We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I'm in the market for a decent face shield/respirator. I'm turning all sorts of exotic woods for pens as well as other man made materials. I'm concerned about the possible health effects, so I'm considering buying one of these devices.
The TriTon is on sale for $199.99 at Craft Supply USA, but they also sell the Trend for $319.00. Regardless of the price, the difference is not as important to me as how well they work. Has anyone done a comparison of these devices and made any recommendations?
>I bought the Trend nearly a year ago at Woodcraft. December 29th to be exact. I've been very happy with the way it works, it's not cumbersome to me at all and I feel so much better about not breathing all that dust. Especially in the colder months when I have my shop door shut and the heat on. I've always talked highly of this unit both here on the forums and to other turners I run into. With all of that said....lately I've become disenchanted with it. It's just not holding up the way a nearly $300.00 piece of equipment should, in my opinion. Over the past 3 months I've noticed fine cracks in the face shield...I've not ever been hit with a piece of flying wood in the face shield to cause this. TREND tells me that they did receive a bad batch of shields. A bit of a concern to me to say the least. Also the piece of material that sits on your face to keep the dust out is breaking down and falling apart. I'm not one to wear makeup so I'm not sure what is causing that. I'd hate to think what a man's 5 O'clock shadow or rough beard would do to it. It's just cracking all over and so it doesn't seal like it should. Finally on the temple points where the two knobs tighten down to adjust the helmet so that it will stay up when pushed up off your face, the spacers(part #13 on the exploded view) are breaking so that this mechanism doesn't work properly any more.
I've talked with Terry from TREND and he assures me that they will take care of these issues. I'm certain they will, by replacing the shield and the other parts that are failing....because it's under warranty....but what happens in 6 months when it starts happening again? If I need to replace all of these parts on a yearly basis, plus the filters and such I'm in for probably over $100 maintenance every year and I'm not prepared to do that. So I'm thinking I may cut my losses and return it to Woodcraft under their one year money back guarantee and go another route. It really bums me out because I really do love this unit, other than it falling apart on me. I'd also like to add that I am pretty anal about taking care of my tools and stuff and I always keep it stored properly in the bag that came with it and take really good care of it.
>Hello Bart, I am in the same position as you are. I don't do a lot of turning so my main two uses are sanding flat material and cutting dovetails with my router, as well as various cutting operations. When I come in and try to clean out my nose and eyes (well you get the picture)I finally said I need something. I saw the sale at Craft Supply and said I guess it is the right time. I read a few reviews online and if I had an unlimited budget I would buy the 3M unit. I liked the Trend but the filter replacement cost and $50 more pushed me to the Triton. I also liked the built in ear protection (it might make me use them more) and the hood that covers the front will help me in the routering operations. Those things that are an advantage to me might be a neg. for someone else. By the way the Triton unit is on back order until about Dec. 23 - if you go with the Trend I saw it for $249.00 (online somewhere) Good luck in your search
>I've had a Triton for a couple of years now and have been happy with it. I graduated from the 3M(Racal) shield when I felt like better dust protection was needed. The built in hearing protection is definitely an encouragement to use it more often. I use it for any operation around the shop that generates dust and/or requires face protection, not just for turning.
>I've been using a Dustfoe mask from Woodcraft for ten years.It's a great little mask-in fact it's so good they stopped selling it.I tried them all and for a non-powered respirator it is the best.Used in the mining industry.Now that it's getting worn out I would like to find another one.
>Bart, I have been using the Trend Airshield for about a year and am very pleased with the system.
If you do decide to purchase please consider buying 2 battery packs because the recharge time is approximately 14 hours and it gives you the opportunity of using one whilst the other charges.