Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

WC Turning Exchange Update

Posts

WC Turning Exchange Update

#1

WC Turning Exchange Update

David Propst

>We now have 88 signed up for the exchange game!

See the rules below. I think I have listed everyone who has e-mailed.

The deadline to join is Nov. 30. I will match up the names and e-mail them within a couple of days after that. I'll post when I do so everyone knows to check their e-mail.

As the administrator for this, I have tried to figure out how I can play and not know who was sending me a turning. If someone has an idea let me know. If I do know I promise it will be a random pick.

  • To enter, please e-mail me with your name and address.

  • The deadline to join is Nov 30

  • Turnings should be received by the week of Jan 15-21. Plan your mailing accordingly!

  • This is a fun exchange of turnings between friends, not an exchange of comparative value items or a contest.

  • All turnings are welcome: pens, hollowforms, bowls, stoppers, candlesticks, etc.


  • We have several international participants. If you do not wish to incur the added expense of mailing an international package let me know and I'll accomodate when matching names.








Kurt Aebi

Richard Allen

Charles Anderson

Chris Andrew

Mike Andriacco

Steven Antonucci

Matt Birchfield

Lan Brady

Harvey Brooks

Cody Carse

Jorge Castaneda

David Chung

Spencer Cone

Wayne Cooper

Mike Cunningham

Terry Daniel

Dennis Daudelin

Ed Davidson

Ken DeMarco

Wally Dickerman

Jamie Donaldson

e

Ronny Eelen

Earl Erye

Gary Evans

Russ Fairfield

George Fitzpatrick

Aaron A. Gesicki

Barbara Gill

Scott Greaves



Dominic Greco

Bill Grumbine

Ken Grunke

Bob Hackett

Bill Hale

Dick Hines

Phil Joines

Frank Joseph

Ed Karch

Mark Kauder

Pete Kekel

Ed Kelle

Tony Kennick

Jay Kilpatrick

Kurt O. Krauter

Chris Kuehn

Greg Kulibert

John Lucas

Bill MacLachlan

Bobby McCarley

James McClure

Bernie McGivern

Gerry Meekins

Harvey Meyer

Doug Miller

Ed Moore

Pat Mulligan

Stephen Mushinski

Ruth Niles

Raymond Overman



Dave Peebles

Paul Porter

David Propst

Jim Pugh

Terry Quiram

David Ramer

Mac Ray

Chris Rolke

Ron Sardo

Jack Savona

Juergen Schleicher

Barry Scotton

Jim Shaver

Dale Sherman

Jennifer Shirley

Michael Sinclair

Dave Smith

Bert Smith

Colin Spencer

Stephen Stokes

Jeff Theil

Keith Tompkins

Doug Trembath

Carole Valentine

Brad Vietje

Molly Winton

Mark Wollschlager

Keith Zimmerman

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

#2

close your eyes

John Lucas

>

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

#3

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

chris rolke

>as far as your question of how you can play

have a 3rd party (perferably someone who does not know much about turning) choose the names

will we be paired up or will it be a setup where you send a turning to 1 person and get someing from a different person ?

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

#4

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

Rick Allen

>How about asking Ernie how he does the Secret Santa selection.

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

#5

88 slips of paper *LINK*

Raymond Overman in SC

>Draw two at a time and pair em' up. If we end up with an odd number of people after the stragglers sign up then three people are in one group. First one drawn sends to second, second sends to third, third sends to first. Easy peasy.

You could also number your list, generate a random number, and use that as your primer for pairs.

88 people

85 is your random number

1 is paired with 85

2 is paired with 86

3 is paired with 87

4 is paired with 88

5 is paired with 84

6 is paired with 83

etc.

With a Secret Santa format you just draw out of the hat with your list of names. If you happen to draw your own name, it goes back in the hat.

My understanding though was this was going to be a paired exchange so if I draw David Propst, I send him a turning and he sends me one. I'm looking forward to emailing and visiting with someone I'm sending my piece and recieving a piece from(hence exchange) if that's the format that this will follow.


Random Number

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

#6

Random Exchange Each Way

David Propst

>Hey,

My thoughts were it was going to be a random exchange each way, not a pairing between two turners. If there are opinions either way let me know.

For the scientific selection process, my 7 year old daughter is going to draw names from two bowls.

David

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

#7

Re: Random Exchange Each Way

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>The random part sounds good, but what if there's an odd number?

Rather than pairing up from 2 bowls, draw from just one bowl. The first draw gets the second draw's piece, second gets third, etc and last gets first.

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

#8

That works..Thanks Ken

David Propst

>

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

#9

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

Ed Moore

>David,

You stated that it would be random each way, meaning that no pair would exchange. That was my understanding when I signed up. Remember, I was one who was concerned about inequities. Random each way reduces that concern.

JMHO,

Ed Moore

SW VA

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

#10

Re: 88 slips of paper

Ed Moore

>Raymond,

I like your random number generator. Assume that there are 88 names and that you generate a random list of the numbers 1,... ,88. Suppose further that the first three numbers on the random list are 47, 58, 4. Then:

1 sends a gift to 47, 2 sends a gift to 58, and 3 sends a gift to 4, and so on.

If 7 sends a gift to 7, then swap numbers with #6 or something.

Ed

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

#11

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

Lan Brady

>I agree with Ed, I hope it is not paired. But, I will participate no matter which. It is a great idea.

David, I cannot imagine you not participating after doing all this work. Any way you select for yourself is fine.

Good luck to everyone! Lan

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

#12

I agree, it is random, not paired.

David Propst

>

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

#13

Easy way to do it

Earl Eyre

>I can't add anything new. All the options have been given but for my 2 cents worth it's very simple. One bowl. Draw one name. Then #2. #1 sends to #2; draw #3, #2 send to #3 and just keep going. #88 sends to #1. Just throw your name into the pot. You're right, though, you will know who is sending to you but that can't be help.

If you do get some straglers after you have drawn names and still want to include them, then just start at your name, and have stragler #1 send to who you were going to send, stragler #2 send to Stragler #1, etc. Nobody else will be the wiser.

I don't envy you, though. That's alot of names to draw, send emails to, etc. Thanks for doing it. It will be worth it even though some of us are scared to death we are going to have to send to one of the well known, experienced turners.

Thanks!

Earl

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

#14

Re: WC Turning Exchange Update

Juergen

>I vote for totally random