Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Liablility question

Posts

Liablility question

#1

Liablility question

Carole in VA

>I know a lot of folks turn candle holders, confetti lamp holders, etc. When you sell them at craft shows, do you have to include all the "Caution" gobbledegook with the piece? You know the stuff...don't place near flammables, always place on a heat proof surface type stuff. How about "If you are stupid, don't buy this candle holder/lamp." Seriuosly though, is there a liability factor there that should be considered? And how do you handle it, if at all?

Re: Liablility question

#2

Re: Liablility question

John U - Charlotte, NC

>keep it simple.

"If you burn anything down, it's not my fault"

Re: Liablility question

#3

Re: Liablility question

David Breth

>I'm no expert, but I have to think that this particular liability would be not be enforceable (in nearly all cases). It would be patently obvious to anybody, judges included, that there is an inherent risk involved in lighting fires in one's house, and he who lights the fire incurs the risk. I know, "McDonald's coffee", but I just don't see it. The only liability I can think of would be if you made something that was physically unstable and a buyer could not reasonably be expected to detect it. I'd stay away from designs subject to easy tipping, or pieces of such delicate design that they could fail and kind of leave it at that. But that's me.

Having said that, when I was a kid, my cat sat down on a lit candle. Her tail went up like tiki torch, and when I yelled at her, she jumped off the countertop and that extinguished the flame. You might need to explain "fire" to kitty.

If only my opinion were worth two cents.

David B.

Re: Liablility question

#4

Re: Liablility question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Carol,

There are several attorneys who frequent this board, but we are prevented from actually answering your question because of a host of issues. If you're truly concerned, rather than relying on urban mythes or internet hearsay, you should check with an attorney in your State who handles product liability issues. Most counties have an attorney referral service, and your State's Bar Association will most certainly have one. Explain your situation and status when you call and you might just get connected to a "pro bono" lawyer, or one who will barter a turning in exchange for drafting you a simple, but effective disclaimer.

Mark

Re: Liablility question

#5

Re: I have no liability

RussFairfield

>I took the easy way out. I quit making them.

Re: Liablility question

#6

Re: Liablility question

georgetroy

>You don't have deep pockets so don't worry about it. The friendly lawyers would go to the place they were sold. Or better yet to the mfrs. I belive insurance would just be an invitation to sue. They would go after your home owners, the mfg. of the lathe, etc. GT

Re: Liablility question

#7

Me Either Russ - Rant

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>In this day and age just about anyone can sue you for anything. Even if you are found innocent, considerable time and probably money is involved. I decided there are many other items that I could turn other than those with which some idiot could burn the house down.

The McDonalds fiasco was enough for me. A total idiot (yes coffee is hot) was able to profit from her stupidity (or was it stupidity?). Or how about the guy that sued McDonalds because he got fat from eating the food (no duh). The juries that award people for these ridiculous suits are really digging a deep hole. Sorry, the whole "let's sue" mentality really makes me mad. :-(

Re: Liablility question

#8

Re: Me Either Russ - Rant

Mac

>Now calm down Barbara...take a deep breath....sit down.....maybe a little Australian wine is in order here......

Re: Liablility question

#9

Re: Me Either Russ - Rant

Carole in VA

>Me too, Barabara. But what makes me really angry is the fact that I am even considering letting them influence what I make and don't make. Grrrr...pass me that wine!

Re: Liablility question

#10

LOL!

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Cheers, a little drop of red.

Re: Liablility question

#11

Re: Me Either Russ - Rant

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>True Carole. Along with getting older comes knowing what battles to fight as well as knowing what boots to wear. ROTFLMHO

Re: Liablility question

#12

Re: Liablility question

The Wood Spinner / Bill Hale

>I posed a similar question some time back and the result was to form an LLC and be safe from these stupid things that should just be thrown out of the judicial process. People should be told if they are so stupid TUFF.

Some states forming an LLC is cheap and easy.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ

Re: Liablility question

#13

I thought you were supposed to soak the wood in th

TDaniel

>

Re: Liablility question

#14

the alcohol?

