Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Shavings and Flower Beds

Posts

Shavings and Flower Beds

#1

Ric Taylor

Shavings and Flower Beds

Ric Taylor

>I've been thinking about the discussions below regarding spreading shavings in flower beds. I've been doing this for years, although I must admit that I'm sometimes disappointed with my flowers. Sometimes, not always. Maybe it will help to say that I turn dry wood, not green.

I understand why some people advocate not using shavings in the yard under the theory that the shavings draw nitrogen from the soil. What I don't understand is, how is this any different from putting mulch on the flowerbeds? In my part of the country, mulch is usually pretty fresh pine bark, or some shredded pine. It seems to me that the mulch would have the same effect as the shavings.

Composting is not an option for me. Any thoughts?

Thanks,

Ric

Re: Shavings and Flower Beds

#2

Re: Shavings and Flower Beds

Tom MacGregor

>The type of shavings can effect the ph of your soil, and some - walnut in particular - are toxic to other plants. I imagine it depends on both what plants you're growing and what woods you're working.

Re: Shavings and Flower Beds

#3

Re: Shavings and Flower Beds

adrien

>it's my understanding that wood chips make fine mulch, to keep plants from drying out, but in order to compost them and turn them into a sort of fertilizer, one should add nitrogen. e.g., manure!

Re: Shavings and Flower Beds

#4

Re: Shavings and Flower Beds

Ed Karch in No.VA

>The layer of mulch next to the soil is where the material breaks down. at this layer there needs to be a balance between carbon and nitrogen to support the microorganism that do the work. If you work the shavings into the soil this results in a large charge of carbon and the microorganisms in an attempt to do all the work at once depletes the available nitrogen leaving a shortage of nitrogen for feeding plants. After the microoganisms have depleted their food (chips) they die off incteasing the nitrogen level and the C/N ratio goes back to normal. If you want mulch to hold the moisture use your chips. You can place som high nitrogen down before spreading mulch if you need lots of greenery. Flowering is more dependent on good levels of phosphorus.I uesw chips both as mulch and worked in to increase organic material and help loosen clay soil.

Re: Shavings and Flower Beds

#5

JL

Re: Shavings and Flower Beds

JL

>How about some nitrogen-phosphorus fertilizer? Also, check the pH balance. You may be running a trace acidic. A good "bellwether" plant that acts as a pH indicator is a hydrangea. (Blue means acidic soil and pink means neutral to basic soil). Of course you have to like hydrangeas.

Re: Shavings and Flower Beds

#6

Re: Shavings and Flower Beds

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>You wrote:

"What I don't understand is, how is this any different from putting mulch on the flowerbeds? In my part of the country, mulch is usually pretty fresh pine bark, or some shredded pine. It seems to me that the mulch would have the same effect as the shavings. "

Pine bark is not as inclined to decompose as quickly as shavings do thus the nitrogen demand does not have the same effect. It also does not pack as do shavings and sawdust. The packing leads to mold and less air.

Re: Shavings and Flower Beds

#7

Ric Taylor

Thanks for Everyones' Comments

Ric Taylor

>