell an unknown sample

if it is

Gabon or not. Same is true for your sacha cumaceba. I am not yet sure

if it is

Platymiscium pinnatum but I hope to resolve it soon if I can see the

flowers,

but I know for fact that USDA cannot tell either. This is one of the

issues we

discussed with the current wood anatomist (Alex) and Regis when I

visited with

them early August (before I contacted you). They are at a loss with

Platymiscium. So, in due time, I would like to take advantage of your

Nigeria

connections to obtain properly collected African ebonies. It would be a

great

service to wood science.

Re: Ebony identification?

#3

Re: Ebony identification?

Anthomy Y

>I'm thinking Gaboon

Re: Ebony identification?

#4

Re: Ebony identification?

Doug Trembath

>Contrary to popular belief, there are a number of different species, I have found out, that commonly get identified as ebony, same as there are maple. The way you describe the shavings and workability, you may have African Blackwood, which is much harder than ebony, and prone to the sapwood streaks you describe. Gabon ebony is another possibility, as it has sapwood streaks sometimes as well. Blackwood, for those not familiar, is hard enough to chase threads, and is often used with Ivory for contrast. Also the primary species used for woodwind instruments. Sure looks good polished and waxed, doesn't it?

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: Ebony identification?

#5

Re: Ebony identification?

Doug Trembath

>William, I had your pic downlaoding while I answered your post, and was about to leave when I found it (dial-up, and not the fastest one out here in the woods).

Looks more like Macassar ebony in the pic. It has lovely light and dark brown streaks, and sometimes the most fabulous grain. I have a full sized blank waiting for myself to get the courage to attack it as a hollow form. I've set aside a few pieces like this among the many hundreds I've turned, wanting to end up with something really spectacular.

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: Ebony identification?

#6

Re: Ebony identification?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Thanks, Jim.

If I'd thought a bit more about it, I would have realized that was probably at least part of the problem. If it were a comodity item, like "red oak" or "white oak," I usually wouldn't care, but it would be nice to know more clearly when using special wood for special tools.

If it's origin is Africa, I suppose the guys who are harvesting it and distributing it consider it just a comodity, and don't care to know any more about it. That's probably part of why some of the ebonies, and also African blackwood, are endangered species. If the origin is some place like Nigeria, that would be cause for concern for other reasons, which we should not discuss here.

If WoodCraft, or someone in their supply chain even suspects its place of origin may give them "bad press" for political reasons, that would be another reason to conveniently forget all about the whats, wheres, whos and hows. But probably, they just honestly don't know.

At least, I would be interested to know if I have a real ebony (of the genus Diospyros), with many species distributed over the old world tropics, or African blackwood, Dalbergia melanoxylon, also called Mpingo and ebony, whose origin is Kenya and Tanzania. It is the latter, which is a rosewood, that is used for clarinets and piano keys (flats).

FYI, While researching these questions, I also found out that the genus Diospyros also includes the persimmons (one species from China, which is the fruit we are familiar with, and another which grows in the Eastern US, and is used for golf club heads) and a species called Lama, which is endemic to Hawaii.

Re: Ebony identification?

#7

Re: Ebony identification?

RussFairfield

>The problem you are having is that Gabon and Macassar Ebony have become generic terms. It isn't any different from all of the various species that are as Pine, or Maple, or any other familiar wood.

I have several pieces of what I bought as Gabon Ebony over the last 30 or so years. The only property they share is that they are all black.