Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Hallo and a question about chucks

Posts

Hallo and a question about chucks

#1

Hallo and a question about chucks

Gautham

>Hallo - this is my first posting here and I was hoping to get some advice.

I have been turning for a while (mostly spindly things and bowls). I have recently wanted to get into turning boxes. So... I think I need a chuck (cant see a good way to use glue blocks for boxes). I have been looking around on the net for one. My main constraint is cost. OTOH, I dont want to buy something that I will not use. The options I see are:

1) Nova Midi (available at Packard) for about $120, they dont seem to sell inserts for this but I can easily get one - but is there some reason why it should NOT be used with an insert. I read (somewhere) that some chuck dont have inserts. Is this an availability thing, or is there a safety reason for this.

2) Grizzly has a 4-jaw scroll chuck for about $90 - looks like a vicmarc knockoff - but no ideas about quality. Can it be used with and insert?

3) Buy a used metal-working 4jaw self centering chuck - not common but findable and try to make/get made jaws for it- affordable but involves a lot of metal work and may turn out pointless at the end of it. How about the metal working jaws that come with it?

I would really appreciate peoples thoughts about this. While a SuperNova or Oneway would be great, I cant afford one now - and I really want to start doing boxes and stuff for which I really need a chuck.

TIA,

Gautham

Re: Hallo and a question about chucks

#2

Re: Hallo and a question about chucks

John Lucas

>First, don't waste your money on a metal 3 jaw chuck. They just don't work for wood.

You can use a wasteblock to turn boxes. You turn a hole to match the tenon on the box and glue the lid in it. Hollow the lid and turn most of the finial if it has one. Part the lid off. Turn a tenon on what is left of the lid wood and fit the lid to this to finish turning the top. Now turn a hole in the wasteblock and glue the bottom on. Hollow this and then fit the lid on. Now finish turning the lid and box. OK it' is much slower than a chuck but I did this for years before buying a chuck.

I have the GRizzly Vicmarc knockoff. Mine works almost as good as my Real Vicmarcs and I know it will do the job for you. I just turned a dozen 2 part ornaments which are very similar to the technique of making boxes. The chuck worked great for this.

Re: Hallo and a question about chucks

#3

I concur ....

Fred in NC

>About the metal chuck. Not very useful for woodwork, and besides, it has part of the scrolling mechanism right on the jaws. It would be a lot of work to make extra jaws for it.

Re: Hallo and a question about chucks

#4

Re: Hallo and a question about chucks

Larry E in NE OK

>I can not imagine life without a chuck albiet it is possible because turners used other alternatives before chucks. You did not mention your lathe size, this has a bearing on your decison. Assuming you have a lathe with 1 x 8 spindle threads, the Oneway Talon is an excellent long-term solution for small to medium size work (bowls up to 12"). The SuperNova2 is an excellent for medium to large work and has a broad assortment of jaws. If you your going into the large to extra large work, the Oneway Stronghold or Vicmark's 5 1/2" chucks are excellent. Like everything, we are only limited by our minds AND our budgets. Have not had experience with the Grizzly but have heard much good about it. The Nova Midi is a nice chuck but it uses Tommy Bars and requires a little extra effort when closing (three hands would be great). Like I said, I can not imagine that you would waste your money if you bought a chuck....that is unless you hardly ever do face work.

Hope this helps,

Re: Hallo and a question about chucks

#5

Re: Hallo and a question about chucks

gautham

>Thanks for your views.

I did try a similar method of turning boxes, but the gluing up takes a while (no access to CA glue) which is fine for bowls, but it would be nicer to finish a box in one go.

So the Grizzly remains on my list while the metal working one goes off it.

Gautham

Re: Hallo and a question about chucks

#6

Re: Hallo and a question about chucks

gautham

>I wish I could have trouble imagining life without a chuck :-)

The spindle is about 9 inches off the bed � so in US terms that�s a swing of about 18 inches. I have no idea what the spindle thread is, but a machinist friend of mine has and does help me make adaptors for it that fit other stuff I need (faceplates etc). I am not really looking for a chuck to hold a chunk of wood that size, since that would be waaaay over budget and glue blocks work..

Would be willing to try to get used to the tommy bars on the Nova Midi but what I was worried about was if I could use a spindle adaptor on this chuck. One of the sites selling this chuck seemed to suggest it should not be used with an adaptor. Cant see why but I don�t want to miss something.

Thanks for any insight you might have about this.

Gautham

Re: Hallo and a question about chucks

#7

Re: Hallo and a question about chucks *LINK*

Gordon Seto

>The Midi is a smaller chuck which is recommended for lathe up to 12" swing. Because its small size, this chuck is directly threaded. There is no room for an insert (adaptor); therefore you can't use this chuck on lathes with different size spindle by replacing insert, except by adding a spindle adaptor. If you don't have to, you don't want to use an adaptor; because the extra length away from the headstock puts more stress on the bearings and increases vibration. BTW, it is currently on sale at Woodcraft at $100 and even lower several months ago. I really don't think the Midi is a good match for the capacity of a 18" swing lathe.

Someone has used the Grizzly chuck in demo in our last Club meeting. We are impressed with the value of this chuck and considering a group purchase. A set of different size jaws costs only $18 is another bargain.

If you mention the brand and model of the lathe you have, probably someone on WC would know what spindle size you have.


MIDI Chuck