Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

Posts

Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

#1

Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

Pete in Holland, MI

>Greetings all -

Have done most of my turning in bowls this past year, but recently had a couple reasons to turn a couple handles for some old Army folding shovels. Resultant handle was about 1 1/2" diameter and 20" long. Wood used was red oak (ya, I know there are better woods for the purpose, but it was handy). Had a lot of problems with chatter during the roughing phases all the way up to finish turning. Found it better to use the rouging gouge more perpendicular to the wood rather than "pushing" the turning gouge, like on a bowl, but only minimised the chatter. Had similar issues when trying to use the skew. Tried slow, medium & fast RPMs and didn't help. Was rubbing the bevel on both tools as best as I could. Tools are sharp.

Is my diameter-to-length in the chattering range? Is it the wood choice.

Thanx for your help !

Pete

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

#2

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

JanManuel

>I turn spindles all the time...a 1 1/2" diam x 20" long spindle shouldn't chatter enough to be a problem. A light touch with the tools will go a long way to keep things steady. Too much tailstock pressure can also contribute to chatter.

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

#3

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

Jim Shaver, Oakville Ontario

>Hi Pete,

Others will comment , but I will say that chatter is an aspect of vibration and any play in the wood being turned. As a spindle turning gets smaller in diameter, the length of the spindle, the speed of the lathe and the harmonics of the wood can give you a "whip" vibration of the material. Twenty inches is not really that long a piece, but it can develop some harmonics. I use a skew and do a planing cut on my work to give it's final surface, usually as fast at the lathe speed will permit with out adding in whip. If indeed teh problem is this you might consider ways to steady the spindle while turning to minimize the effect.

If it's vibration from your tool, I think you will find the planing cut with a skew will clean it up nicely..

I am also going to follow what other people post on this, I have considered buying or making a spindle steady reast, but most of my work is 6 inches or less these days..(pens).

take care,

Jim

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

#4

JL

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

JL

>A spindle steady will "dampen" the chatter and some of the harmonics. Another thought - how much pressure on the tailstock? I am contemplating going to the new Sorby revolving steb centre (sort of a match for the Sorby steb centre on the drive side) - it supposedly requires much less pressure for a good bite.

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

#5

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>I would rough down a long, small dia. spindle to within 1/16" or so of final diameter without worrying about chatter, then take light final passes with a "scary sharp" skew using a planing cut. I hone my skew often, and go another step further by polishing it using white buffing compound on an MDF wheel.

Could be that the bevel angle on your skew isn't keen enough--an included angle of around 35 degrees seems to work best. No protractor needed--if the length of the bevel is close to 1 1/2 times the thickness of the blade, you've got it.

Chatter is mainly caused by resistance between the tool and the wood, the idea is to reduce that resistance as much as possible.

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

#6

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

JKJ in East TN

>Pete,

I do more spindle turning than bowl turning. You can use a roughing gouge or spindle gouge for finished turning, but for straight cylinders, tapers, or shallow curves the skew is a lot easier and makes a smoother surface.

When I run into chatter, I first try taking lighter cuts, and if that doesn't work, I touch up the edge with a hone, make a slower cut, adjust the lathe speed a bit up or down, or crank down or loosen the tailstock. Sometimes switching to a skew with a larger angle grind helps. Sometimes the grain/figure itself is such at it makes chatter worse, in which case sharper and lighter AND faster seem to work.

Raffan says "any force should be exerted...parallel to the axis rather than against it, so the force is transferred to the headstock or tailstock. Excessive tool pressure against the axis causes chattering, flexing, or even breaking of slender work..."

I have not yet found the need for a steady rest. I use my left hand as a steady rest where needed.

JKJ

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

#7

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

nathan murphey

>just a thought since you mainly do bowl turnings, did you line up the centers of the headstock and tailstock before you started--this will make a world of difference in spindle turning.

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

#8

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

RussFairfield

>There are 4 causes of chatter in a long spindle - too much pressure on the bevel and bending the wood, too much pressure on the tailstock and bowing the wood, the grain of the wood itself, and a dull tool.

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

#9

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

Edward

>Pete: are you using your non tool hand to wrap your fingers around the wood to dampen the vibration? The heel of that hand rests on the toolrest and the thumb can be used to guide the tool.

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

#10

Lots of great advice! Many thanx !

Pete in Holland, MI

>

Re: Spindle turning chatter - - wisdom sought !

#11

Re: Spindle turning chatter; Don't ride the bevel

Ruth Niles

>When the spindle starts to chatter, riding the bevel just rides the chatter causing more chatter. As everyone has already said, a very sharp tool, a very light touch and hold the spindle with your free hand.

I do a LOT of spindle work (since I can't live long enough to make a living doing Art-type turning!) and have the Oneway spindle steady. I rarely use it because you have to be careful not to burnish the spindle, have to move it as you turn down the spindle, can't put it where there's a cove, you have to either have a super long tool rest, a second banjo or take the steady off, move the tool rest, put the steady back on. I could turn 3 spindles in that time. But, then too, I am not a gadget person so pay no attention to my opinion on the steady rest. : )

Ruth