tenon or recess
Pat
>What is the prefered method to hold bowl in chuck, tenon or recess?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
tenon or recess
Pat
>What is the prefered method to hold bowl in chuck, tenon or recess?
Tenon
John Trant (Baltimore/DC corridor)
>
Re: tenon or recess
The Wood Spinner / Bill Hale
>Tenon
When I started, years ago, used recess and tended to blow out as I worked the piece. The tenon has a better grip.
After rgh. turning and cure the tenon is easier to reshape round.
Good turning and be safe
Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.
Re: tenon or recess
JKJ in East TN
>Outward force in a recess can pull the bowl apart, while inward force on a tenon compresses the fibers and can be stronger. I think the recess is good for plates/platters with plenty of wood in a large foot. If the recess can be left in the piece as a design element, it saves the effort of dealing with a glue block.
JKJ
tenon
Norm Smith in Nova Scotia
>
Re: tenon or recess
John Lucas
>I'm a tenon person. I always reshape my foot to whatever works for that bowl. If I have a recess I am limited on what I can do. Since the tenon sticks out further than the foot will I have total design access.
Re: tenon or recess
Bill Neddow
>I agree with John. And if you are concerned about breaking the tendon off -- give the tendon end grain a squirt of CA glue. Wild horses will not tear it apart then.
Re: tenon or recess *LINK*
RussFairfield
>They both have their benefits and faults. I discussed them as I see them in an old post in this forum that has been preserved in an Article, also here on Wood Central.
Link to: "Recess or Spigot??"
Re: tenon or recess
Keith Tompkins
>I agree with everything here, but would add...if you employ a recess in your pieces, it should NOT affect the final shape or form. Otherwise, you will be eternally making forms with a footprint that is too large, out of proportion with the rest of the piece...platters may be the exception here.