Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Bagging Rough-outs

Posts

Bagging Rough-outs

#1

Bagging Rough-outs

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

>Just started turning. Got some free freshly cut bigleaf maple and roughed out the bowls. Was told not to put them in paper bags as this promotes spalting. Others say to use paper bags. What should I do if I don't want spalting nor splitting? Bowls are stored in an unheated shed out of drafts and sunlight.

Re: Bagging Rough-outs

#2

Re: Bagging Rough-outs

Fog Tanner

>I put them in paper bags to slow down the drying and checking. I don't really care to turn spalted wood, although I do get some periodcily. I store the bags in a low shelf or floor in an area that is calm. After some period of time, which will depend on where you live, I remove them and put them in cardboard boxes, face down. Rotate the stacks from one box to the next every month, so that you get the top on the bottom and vice versa. This can take 6 months to a year depending on size of bowl and where you live (relative humidity).

I have also stacked bowls face down in a cardboard box layering it with shavings and left it that way for seven months. I had no problems with this method either. The shavings are just to slow down the drying rate. After seven months I fished the bowls out, removed the saw dust and placed them back in and set them off to the side. This Decemeber or Janurary I'll return and finish them, that will have been a year or more.

These are just two of the many ways to dry your rough outs, there are many more that will be posted. All work for those that use them, just try them and see what works in your part of the world.

Fog

Re: Bagging Rough-outs

#3

Re: Bagging Rough-outs

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>For many years I've used Johnson's Paste wax for protecting rough turned bowls and vessels. I date them, then very liberally coat them with the wax. If I think that it's necessary, I apply a second coat later. If I'm turning a wood that's very prone to cracking, such as fruit woods, I put the piece in a paper bag for a month or so. I've had great sucess using this method and I live in hot dry Arizona.

The photo shows around 70 pieces, all coated with the wax, and in various stages of drying. None are cracked.

Wally


img

Re: Bagging Rough-outs

#4

JL

Re: Bagging Rough-outs

JL

>Wally, do you stack them that way (mouth over mouth) to slow the drying?

Re: Bagging Rough-outs

#5

Brad Vietje

Re: Bagging Rough-outs

Brad Vietje

>Doug,

I agree with the paper bag advice you've gotten so far. I suspect your informant meant plastic bags to encourage spalting (careful not to go too far), followed by paper bags for slow, crack-free or crack-reduced drying. I also use the smeared paste wax method that Wally mentions, but use neither method exclusively. Once I move into my new house/barn/shop, I'll probably standardize the process a little more.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Bagging Rough-outs

#6

Re: Bagging Rough-outs

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Actually, I don't think that it makes any difference. I just stack them 2 or 3 high to gain space. No wax goes inside bowls or vessels.

The photo is in John Jordan's recent video on wood.

Wally

Re: Bagging Rough-outs

#7

Re: Bagging Rough-outs

Doug Trembath

>Doug, I think you have gotten good advice so far, but each of the responses is the experience of folks in differing climates and diferent experience levels. I personally believe that the success factor in successful drying of roughouts has much more to do with the grain orientation than the drying methods. I also think it contributes strongly to the varying results folks post on the different drying methods. If you rough out a piece which has grain oriented such that the drying induced stresses are uniform, you can normally throw them in a corner where the airflow is restricted, and a few months later they're warped, but not cracked. Obviously there are some really troublesome timbers, as well, and they deserve, and demand special treatment. Lots of methods have been devised to make it either faster or more reliable, such as boiling,(which does work very well in my experience), Bagging, (which has been less effective for me), alcohol drying, (which along with dishwashing liquid soaking I don't even try), etc. Folks have luck of varying degrees of success with all of these. I just rough them out with the grain oriented such that I even out the stresses, with most indigenous timbers, throw them in a corner for a couple of months, then move them to my shed, where they stack up until I get in the mood to finish turn them. I probably haven't lost five in the five years since I moved here to SW Pennsylvania. In the end, what you will find is that you will need to experiment with a lot of different methods, and find one that works for you. The important message is not to be in too big a hurry, however. As I have heard, and have often said, it's the journey that counts, not the destination.

Good luck with it,

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods