Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

Posts

Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

#1

Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

Dawn Adams

>I have a VERY NICE friend who offered to build a cabinet bowl drying kiln for me out of a cabinet/light/computer fan (like the one on woodturningonline.com). I am wondering if I want to try drying my bowls using a kiln like this, or would it be easier to just use an alcohol drying method (soak in detured alcohol, then wrap outside in paper)? Anybody have experience in both who can compare the results and ease of use? Any information would be much appreciated.

Thanks!

Re: Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

#2

Re: Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Dawn, when I first started turning I built a kiln from an old freezer. I discovered that it worked best when I filled it all at once. I used it for awhile but then it fell into disuse. Maybe it was because it was not at my shop.

I dry most of my bowls using the paper bag and AnchorSeal method. I use the alcohol soak for those items I want to dry fast either because of a time factor or because to dry slowly might mean a loss of white (holly).

I also use boiling when I have a bowl that I expect might crack.

Don't turn down an addition to your shop. You might find that like me you will use many methods of drying.

Re: Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

#3

Re: Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

JKJ in East TN

>Dawn,

I've been researching kilns both for drying lumber and turnings. I worry about the simplistic "trial and error" drying schedule described in the article you mentioned.

The art and science of kiln drying is well evolved. To dry wood without internal checking, "case hardening", excessive splits, and other defects you have to carefully monitor and control both the temperature and humidity in the kiln and montitor the moisture content of the wood during the run. There are complex schedules that specify the rates, but they are geared towards 1" and 2" lumber. The schedules assume that all the wood in one load is the same type (with the same drying properties) so mixing species could be a problem. It is also assumed that all wood loaded into the kiln is at the same approximate moisture content - if you put wet wood in with partially dried wood the dry wood will actually pick up moisture before losing it.

Of course you could ignore all that and just try drying as the article mentioned. If the drying schedule is gentle enough it should not damage the wood and still be faster than air drying.

If the alcohol method will work for you, it would be a lot simpler. Other methods include microwave drying, soaking in soap solution, boiling, and the one I use, air drying: coat the rough-turned object with Anchorseal and wait for 6 months before finish turning.

If you do build and use the simple kiln, I'd be very interested in your results, especially in the actual moisture content after drying. This would require oven drying and weighing a sample or section from a sacrificed bowl.

If you have the energy and want to advance the science of drying for turning, you could even try several different methods on the similar pieces made from the same tree. Weigh each before and after drying and final turning, and continue to monitor for long-term weight changes and dimensional stability. It seems that very little of this type of careful testing has been done.

JKJ

Re: Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

#4

Can you define careful testing?

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Hi JKJ,

I had to chuckle at your comment.

"If you have the energy and want to advance the science of drying for turning, you could even try several different methods on the similar pieces made from the same tree. Weigh each before and after drying and final turning, and continue to monitor for long-term weight changes and dimensional stability. It seems that very little of this type of careful testing has been done."

I could add to the statement, "No matter how many people use the method with great success it isn't real until the biggies in the turning world say it is an acceptable method."

I was very careful when I tested several methods on wood from the same tree. However, there is no incentive to invest an enormous amount of time and a considerable amount of money with no expectation of compensation. It is a fools errand.

Dave Smith

Skin must be a little thin tonight in Longview, WA.

Re: Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

#5

Or....

Bob Hackett

>You could just contact David Lancaster here in Maine.He`s been drying bowls in a production kiln for years and knows how it`s done.

Nyle in Bangor ME,who makes dehumidification kilns is also an excellent contact point for info.They cater to the smaller kiln owners and have tons of info that they share freely.

MB

Re: Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

#6

Fool's errand

JKJ in East TN

>>I was very careful when I tested several methods

>on wood from the same tree. However, there is no

>incentive to invest an enormous amount of time

>and a considerable amount of money with no

>expectation of compensation. It is a fools errand.

