Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Expert Recommendations Needed

Posts

Expert Recommendations Needed

#1

Expert Recommendations Needed

George (Oxford, NC)

>First, I have never done turning. I have a chance (if it is still available) to get a HF 34706 3/4HP 12" swing with additional scroll chuck (whatever that is and extra faceplates) for $180. I had been looking at a new Rikon mini, �HP, 12" swing at $250. I will probably not (in the beginning) be turning massive bowls etc. Should I buy the full size lathe used or a new Rikon?

This has to go into a small area. My shop is 16 x 24 and I already have a tablesaw w/fixed outfeed table, DC, 14" BS, 6"jointer, 12�"planer, DP, router table, �" shaper, 6x48/9" disc sanding station, 1x42/6" disc sander, full sized bench and a wall bench.

George

Re: Expert Recommendations Needed

#2

Re: Expert Recommendations Needed *LINK*

georgetroy

>Hi George to George,

I would recommend a Nova DVR or Nova 3000 for a small shop. You have a 16" swing, tilt head. You can add beds. 1 1/4" x 8 spindle thread, which is common through out the Industry. The Nova is made in NZ and fully backed up by the factory. Listing the web site for the Nova. As soon as you get a smaller lathe you will wish you had a big one. Been there and done that over 20 years ago. GT


Nova Web Site

Re: Expert Recommendations Needed

#3

JL

Re: Expert Recommendations Needed

JL

>It all depends on what you want to do. Minis are good lathes, but your spindle length (16") and bowl width are limited. I don't know if bed extensions are available for the Rikon like they are for the Jet. If you want to turn longer or wider, other lathes are prefered - such as the Nova.

Re: Expert Recommendations Needed

#4

Re: Expert Recommendations Needed

John Lucas

>George I think I would go for the HF. That sounds like a good price. I did a quick search to find out what lathe that is and found several people speaking highly of it. The Rikon I saw looked very good but I've never turned on one so I can't tell you how good it might be. I'm sure it will take up less space. The HF is a full size lathe and will probably be 4 to 4 1/2 feet long. However it will be longer before you outgrow it because it is larger. I don't know which chuck came with it but even the cheapest ones are $40 and they go up to $250.

Re: Expert Recommendations Needed

#5

Re: Expert Recommendations Needed

RussFairfield

>From the tool list, you seem to be set up for making furniture. For that reason alone, the Harbor Freight might be the better choice for you. Should you choose not to become addicted to turning round things, and that does happen, it will be useful for turning table legs and other spindle parts for furniture. Add a shop built table and a faceplate and you will have a very useful 12" variable speed disc sander

If you become adicted to turning wood, I don't think it matters which one you bought. You will be wanting a bigger and better lathe within a year.

Re: Expert Recommendations Needed

#6

Re: Expert Recommendations Needed

LT

>I have that exact HF lathe. It was my entry point into turning and I've had it about two years. So far, so good. If you plan on turning bowls, you will definately want to add some weight to it. Also, make sure that the headstock and tailstock line up.

At some point, (money permitting) I will upgrade to a bigger/better lathe. So far, the HF lathe has served me well and was a relatively inexpensive way to get into turning. Hope this helps.

LT

Re: Expert Recommendations Needed

#7

Re: Expert Recommendations Needed

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Get a bigger lathe. You've got lots of room in that shop. If the paths of most of the experts on this forum are typical, you soon won't be needing anything else except the bandsaw and grinder. You'll keep your chainsaw, gasoline, chaps, etc., and a can of Anchorseal in the car, so they won't take up any room in the shop.

Tongue in cheek

Re: Expert Recommendations Needed

#8

Re: Expert Recommendations Needed

George Fitzpatrick - Springfield MA

>No expert here, but my 2cents...

I started with a delta midi lathe. I am only doing smaller projects, small bowls, bud vases, pens and the like. But I reasoned that with the smaller lather, I would be limited to smaller turnings. My thinking was that as a beginner, I would not be tempted to do something too large before I had some learned some good basics. Semms a little safer, somehow.

If you go with the smaller lathe, I agree that within a year, you will develop "lathe envy" and start looking at the full size lathes.

That's my plan, and I will keep my midi lathe for smaller projects.

geofitz13

maker of fine sawdust