We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
As I was making my final shopping list for the Ottawa Wood Show this weekend, I came across Hamlet Turning Tools on Jacques Coulombe's website. (http://www.jacquescoulombe.com) I had not heard or seen these chisels previously, but of course I haven't been in the market for high end chisels for very long.
They offer most of their chisels (I figure they have just about every kind of turning chisel in existance) in regular M2 HSS as well as in even harder steels, ASP 2030 and ASP 2060. They claim that the ASP 2060 steel will hold an edge 4 times longer than regular M2 HSS.
What I would like to know is whether the M2 HSS steel they sell is as good as the M2 steel offered by Henry Taylor or P&N. Jacques has currently got a 25% discount on the already reasonable prices for Hamlet Tools. I just want to make sure there is no reason for me to change all of my HT and P&N chisels on my list to Hamlets.
>Hamlet tools are quality tools in the same class as Sorby Taylor etc. I have a couple of the 2060 tools. Their claim that an edge on a 2060 will last 4 times longer is a stretch. I have a number of bowl gouges, Sorby, Taylor and Glaser. My go-to tool is my 2060, although for roughing out I usually use my Glaser because it's heavier.
I have a few of the M2 variety, one of them the Ellsworth gouge, is my go tool, and the others are good too, I like them better than the Sorbys, same quality as Henry Tailor.
>All the M2 steels are, basically alike if they are all made in Sheffield. This includes Henry Taylor, Ashley Isles, Sorby and Hamlet, as well as the less well known ones. Buy the one that is on sale. I did not realize Hamlet still made the 2030 -- I thought they had been phased out some time ago because people did not see enough of an improvement in the steel to justify the cost. The 2060 will stay sharper longer. This can come in handy if you are roughing out a bunch of bowls. But if you are finishing dried bowls, it is of no use because you are going to want to sharpen the tool before the final cut on each bowl. So, in this case, it lasts the same length of time as a regular 2060. I have found the P&N tools last just as long as the Sheffield steel tools and are often less expensive. P&N also has some very useful shapes like their detail spindle gouge. I use it all the time to do detail work on bowls.
In the non-name-brand products, there are some good tools, and some junk. Our club recommends a set sold by Canadian Tire. These often come on sale at half price and are very good steel. Great as a backup set of tool on which you can try new grinds. Also, I bought a Benjamin's Best tool a few months ago from Penn State (at a show in the US). These are made in China. I figured at $20US I could not go wrong. The steel seems to be as good as the Sheffield. steel.
I keep five 5/8 inch bowl gouges going at the same time. They include a Hamlet 2060, a Henry Taylor, a Oneway, a P&N and now the Benjamin's Best. They all get dull in about the same amount of time and all go to the grinder at the same time.
The Chinese will make whatever quality you ask for. Obviously, Penn State has gone for quality. But that does not mean that all Chinese-made tools are of similar quality. I have seen some pretty awful looking junk out there I would be afraid to use -- and not all of it was made in China.
>Me too Bill. The set of tools from Harbour Freight is good steel too. I go for the profile much more than for the ability to go longer between sharpenings. Also, in the performance area: how does the gouge eject chips (curls)? Some of the grinds use extra metal under the cutting edge to add minutes to the life but this alters the profile so that curls don't eject quickly or easily, not to mention moving the cutting edge higher which adds to problems with catches. My favorites are Sorby and One-way.
I have most of my turning tools from Jacques Coulombe. I see him annually at a couple of local shows. I buy almost all my turning tools from him, all Hamlets!
>I agree about PSI's Benjamin's Best gouges. I have several, and like you said, at about $20 a pop, you can't beat them. That being said, the tool I have that keeps its edge the longest is a Crown Powder Metal (black handle) spindle gouge. It stays sharp about 2-3 times longer than the Benjamin's Best, at 2-3 times the cost. I guess it depends on how close your grinder is to your lathe...
>I've bought several Hamlet gouges from Jacques Coulombe Ltd. over the past few years. I have several in ASP 2060 steel and a few in HSS.
It's always fun when Jacques himself answers the phone in French to take your order. He'll adjust to English right away, of course, if that's your language. I'm not sure the current price is any better now than it has been in the time I've been buying from him. His web site is linked below and you'll find a currency converter that you can access to get prices if you're a US buyer.
For the record, Hamlet makes most of the Packard branded gouges sold by Packard Woodworks. This has been discussed here before.