>

>...Skin must be a little thin tonight

Dave,

I'm very sorry if you think I'm out to discredit your hard work. The opposite - I'm quite interested in the technique and furthering any technique which aids woodturning. But my scientific and technical background makes me question, verify, and search for the "why" behind processes, especially those with great potential benefit but with primarily anecdotal "evidence" of success. (My own first experience with this was disappointing.)

I'm quite certain you were careful in your tests, but the article you wrote doesn't follow through with the controls. You even allude to this in your closing paragraph: "Although I collected data in a consistent manor [sic] and attempted to control variables, this is not a strict scientific study. The study did not verify my theory of why the process works."

It would be interesting and valuable to know the mechanism of why this works and to have quantifiable data as to how well it works compared to other methods currently in popular use, as well as methods that were popular in the past. It would be especially interesting to understand how alcohol can interact with cells deep in wood such as hard maple burl, or if the benefit gained is primarily from the tension induced by directed surface drying. There are many questions a careful study might answer.

As for the fool's errand, I guess it depends on your perspective. I expect no compensation for most of what I do outside of my job. Unfortunately, I am the only one with my particular expertise in a very large organization and my time is high in demand - there is very little time for anything else, including turning. If I can manage to retire next year, I hope to look at this whole subject more carefully. (I don't think such a study would require any significant financial investment with ready access to free wood.) I would consider the knowledge gained, and the pure joy of the persuit of knowledge, as ample reward for the investment in time and effort. (I was one of those fool geeks who worked all year on science projects in high school just for the fun of it!)

In the mean time, I would be most interested in your refined theories as to why this works and any further data you have acquired. I am accumulating files on this and other methods.

JKJ

Re: Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

#7

Re: Fool's errand

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I don't want to rain on your parade, but figuring out the how and why will probably take some reasonably sophisicated testing/analysis equipment - i.e. access to a reasonably well-equiped lab. Maybe a local college... I'm a chemist and I've thought about this a little... There's a doubter that posts on the AAW forum and I've crossed words with him a couple of times. (Not exactly my cup of tea!) If only we could get a biologist, or even better a wood scientist, interested in this...

Re: Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

#8

Re: Or....

JKJ in East TN

>I found contact info for Lancaster and Nyle. JKJ

----------------------------------------------

David Lancaster

166 Weeks Mills Road

South China ME 04358

http://www.mainecraftsguild.com/lancaster.html

lancaster@pivot.net

----------------------------------------------

Nyle Corp.

P.O. Box 1107

Bangor, ME 04402

Phone: 207-989-4335, 800-777-6953 (toll free)

Web Site: http://www.nyle.com

----------------------------------------------

Re: Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

#9

Re: Fool's errand

JKJ in East TN

>Good points, Brian. Just this weekend I got the names of two local researchers who are supposed to have studied some aspect of drying wood - the guy who told me about them has done some SEM work for them. He thought they had been working with RF and microwave energy. I also have names of some scientists working in wood research at the OR national lab where I work. I hope to contact these people and see what information they might have. Perhaps I can drum up some interest. I know exhaustive research has been done on kiln drying since it has commercial interest - perhaps someone has already studied the effects of alcohol or some other substance.

When I get time, the experiments I want to do would try to compare the results of various drying methods such as microwave, boiling, alcohol, kiln, and plain old air drying. Since this may require hundreds of bowls to get a reasonable sample size, the number of methods compared might have to be limited. I still have to give it some thought, but I envisioned this: turn a number of nearly identical bowls from the same tree, treat, then record RH, temperature, weight, MC and dimensions over time. The biggest problem to overcome seems to be the natural variablity of wood even within the same tree, perhaps minimized by taking more samples or perhaps by using wood from deep within larger trees. Since warpage, cracking and checking may be dependent on geometry, I suspect tests would have to be on whole bowls, but might be useful to measure the moisture gradient in samples of the same material treated along with the bowls.

I'd be interested in any comments and ideas.

JKJ

Re: Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

#10

I have to admire you Dave.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I doubt that I could be as calm about a carefully thought-out and researched idea as you are.

