Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

HELP - stinky wood!!!!

Posts

HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#1

HELP - stinky wood!!!!

David Breth

>Today I grabbed a log about 16" tall and probably 25-30" diameter from a discard pile. Thought at first it was maple, but believe now it is ok. See the pics. There was no bark when I got it. I smelled manure on the wood when I picked it up, but not until it was in the van - a considerable effort, so I took it home.

I figured maybe the thing had been near manure at some point, maybe soaked a little in to the wood, I dunno, but thought it would clear up once I cut bowl blanks out of it. Wrong. Still smells.

Question is - I know there is some wood that has a urine smell when cut, any small chance there is some wood that has a nice cow poop odor to it when cut? I'm stunned that this smell has carried so deep into the wood - I really cut into this thing to try to get past any embedded stinkies. Any experiences like this? Any chance this stink will dissipate? It isn't like you pick it up and get knocked over, but the scent de jour is clearly present.

Probably a dumb question, but after the effort I put into this thing, I'm willing to grasp at straws.

Thanks -

David B.


img

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#2

If you can't get rid of the smell!!!!!

kevinT in T Bay

>If the smell doesn't disappear, Make someone you dislike ,a chamber pot for X-mas...LOL... I won't even suggest the gift exchange thingy...OOPS.... Cheers KevinT in T Bay ( Just having fun, sorry if this offends anyone..)

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#3

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>From your description of the smell, I'm guessing it's hickory. I haven't turned any, but is smells like downwind of a feedlot when you cut it on the table saw! Fortunately, the smell goes away quickly, and/or is covered & contained by finishes.

Jim D.

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

Keith Tompkins

>That, I believe, is elm. The scientific name is Pi$$ elm. Now you know why! LOL

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#5

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

David Breth

>I've heard the expression pi$$ oak before, or maybe it was pi$$ elm. Either way, this stuff smells distinctively like manure - definitely matches the "downwind of the feedlot" description. At present, the garage is somewhat reeking of it. But I'll wait until a few more bets are in before I officially choose sides of Hickory vs Elm. These "what type of wood" questions are always kind of interesting, because typically there are about ninety-seven offerings of what it is.

Having said that - how warpy would either hickory or elm be? How prone to checking/splitting? I've got some sections that I could make into a screw together cane, which if this is hickory, might actually look kind of cool. I also like turning green bowls to allow them to warp.

By the way, the wood, in my mind, very much reminds me of oak (I'm not exactly a wood-type expert, as if you couldn't tell), given the colors and patterns I'm seeing. The age rings are quite large. I'll bet they are a good width of my pinky apart.

Thanks very much for the input - greatly, greatly appreciated.

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#6

Elm . . Not

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Cottonwood, Oh yeah. Giveaway is the wide annular rings and the featherd cut edges. Fast growing, heavily cut bark, very strong urea content, very heavy when just cut, yet about like poplar in hardness when dry with interlocking grain. Be prepared to leave your clothes in the shop. Main use is for horse stalls because they (the horses) won't crib it (chew on it) because the stuff tastes so bad. Not worth burning as the BTU rating is one of the lowest.

Not your best choice for a food-use bowl, but the grain and coloring can be nice.

M

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#7

Cottonwood

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I have turned a lot of cottonwood. The figure can be awesome. Once the wood has dried, there is no more smell. It will soak up the finish. It is also a real challenge to get a smooth surface on without heavy sanding. I like to make plates from it because if you get it on the thin side and soak real well with multi applications of oil it will be translucent.

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#8

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

jeff jilg

>There are a lot of woods which stink when still wet. This includes some of the woods already listed - hickory, oak, elm, cottonwood, and box elder. Generally the smell goes away when the wood is dry. Or at least the smell is hardly noticeable at that point.

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#9

Re: Elm . . Not

Curt Fuller

>I'll second the vote for cottonwood. There are a couple varieties of cottonwood. One, a broadleafed tree with a large spreading canopy, and others that have longer, narrow leaves and grow more straight up. But the big broad leafed version smells like cow poop, almost more than cow poop does. Turns kind of wierd, gets fuzzy and requires a lot of sanding. Dries to very light weight so that bowls and platters are almost feather weight.

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#10

I agree with Barb, but it could be ....

TDaniel

>sycamore. I tend to agree with Barb because of the big growth rings. Sycamore if grown in a low area in a pasture with cattle will smell just like cow poop; I suspect the tree just sucks up what is under it. But since I have never seen growth rings that big on sycamore I have to agree with Barb.

