Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Is there a "clear" oil finish?

Posts

Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#1

Is there a "clear" oil finish?

Carole in VA

>That will not darken light woods? Or that an impossible quest? Are there some oils that have less of a darkening effect than others? The ones I have seen all seem to have the same amber tint. Also, it seems that higher I go with the sanding grits, the less effect the oil has on the color. Is this my imagination or is it maybe because it can't penetrate as deepely on a highly sanded ( micro mesh) piece?

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#2

Sorry no help, but interested also.

DougJ in Crawfordsville, IN

>I'll be watching this thread with great interest.

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#3

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

Sean Troy

>I would say mineral oil is the clearest of the oils with the least amount of yellowing if any at all. Sean

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#4

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

georgetroy

>Twenty years ago Dale Nish showed me a finish which will help keep your wood from darken. It is still true today. We applied a heavy coat of Deft Clear wood finish, wiped it off and immediately applied Antique Min Wax oil. Urethane oil and Min Wax Tung Oil finish also works. Give it a try and see what happens. GT

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#5

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

RussFairfield

>There is no easy answer. All oil finishes impart some degree of amber to the wood.

Tung Oil doesn't get as dark or as fast as Linseed Oil or the other finishing oils.

Sanding to a finer grit reduces the penetration of the finish into the wood, and that also keeps it clearer longer.

Sealing the wood with lacquer before application of an oil finish limits penetration and keeps the finish clearer longer.

If you are using an oil finish with varnish resins, then avoid Polyurethane finishes. Poly turns a darker orange faster than phenolic or alkyd varnish resins.

Doing all 4 imparts the least color to the wood by the oil finish.

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#6

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

Carole in VA

>George, isn't the Deft Clear finish a lacquer? I can't use lacquer until spring. Too cold in my shop and I am not about to use it in my house since it really makes me ill. If i used it in the house I would probably have to wear my respirator for hours!

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#7

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

Carole in VA

>Thanks, Russ. I have been sorting through your finishing articles and that's about what I figured out from reading, but you summarized it very well in your post.

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#8

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>This is a problem I faced with the holly bowls. I now use a water based poly that is quite thin. I let as much soak into the wood as I could and then wiped it off. The next day I sanded the raised grain with 450 grit paper and applies and wiped. After it dried I buffed. Holly doesn't have much character to hide so the poly works well.

I tried the same thing with a wine glass stem I turned out of cherry and was not happy with the results.

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#9

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

John Lucas

>Russ can you clear something up for me. I've never used oil over another finish. It just never occured to me to try it. I usually do the opposite. I thought oil finishes was used to "pop" the figure in the wood or to be used as an easily repairable finish. I have also used it in different mixes to produce a wipe on finish. What would be the advantage of using an oil finish over a finish that doesn't penetrate such as lacquer, varnish or Poly. Thanks John

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#10

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

John Lucas

>Carol I have the same problem in the winter. I don't spray the lacquer in the winter. I thin it about 50 percent with lacquer thinner and wipe it on, let it sit for 10 or 15 seconds and wipe it off. I'll do this several times. If it seems to get streaky I thin it more. This is not a high build finish but if you buff it with the Beal system looks very nice and protects the wood pretty well.

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#11

Re: Oil over lacquer

RussFairfield

>Oil over lacquer does sound to be going in the opposite direction but there are several benefits.

The lacquer is used as a sealer, and than means IN the wood, with no film on the surface. The advantage of the lacquer sealer is that there is no blotching in the end-grain areas, and the oil builds faster because there is no wait for the penetrated oil to cure. You still get all of the advantages of an oil finish, but none of the disadvantages of a lacquer. There is less color change over time because there is no oil IN the wood, and the oil keeps the lacquer from turning orange with age.

As for popping the grain picture, lacquer on wood that is sanded to 1200-grit or higher will do as good or better a job of accenting the grain as any oil finish. There may be a better explanation, but I see it as that lacquer accents the wood grain by changes in reflectivity, while oil does it by changes in color. For that reason, oil can accent the grain on a much rougher wood surface. Reflectivity wins that race every time.

I used this same finish on tall clocks for many years. I was always amused by how many folks, some who were famous for their furniture, would admire the brightness and grain under my finishes, ask me how I did it, and then tell me that I couldn't do that.

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#12

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

RussFairfield

>The waterborne finish imparts no color to the wood, and it changes color the least of any finish over time. That is a good thing when you want to keep the whiteness of Holly. That is not a good thing for highly figured woods because there is no color change to accent the grain.

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#13

Re: Oil over lacquer

Ed Moore

>Deft sanding sealer is lacquer based and it is very easy to spray on and wipe off. Would this probably work as well as the straight or thinned lacquer from Deft?

Would General Seal-A-Cell be a good finish to apply over the wipe-coat of lacquer?

Since you have told us about it, I assume that the finish that you described has been durable.

