Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

tricky cuts and sanding

Posts

tricky cuts and sanding

#1

tricky cuts and sanding

David Breth

>Last night I turned a box - one of few I've ever turned, and for once did not completely destroy it. But questions arise:

1) What do you use to hollow out the endgrain box? This was maybe 2-2.5 inch interior diameter. I was throwing everything I had at it to hack away that wood, but everything I have is a starter Sorby set of five tools - 3/8 roughing, 1/4 spindle, skew, 1/8 parting, round scraper. Whenever I do an endgrain opening like this I just kill the interior if it goes to any depth, I'm not getting sufficient bezel on the wood. Whattya use?

2) Sanding a piece like this is a bit of a trick. I ran the lathe at the slowest speed, delicately stuck my fingers in there and did it as best I could without getting too aggressive. Unwise sanding method on my part - my fingers were in there up to the hilt, and a little left-right movement and I'm pretty sure I don't want to know the outcome. ("stupid" comes to mind) How do you safely sand something like this while on the lathe?

Thanks -

David B.

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

#2

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

RussFairfield

>I use a diamond parting tool. Push it straight in. It does a good job on end grain. I put a longer handle on it to get more leverage.

I sand by wrapping strips of sandpaper around a 1" wood dowel. A slit across the end keeps it in place, and 2 or 3 wraps gives it a soft backing.

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

#3

Re: tricky cuts and sanding *LINK*

Mike Schwing from Md.

>David, I don't make many boxes (a couple pic'd below though). But for those that I did, I first drilled a pilot hole, using as large a forstner bit as I could manage, to remove the difficult center and set the depth. (A set of Forstners is REALLY useful when making boxes). After that I use my hollowing tools - scrapers, to do the rest. Pam Reilly told me she uses a Sorby multi tip scraper to hollow her wonderful boxes, and they don't really get any better than hers.

Sanding is another story better told by folks better at sanding boxes than me.


A couple of boxes

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

#4

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

John Lucas

>David I do quite a few boxes and teach classes. I generally use a bowl gouge but I find that my students are more comfortable with a round nose scraper. Grind the left side back about3/4 to 1 inch so it has the same bevel. Most scrapers come with a little grind on the front and if you catch that non ground corner it will grab on you. I find it is also easier for students to use the scraper if they drill a starter hole. We use a 3/8" drill in class but you can use what ever you like. The scraper doesn't cut very well in the dead center. Drilling out the center solves this problem.

I've always just used my fingers on any box that is short enough for me to get into. As long as you stay left of center and at or above the center line you will be fine. If your worried Russ's suggestion of a dowel works great. I used to have a set of Forceps that I held sandpaper with. These worked great but walked off during one of my classes.

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

#5

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

David Breth

>As I think of it, all these responses jive with what I knew the answers must be.

I did drill a hole to alleviate the center problems for the scraper, and to set depth. Problem was/is that I don't have one of those drill bit deals for the lathe, so I use the cheap ineffective alternative of holding a bit in vice grips and very slowly cutting a hole. Thing is, the hole was not straight - difficult thing to do if you haven't tried it. So, the scraper was getting punched each revolution because the hole wasn't true. Future - get one of those drill bit deals for the lathe, duh.

David B.

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

#6

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

John Lucas

>David it is nice to have one of those things, I use a jacobs chuck with a morse taper but you can also buy drill bits that have a morse taper shank. If you drill the hole by hand it's off a little just take the roundnose scraper and push it straight in. Make sure the right hand side doesn't touch the right side of the hole. It should cut all the way to the bottom but you might try pushing in a little ways and then moveing it to the left to open up the space and give some clearance and then push in a little further. Repeat this process until you've hollowed the box.

If you have a dimple in the center of the bottom take the scraper and start just below the dimple. Then lower than handle so the scraping edge raises up through the dimple. Then just move the scraper gently left and right to blend it in.

