Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

turning table base question

Posts

turning table base question

#1

turning table base question

ken chase

>If I attempt to turn two rather large bases to support a

glass table top. What should I expect to happen as normal

distortion occurs. Iknow how bowls behave as they dry but

acvice here is really needed.

Thanks

Re: turning table base question

#2

Re: turning table base question

John Lucas

>Ken Let us know a little more information. Are you turning it out of solid wood or segmented wood. It will move either way but will move differently.

Re: turning table base question

#3

Re: turning table base question

ken chase

>Sorry. Most likely fairly green mesquite which is plentiful where I live in Palm Desert CA.

Re: turning table base question

#4

Re: turning table base question

John Lucas

>Mesquite is supposedly one of the most stable woods we can turn. I don't get to turn much of it around here. There are probably tables somewhere on the web that will give you the percentage of wood movement although Ithink it would be minimal in Mesquite. I only have tables for the commmon woods around here.

Re: turning table base question

#5

Re: turning table base question

ken chase

>Thanks John:

I'm thinking if over time there was warpage and the pieces leaned a bit I could flatten the tops without too much trouble. An, if necessary, the same with the bottoms. Have I missed anything? What do you think?

Re: turning table base question

#6

Re: turning table base question

John Lucas

>Ken I just looked through all the books Ihave and don't have specks on Mesquite. Hopefully someone else will have something. I found a few mentions on the web about mesquite having almost no movement but they didn't give any refernces.

Re: turning table base question

#7

Re: turning table base question

JKJ in East TN

>Ken,

First of all, is your wood prosopis juliflora (neltuma juliflora) or prosopis glandulosa?

As ususal, there seems to be a lot of common name confusion between references. The first is referred to in my references as mesquite, common mesquite, honey locust, western honey mesquite, velvet mesquite, algarobo, and honey pod, mesquito, mesquitebaum, prosopis common, and baya hon ("Useful Woods of the World" and "The Woodbook"). The second is referred to as mesquite, honey locust, ironwood, or algaroba ("World Woods in Color"). Both are described has having the same physical and rot resistant properties, the same habitat and range in southwestern US, Mexico, and South America, and appear to have the same leaf and pod structure (from the above references plus "Audabon Field Guide to NA Trees" and Peterson's "Eastern Trees").

Does anyone know if these scientific names actually refer to the same species?

"Useful Woods of the World" describes the shrinkage of prosopis glandulosa as 1.6% radial, 3.2% tangential, and 4.8% volumetric (green to oven dry). If that is correct for your wood, the absolute shrinkage is quite small (1/2 to 1/4) compared to the common commercial species listed by Hoadley in "Understanding Wood".

However, the T/R of 2.0 is close to that reported by as Quaking Aspen, Butternut, Black Cherry, Hackberry, and Sweetgum (all 1.9), Catalpa, Chestnut, American Hornbeam, and Red Maple (all 2.0), and American Holly, Sugar Maple, and Red Oak (all 2.1). This seems to indicates that something built from a single piece can still distort significantly, especially in RH conditions found in your area.

I'm having trouble picturing your design. As Sir Lucas mentioned, much depends on the geometry of how your object is designed. Is it made from solid pieces or segmented (glued-up from smaller pieces)? You mentioned you are concerned that the pieces might lean a bit - most wood does not bow much while drying unless it is reaction wood or if it is a board or beam cut off-axis or through twisting grain. What will be the orientation of the grain in the wood? There is almost no shrinkage along the grain in most wood species (Hoadley reports about 0.1%) so that dimension should be very stable even if using freshly cut green wood, except for juvenile or reaction wood.

I don't thing you have provided enough information. You might post a simple sketch of your design showing the orientation of the grain. That way, someone here might be able to offer some specific advice.

For the long term, I would also highly recommend R. Bruce Hoadley's book "Understand Wood" which has excellent information on how wood shrinks and how to deal with it.

JKJ

Re: turning table base question

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: turning table base question

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Ken, I don't think the columns you describe will have a problem with warpage, as the end-grain will be supporting the table top. I cannot picture how the columns alone will provide enough support without an added piece top and bottom, as the whole assemmbly will tend to topple over. Yes, a photo will help!

Re: turning table base question

#9

Re: turning table base question

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>If you use 3 points of contact for supporting the top, and for the base, you shouldn't have to be concerned with warping. I don't know what specifically you want to do, but this 3-point principle can work with just about any design you come up with.

Re: turning table base question

#10

Re:Thanks All for help

ken chase

>I haven't actually even acquired the material or drawn a plan.

I do now envision a horizontal turned piece tenoned into each

pedestal for support. I expect the design will in many ways resemble the shape of a wineglass, but with more thickness in the center,

Appreciate the comments

Re: turning table base question

#11

Re: turning table base question

John Lucas

>Ken 3 points will always sit flat now matter what, but I prefer 4 points,I think It's more stable. This does bring up a good point. If you make little feet, even a 1/2" or so, if the wood does warp it's very easy to remove a tiny bit from 1 or 2 feet to bring the whole thing back to level.

Re: turning table base question

#12

Re: turning table base question

The Wood Spinner / Bill Hale

>Ken, I also have no specs but I do turn a lot of mesquite. When green cut the moisture can be low or very high depending on where you get it. Most of mine comes from residential landscapes and is wet. Desert cut can be quite low.

What are your plans for construction or are you going to spindle turn it? If you are spindle turning I would think it is wood from a landscape.

Large pieces of mesquite will split as they dry.

If you want more info give me a call 520-836-3044 7pm is best time to get me.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: turning table base question

#13

Re: turning table base question

The Wood Spinner / Bill Hale

>JKJ

Most likley his wood will be Prosopis velutina if it is native. Honey mesquite limits its western movement close to Casa Grande, AZ. where I live. The only reason it is here is the cattle being trucked from Texas bring the seeds and plant them along the highway.

The common landscape verity is a Prosopis hybrid we call "chilean".

The native velutina is going to be much tighter in growth ring size.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: turning table base question

#14

Re: turning table base question *LINK*

JKJ in East TN

>>Prosopis velutina

This is in none of my books, but well described on the web. Prosopis velutina is supposed to be the largest of the mesquites. As for the shrinkage properties, I suspect that all of the species are probably similar.

The more I look at mesquite, the more confused the literature is. I see references to

1) prosopis glandulosa

2) prosopis pubescens

3) prosopis juliflora

4) Prosopis velutina

It is the common names that confuse things. For example different references list #1 is listed as honey mesquite but #3 is sometimes called western honey mesquite. #3 and #4 are both called common mesquite. #2 is screwbean mesquite. #4 seems to be most often called velvet mesquite or Arizona mesquite, although #1 is also called velvet mesquite in some places. This is almost as bad as "ironwood" - I read once that there were at least 20 different species referred to locally as ironwood in different places. The more I study wood and tree ID, the more I wish everyone would always use the scientific names!

I did find a bit more discussion about the stability of mesquite, link below. This is concerning sawing for lumber, but perhaps it will still be interesting. One person mentioned that if the wood was not fully dried, it may distort significantly.

JKJ


Sawing and drying mesquite

Re: turning table base question

#15

Re: turning table base question

ken chase

>Thanks John. Good idea.

Re: turning table base question

#16

Re: turning table base question

Ed Karch in No.VA

>Yes there are many different Prosopis species and you could place all the common names in a bowl and drawm at random and that would be the local name some where. One of the more interesting for juliflora I ran onto in Senegal was Dakar toubab. translation from Wolof is whiteman's tamrind. both juliflora and tamarind were exotics in Senegal where the local Prosopis is P.Africana.