Ed

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#14

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>As you probably know we used to install high end custom floors; now we just make them (installing is hard on "old knees").:-) Our finishes of choice are either Velvit Oil or a DuraSeal oil/wax. We installed a wide board (mostly 8" and wider), flat sawn, white oak floor for some friends. They wanted the oak to remain "bright". The only way to do this was with a water base poly. The floor was installed at least 5 years ago and still to this day has stayed light.

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#15

What I do *LINK*

TD

>Carole, this is what I do:

Start using the oil with 100 or 120 grit wet/dry sandpaper and continue using it until it starts coming through the other side of the wood, then do the same from the other side. This gives you full penetration of the wood so you will never be able to sand or polish through your finish.

Wipe dry with a paper towel.

Let cure for several days. Notice I said "cure", not "dry".

After the oil has cured, sand with 150 grit, wipe off, sand with 220, wipe off, sand with 320, wipe off, sand with 400 and wipe off.

Let cure for a week.

Repeat process with starting with 400 or 600 and then 800, 1000, 1200, 1500, wiping dry between grits. Let cure for a week.

The final sanding is done with water instead of oil (it is thinner). Sand with 2000 and then 2500. Let dry thoroughly. wipe or spray a final thin coat of oil and do not wipe off. This will give you a very nice gloss finish or a frosty looking finish. If you get the gloss the first time you are lucky. If you get the frost you must steel-wool it off and repeat. If you find out what causes the frost please let me know. I eventually get a finish that looks like lacquer but sometimes it takes a long time to get there. On my cheaper pieces I will use an oil with resins to quicken the process but on my collectible pieces I stay with the Watco Danish Oil all the way. When properly done this finish is 99.9% "in the wood" and my customers are willing to pay for the extra effort required to get it. For some reason unknown to me the gloss oil finish does not show fingerprints like a gloss lacquer; perhaps Russ can tell us why? On average I would say that my finish probably takes about 4 or 5 times longer than the lathe time. Obviously, you cannot use this finish on $50 items. I normally only offer a gloss oil finish on items that will sell for $300 or more. A satin oil finish can be done much quicker and looks plenty good for most buyers. And yes, it will turn the wood a bit amber but I get no complaints on that, even on boxelder.

TD


http://www.theoldrebelworkshop.org

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#16

Wood Pre Seal - "clear" oil finish? *LINK*

georgetroy

>Yes Deft Clearwood finish is a lacquer. Highland Hardware has a Water base Hydrocote Wood Pre-Seal. I also use this product for a primer before I use an Oil base finish. This product seems to keep the wood light. In the search for a perfect just right finish, you can try this. Price is only $7.99 per quart. I wait overnight before applying the oil finish. GT


Highland Hardware Wood Pre-Seal

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#17

George Balock

Re: What I do

George Balock

>Carole,

A friend reccomended teak oil for oily woods. I used it on a tasmanian olive platter and it hardly had any yellowing--so far. My friend uses it on woods like cocbolo with good results.

George

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#18

Re: Oil over lacquer

John Lucas

>Thanks Russ. I guess I just didn't know exactly what an oil finish does. It seems like it may just be a thinner form of a hardening finish. I just assumed you used an oil finish when you wanted to penetrate the wood. It never really occured to me that it could be used over another finish.

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#19

Re: Oil over lacquer

RussFairfield

>A lot of folks use sanding sealers and swear by them. I don't use sanding sealers because they are a finish that has something in them to make them easier to sand. That something is usually opaque in the can, and that means it is opaque on the wood. I am trying to accent and brighten the grain picture, not cover it up.

That's my opinion and I know there are lot of folks who will disagree with me.

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#20

Re: Oil over lacquer

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I learned from Dale Nish many years ago about using a couple of coats of semi-gloss Deft on soft spalted wood. The first coat thinned with lacquer thinner. Both coats applied very liberally, then wiped off. This is followed by as many coats of Daly's Ben Matte Danish oil as needed. I have a couple of pieces that I used this method on about 20 years ago. I recently polished them with the Beall system. They ended up looking like new.

Wally

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#21

Re: Oil over lacquer

John Lucas

>Russ I may be wrong but I think that it is Zinc Stearate which is a white opaque powder. It's supposed to keep the finish from clogging the sandpaper. We used to use it to polish the drum on copiers when I did copier repair.

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#22

Yes, almost!

Earl Eyre

>Russ mentioned the waterborne finishes. Gives those a try. They are almost foolproof and leave very little color. I used to make skin-on-frame kayaks and started using that exclusively on the "skin" made from heavy white nylon because it kept the fabric perfectly white and clear. It goes on milky but will turn very clear on drying. I have a large can that I bought several years ago and it still works great. It will raise the grain slightly so you will have to sand lightly after the first coat and apply at least one more coat. Buffs beautifully.

Earl

Re: Is there a "clear" oil finish?

#23

Re: Yes, almost!

Carole in VA

>I may give them a try. I was at Bruce Hoover's shop yesterday and he said he uses a water based lacquer. I was surprised that it did not have any of the blueish tint I had noticed with the only water based product I had ever tried (but I think that was a cheap water based poly on something that needed a hard coat of protection.) I can't for the life of me remember what the brand was that he uses though. I'll have to ask him again.