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

#7

Spindle Gouge & Shear Scraper

Turner

>David,

I use a spindle gouge to take out the waste material fast... no need to drill a hole first using this method, just don't go too deep. Remove almost all of the wood that needs to be removed with the spindle gouge.

Next switch to a round nose scraper with the left side ground back, or a purpose-made shear scraper and shear-scrape the finishing cuts. With practice you can start sanding with 220-280 grit paper after mastering the shear scraping method.

I hope this helps!

Turner

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

#8

Re: Spindle Gouge & Shear Scraper

Tony - Memphis

>I am an absolute rookie at turning, but when I discovered what I was doing wrong when end-grain hollowing, it was like magic! I use a spindle gouge turned at around 45�. Between this site and a video (Keith Rowley I think)I have, I discovered that I was not turning the gouge to the proper angle. I then do a little clean up with a round nosed scraper. Still need practice there, but I'm getting it. I mostly do furniture parts, but I liek to turn some fun things with scraps. I've made a couple of coffee scoops ala Ruth Niles and a brush vase for my wifey the artist to hold paint brushes in.

Tony

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

#9

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

JKJ in East TN

>The Termite tool works very well hollowing end grain. It was designed just for that. Once hollowed, I use a box scraper to clean up the side and bottom corner, it's sort of a flat scraper with a long angle up one side at the tip. Another thing that helps is supporting the scraper with a flat tool rest that fits inside the box. Best Wood Tools has these.

JKJ

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

#10

Re: tricky cuts and sanding *LINK*

phil in NJ

>The Richard Raffan book and DVD on turning boxes are very good. I would strongly recommend both. I think all of your questions would be answered there.


Raffan book on Amazon

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

#11

Re: Spindle Gouge & Shear Scraper

Michael Serpa

>I recently attended a demo by Chris Stott who started off by making a box, with perfect fitting lid, in 32 seconds!!! OK, not the prettiest box, but a box with lid none the less! He only used two tools, his signature parting tool and a 3/8 spindle gouge. The method of drilling out the center with the spindle gouge is precise and very fast. You can't get the hole off center.

I have been making boxes with my homemade hook tool and almost never have to sand. Some softer woods require sanding but the exotics seldom do. If sanding is needed I use Chris Stott's method of flexible K wieght paper primed with Briwax. This works really well on ebony, cocobolo, etc. There are many good tools on the market for hollowing endgrain. Berger tool, Hamlet Big Brother, Little Brother, Supercut, Just to name a few. There are many scraper grinds that work really well also. As they say "there are many ways to skin a cat"!

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

#12

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

David Breth

>Thank you very much everybody!

Man I love this website.

David B.

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

#13

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

Ed Karch in No.VA

>I use a spindle gouge to drill the hole then a Berger tool for a nice flat bottom box.Very fast then follow with sanding using a split dowl.

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

Keith Tompkins

>HI David, to clarify what several others replied, the DETAIL gouge with a long swept back grind works wonders. Start at the center and work outward with the flute facing the tool rest at about a 45 degree angle. Push in, remove material with a scooping action, repeat. I make my last cut from the rim to the base which produces a clean cut. An Ellsworth grind bowl gouge works very well, but is easy to get a nasty catch until you gain experience with it. Very fast technique.

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

#15

Re: tricky cuts and sanding

Niedling

>David

Of the tools you have, I agree with the others that the round nose scraper is the right choice. Normally this tool is very easy to control. I agree with John, that you should grind the tool to eliminate the corners. I usually grind it more like a finger nail, so the corners are swept back along the sides. You did not mention how deep you were trying to go, but a small 1/2" scraper will be hard to control if you are extending the tool more than about 3" over the tool rest. You will get some vibration and the tool will start jumping around. The larger the scraper, the deeper you can go.

Also make sure that your tool rest is set at the right height. The tool should be used with the back of the handle higher than the cutting edge and the cutting edge at about center.

Also make sure that you re-sharpen your scraper to make the last couple of finishing cuts. These cuts should be lighter than the roughing out cuts.

Good luck turning.