Doubters are everywhere, but in the end truth will prevail!

Unfortunately, that may take years (decades...).

Re: Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

#11

Good Luck

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>There are some people (maybe even a majority of people) that will accept empirical evidence.

Then there are the doubters that need detailed expanations of the how and why before they will believe the evidence.

It sounds like you've got a line on some potentially useful expertise. I hope it pans out!

Re: Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

#12

Re: Fool's errand

Phil Smith

>There are good thermodynamic reasons why this should work to speedup the drying process. The cellulose in wood has lots of hydroxyl groups, which hydrogen bond with them selves and with water. The hydrogen bonds, which are weak attractions of one molecule of cellulose for another molecule help give wood many of its properties including its attaction for moisture. Water strongly hydrogen bonds with itself and with other materials which have hydroxyl groups.

The alcohol that I have heard of most people useing is ethanol. Ethanol has one hydroxyl group which can hydrogen bond with istself or with other materials which have hydroxyl groups. But it is not nearly as good at hydrogen bonding as water, which results in a lower boiling point than water and a signifcantly lower heat of vaporization than water. ie it takes much less heat (energy) to evaporate (dry) than water.

With that said the first step of the drying process as I understand it is to put a green blank in to a container of denatured ethanol. Denatured ethanol is typically 95% ethanol and 5% water. The green bowl blank initally contains only wood and water and the tank contains almost all ethanol with just a litte water. This sets up a large concentration difference between the wood and the tank which causes a large driving force for the concentrations to equalize between the wood and the alcohol in the tank. Water will migrate from the wood into the ethanol and the ethanol will migrate into the wood until the concentrations of ethanol and water are near equal in both the tank and in the wood. The ethanol will fill the space taken up in the wood by water and provide the hydrogen bonding to the wet wood so its shape and volume when wet with ethanol will change little if any.

Once you remove the bowl blank from the tank most of the water has been replace by ethanol which has a much higher rate of evaporation (remember it takes much less energy to evaporate ethanol than water) than water and a much lower affinity for wood than water. With the water gone and only ethanol to evaporate the wood should dry at a fast rate. Most of the water soluble alcohols should work for this process. My guess is that small ketones such as acetone will also work.

Hope this helps.

PS. Lots of work has been done at the forrest products laboratory on the stabilization of to resist moisture pickup and change in size due to humidity. Essentially all of that work focused on the reaction of the free hydroxyls in wood with chemicals which wood reduce their ability to hydrogen bond with water.

Re: Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

#13

Re: Fool's errand

JKJ in East TN

>Excellent, Phil. I've added your comments to my files.

It would be interesting to discover both the rate and depth to which alcohol migrates into the wood. You wrote "when you remove the bowl blank from the tank most of the water has been replaced by ethanol." Would not the amount of replacement be highly dependent on factors such as time, thickness, and type of wood? For example, I suspect the open pores in a wood such as red oak should deliver ethenol to the inner cells far more quickly than pores clogged with abundant tyloses, such as found in black locust or white oak, or filled with resins as in some tropicals such as cocobolo. (And is temperature a factor?) It seems to me a valuable result of alcohol treatment research would be tables of recommended soaking times for various species and wall thickness.

Your comment about the typical concentration of ethanol in the denatured solution brings up another issue which I've wondered about and has been discussed here earlier - how much does the effectiveness of alcohol soaking decrease when the same alcohol solution is reused over and over? Since the concentrations of alcohol and water do equalize as you point out, it seems that repeated reuse would rapidly dilute the solution and make it less effective. Perhaps in actual use the liquid volume is decreased to the extent that sufficient concentration is maintained by replenishing with fresh DNA from the can.

JKJ

Re: Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

#14

Re: Fool's errand

RussFairfield

>Jeeeeesch. And all this time I was thinking this was magic. You guys take all the mystery out of life.

Re: Kiln drying vs. Alcohol drying

#15

My thanks also for adding to our knowledge base.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>