Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

McNaughton System question

Posts

McNaughton System question

#1

McNaughton System question

Vicmarc.fan

>I have Mike Mahoneys DVD and in it he says " lets use this blade because it is the logical one to use". He never explanins why he really picked that blade. My problem is I usually turn the bottom out of the blank under the top one because I make too much of a cone shape in the top one. I can't seem to "thread the needle" as he says. Is there any logic to which one of the three blades to use? So far I have had luck only with the straight blade as a parting tool. Works great.

Ron

Re: McNaughton System question

#2

Re: McNaughton System question

Fog Tanner

>Take the various blades and hold them over the top of your bowl and look down. You can see the various curves and their relation to the shape of your bowl. You can also see the entry angle, its not square to the face of the blank, but at an angle. What Mike was looking at was the above, the blade with the best fit and what angle to enter the wood. But, he has done so many that he knows which blade works on that piece of wood.

The first time I used the system, I would up using the straight blade and cutting a cone too. The second time I cut the blank as I intended and got two more bowls from the center. It just takes a little thought and practice. I got Mike's DVD just to see if there was another way of using the tool, but enjoyed his presentation and found it helpful.

Fog

Re: McNaughton System question

#3

Re: McNaughton System question

Sean Troy

>If you've ever seen Mike use the system, you'll notice he pulls like mad on that handle(pressure/release)that clears the hole and gets your curve to continue. He also make two passes down the same path. There is no pussy footen around when coring like the directions may lead you to beleive. You just plan your cut and go for it. That bar is bending pretty good if your doing it correctly like Mike shows.

Re: McNaughton System question

#5

Re: McNaughton System question

Darryl Hansen

>Remember that the tip of the tool is on the center line of the handle extension. I took a piece of 3/8" aluminum flat stock. Bent it 90 degrees. One leg is long enough to reach the tip of the tools the other longer than the diameter of the largest bowl I can turn. Put the flat of the leg against the flat place where the tool goes into the handle. The edge of the leg is against the gouge. I put a mark on the tool leg for the various lengths of gouge. You can easily see where the gouge will goby holding it above the bowl blank. As I hollow I check to see where the gouge really is inside the bowl. Cheeeeper than lazer and works for me.

Re: McNaughton System question

#6

Re: McNaughton System question *LINK*

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Ron

I've been using the KM tool for years, and have taught a whole bunch of people to do the same in my shop and in others. I am not sure what exactly you mean by the top bowl, but if you mean the largest bowl of the blank, the one we call the "money bowl" around here, then there are a couple of things I can suggest right away.

The cores you take from any blank need to follow the outside shape of that blank fairly closely if you want the maximum sized core. However, it is better to err on the side of shallow than go too deep. It is not very satisfying to have a perfect core if the main bowl is now a funnel. When I turn a bowl that is going to be cored, I will turn it to the shape that I want to turn, not necessarily one that will core out with a particular knife. Once I have it the way I want it, I will get out the knives I have and look them over to decide which one is going to do the best job for this particular application. As has already been mentioned, I will lay that knife on the wood looking down from the top and visualize the way it is going to penetrate the blank and where it will end up. This is an estimate, but as you practice the technique, you will gain in accuracy.

It has been my experience that the steeper the sides of the bowl, the smaller the core is going to be relative to the next largest bowl. If the bowl is very shallow, you can get more cores that are closer in size. Again, if you take a core that is different in shape than the main bowl, it is going to be significanly smaller as well. Once I have selected the knife and estimated the angle, I proceed to core the blank. If I want more cores, I repeat the process. I will humbly suggest an article I wrote a while ago on coring bowls which is on my website. The link is below. Good luck with it, and if you have more questions, I will be glad to try and answer them.

Bill


Coring Bowls

Re: McNaughton System question

#7

Re: McNaughton System question

Joe Flemig

>Ron,

I just sent you an article I wrote in "More Woodturning" a couple of years ago. It explains the tricks.

Also, some suggested pulling on the handle. Doing so will cause the blades to bend and will cause the blade to drift "out". In other words, the radius of the kerf will increase risking a cut-through in the lower section of the bowl.

McNaughtons are designed to be pushed parallel with the handle, into the wood. Wiggling the handle back and forth is not recommended by McNaughton or their North American representative Greg Jensen. Making two overlapping, side-by-side cuts will make a wider kerf that is easier to clear of chips.

Joe FLeming - San Diego