Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

Posts

Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

#1

Keith Tompkins

Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

Keith Tompkins

>Which finish will hold up the longest? Although they all have their strong points, which will have the best appearance 20 or 30 years from now...or more?

Lacquer has great depth, but may lose flexability over time. Oil has a tendency to darken over time, but can easily be renewed. Poly? I don't know. I have seen antiques with a shellac finish that has endured for two hundred years.

I have been using more and more oil finishes lately rather than lacquer, which has been my mainstay for years. Any opinions welcome.

Re: Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

#2

Re: Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

Ad de Crom Netherlands

>Shellac is very good, you're right with the antique.

I use only a transparent lacquer "glitsa", after using oil in the beginning.

This glitsa is also used for the protection of tabletops as well as for furniture.

My experience with glitsa are very good

Re: Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

#3

Re: Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

RussFairfield

>I use the homebrew mix of equal parts 100% Pure Tung Oil, McCloskey's Gloss Spar Varnish (in the red can) and Turpentine (pure gum spirits) because it holds up better than anything I have used in the last 50+ years, either commercial or homebrew.

The Tung Oil doesn't get as dark or as fast as Boiled Linseed Oil or the Soybean Oil that is in a lot of the commercial oil finishes. There are more solids than any commercial finish and I can build a nice gloss with 6 coats, and a surface that is the equal of most high gloss lacquer in 10.

This is the only finish that I have ever used that will withstand the environment of the galleries for a year and still look good, and it is easilly repaired should it need it. Too many galleries are terrible with turned wood. They are too often too hot, too bright, too much sun, too dry, and those damn water art sculptures get water drops on everything. Customers who insist on tapping the wood with their fingernails and rings are always a problem. The oil/varnish finish is the only one that will survive this environment for me.

There is always somebody who claims that there is no such thing as 100% Pure Tung Oil, but if that is what it says on the can, that is close enough for me.

I have some bookcases that have a 120 year old shellac finish that still looks pretty good; but has started to deteriorate in the last 10 or so years. I have tried, but I have never been able to duplicate that durability in a shellac.

I have never had a high gloss lacquer that survived past 10 years under normal conditions. Air Conditioning and low humidity is the enemy of lacquer, and it will last twice as long when there is none.

There are a lot of claims being made for the modern finishing technology. It will have to be up to someone else to look back in 50 years, and see if they are all they are claimed to be. So far their record hasn't been that good.

Others may have longer experience and come to different conclusions, but these are mine.

Re: Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

#4

Re: Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

Bill Stehman

>Russ, I too like my own brew of your tung oil and spar varnish which seems to work best here on the desert because the spar varnish has ultra violet inhibiters slowing the color change of most woods. My $.02.

Re: Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

#5

Re: Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

Jerry from Lapel In.

>Russ: Do you spray or brush it on?

Re: Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

#6

Re: Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

Ron in Drums PA

>That sounds like the Rolls Royce of danish oil.

What is the shelf life of 100% pure tung oil? Does it gel like Waterlox?

Re: Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

#7

Re: Neither..........

RussFairfield

>Nither brush nor spray. I use it as a wipe-on finish, the same as Watco or similar products.

The shelf life of Tung Oil depends on the age of the oil in the can before we opened it. Some of this stuff has been sitting on a shelf for a long time before we buy it. The best mail-order supply that I have found is Swing Paints. They advertise ther on Wood Central and there is access to their website from the front page. The price is reasonable and their product is fresh. I recommend it.

I always try to use fresh Tung Oil, and I buy it once a year from Daly's Paints on Stone Way in Seattle, and always in quart cans. It is as fresh as the drum they are using to mix their finishes on that day. I am now using a can that had been opened, 1/2 used, and has sat in the back of the finishing cabinet since we moved here 4 years ago. Except for a slight darkening in color, there are no apparent signs of aging.

Shelf life of the mixed finish is 2, maybe 3, seasonal changes at best. That will usually be less, and how much less depends on the age of both the Tung Oil and the varnish and how long we have been using from the can when it was mixed.

Re: Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

#8

Re: Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

adrien

>Hey Russ,

You mention the deterioration of lacquer finishes in 10 years or so.

What kind of lacquer do the Japanes use on their wooden soup bowls? I've had mine for some fifty years now with very little change. I note that in museums the Japanese keep an open jar of water inside the display cases.

Re: Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac?

#9

Re: Lacquer-Poly-Oil-Shellac? *LINK*

RussFairfield

>My "10-years" comment applys to what we find in the can that we buy from the store. The Japan lacquer (Urushi) is a complex finish that is made from a tree sap. The only property they share is a glossy surface, and from that comes the common name they share. Other than that, they are totally different.

The link has some introductory information on Urushi.


Urushi