TDaniel

>

Re: Liablility question

#15

Oh, I Do That Too. :-)

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Liablility question

#16

While Sipping on My Glass of Merlot...

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I pondered the subject and decided that if you want to turn something that a stupid, careless, greedy person might want to sue you over... don't sign it. :-)

Re: Liablility question

#17

Re: I'm with Barbara!

Ruth Niles

>Carole,

This subject insults the average person's dignity and intelligence. EVERY law in this country is made according to the DUMBEST person.

I'd suggest that you go through all the department stores and see what warnings they have on their candles, candle holders and tea lights. I'm sure Lord and Taylor knows the "stupid person" laws.

I like the label on hair dryers about "do not use in the shower"!

Ruth

Re: Liablility question

#18

Amen Sister Sue! This is fun. Pour me one too!!

Molly Winton

>

Re: Liablility question

#19

Re: Liablility question

John Lucas

>Caroland others. No one has mentioned Fire Retardant. You can buy the stuff and mix it with finish. I haven't tried it on candlesticks but I bought it so that I could use it like a resist to create burned designs. One of my friends does wonderful "paintings" this way. He paints the design with the fire retardent and then burns the whole board. The design is left more or less unburned. I think this stuff would work quite well on candlesticks. I'll look it up tomorrow when I'm in the shop and tell you what it is.

Re: Liablility question

#20

Re: While Sipping on My Glass of Merlot...

Mac

>Easy there Barbara,we seem to be getting a little excited again.

Re: Liablility question

#21

Re: Liablility question - - suing subdewed

Pete in Holland, MI

>As soon as the government decides to pass laws that caps what money can be made during a law suit, the number will fall off. If the law firm that took on the McDonald's coffee episode went into it knowing the most they and their client would ever collect would be, say $100,000, they would probably have laughed at the lady's stupidity and escorted her out of the office. Threats of being sued has unfortunately cut back a lot of events you and I used to enjoy, just in case someone should get hurt and a lawyer decides he wants to seek his retirement fund in one case.

Re: Liablility question

#22

Re: Me Either Russ - Rant

Jim Shaver, Oakville Ontario

>This is funny in some ways.

I remeber my grandmother (1900-95) telling me once, if you are dumb enough not to be able to see the obvious then you don't know what hits you when it hits you...then she mentioned something about thinning out of the gene pool as well.

The process of the legal procedure is the issue for me.....where did simple common sense go???

I'm sorry, but I have no time for people who see the obvious and still make it their method to achieve from greed....this is wrong.

Maybe I should stop making pens, because some one is likely to poke out an eye or ear drum some day...UGH!!

:-)

Take care,

Jim

I think my grandmother was right

Re: Liablility question

#23

Re: I'm with Barbara!

Carole in VA

>LOL I used to keep a list of the really idiotic ones I found in the "Caution" and "Disclaimer" statements. I wish I could find it. I used to read them on stuff I bought just for the amusement and to add to my list. The ones translated by the Chinese were the best.

Re: Liablility question

#24

Re: I'm with Barbara!

David Breth

>I kept one for awhile that was on the box for a window fan. The kind where you open the window, put the fan in, and shut the window more or less on top of it - you know, a WINDOW fan. The box labeling had a rather emphatic statement that you were not to use the fan in a window. 'kay....

Re: Liablility question

#25

Re: Jim, GOOD point ......

Ruth Niles

>and pardon the pun : )

You really did make an excellent point in that if (IF) everyone is so darned concerned about the liability factore, we should not sell pens because a child might pick Dad's pen up and poke his eye out. We should never make salad bowls; beeswax = people allergic to bee bites: no finish = someone might get a splinter in their tongue if the wood dries and chips: walnut oil = nut allergy, etc. Never turn baby rattles, the kid could chew it, get splinters in their tongue, pierce their stomach lining, etc. And for goodness sake stop turning ornaments, talk about poking your eye out! Wonder what disclaimer Cindy Drozda puts on her turnings?!? Oh, then there's those hollow forms with the tiny hole, couldn't someone get their finger stuck in it and sue because he couldn't make love to his wife for a month or until he got the form free! I put a warning on my mushrooms that they are NOT meant to be eaten.