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#11

English Walnut?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>I had the same poopy smell once with that?

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Elm . . Not

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Mark! You may have it here....I have some elm however that was growing in a swamp...large growth rings also. An easy test is the hardness. Cottonwood is hard to split for firewood because it's so wet and soft. A splitting maul sinks in and you can't get it back out. Elm grain is so interlocked, it's near impossible to split by hand. Most wood burners don't bother to take fallen elm.

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#13

Re: English Walnut?

David Breth

>For those who have been tabulating (me), the current votes/opinions stand at

Hickory - 1

Elm - 1

Cottonwood - 5

Sycamore - 1

English Walnut - 1

The more I'm hearing of the descriptions, the more I'm leaning toward the Cottonwood - growth rings and smells like poop. Not sure how long my wife will have a sense of humor about the garage, so hopefully the heavy part of the stink will dissipate in a few days. If not, I may end up posting some free wood....or offering a trade for wood that smells like pretty flowers or vanilla.

Thanks again for all the help. Additional comments are definitely welcome!

David B.

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#14

Re: Looks like Cottonwood to me.

RussFairfield

>

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#15

Re: Cottonwood

Phil Joines

>LOML and I both like cottonwood. It has a bad rep around here but I don't think it's deserved. This piece got several coats of laquar after the photo.


img

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#16

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!! *LINK*

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>I'm not very familiar with cottonwood, as it doesn't grow around here.

But an easy way to distinguish between it and elm is by looking closely at the end grain, which in elm you'll see a zig-zag pattern in each growth ring, which looks like a feather pattern on the side grain. I don't think cottonwood has that pattern.

Check out Hough's American Woods site, with high rez pics of 350 types of wood. Each type has a view of end grain, radial grain, and tangential grain. The highest resolution pics are around 600 kb in size, at 1863 x 2690 pixels.

Here's a close crop of white elm end grain, then below it the link to Hough's site.


img

Hough's American Woods index

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#17

Re: English Walnut?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Jennifer,

I wonder if you burnt it would it still smell as bad?

Take care,

Jim

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#18

stinky wood UPDATE!

David Breth

>I know it is pretty late - rest assured, I do not turn when I'm even remotely tired, I'm just a bit of a night owl. I turned a couple of small bowls from the wood that I'm pretty sure now is indeed cottonwood. Here are a couple of pics.

My wife will most definitely not be amused at the smell in the basement tomorrow morning. I stripped to nothing, and threw the clothes in the washer, then took a shower myself afterwards. I'm sure she'll tell me she can still smell it on me.

Also would like to comment that the posts on respirators last week paid off. I bought a North 7700 to replace the lousy cannister mask I had - first time I think I've ever been in the shop where I didn't walk out with a little bit of a sore throat. Saving my pennies for proper dust collection to boot.

Now to topic. This wood turned really, really, really well. I did not experience tearout at all, and it cut like a dream. The biggest problem was the growth rings versus the valleys, as the tool really wanted to fall into the valleys. Not so much a problem as just something to be aware of. I turned two bowls (cups, whatever) just to see how it would look. I think the figuring in the wood is gorgeous, and the pics don't really do them justice. They have that fine sort-of feathering between the growth rings, which reminds me of a cottonwood burl I did over the summer (that piece was bone dry, so no smell at all). I think this is visible in the pic. The one on the left I turned the wall thin enough to see light through it. Both are in paper bags now, and I can't wait to see how much they warp, hopefully a lot, but I guess we'll see. These pieces are very far from the pith, so there might not be much working to distort them. By the way, these did not move at all during turning. Round remained round until I got to the point where there was very little wood left on the wall. It really held its ground, which makes a pretty forgiving environment in which to work.

My method (of experimentation) with this is to sand my green pieces to finish sand 600 grit, then stick them in paper bags. My idea, such that it is, is that finish sanding will help slow the drying process. I haven't lost a piece yet doing this, but I also haven't gotten the collosal warping I'm after either, though I've only done it maybe a half dozen times.

Anyway, thanks very much to everybody. I really appreciate it. I couldn't figure out how it was possible for a piece of wood to stink of manure short of having Bessie cut loose on it for thirty years which didn't seem to be the case, and felt pretty silly writing this post - I envsioned everybody telling me this wasn't naturally occuring, and you better move the poop wood back to the discard. Guess not! But I still may get asked to move it out of here...

David B.


img

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#19

stinky wood UPDATE!

David Breth

>I know it is pretty late - rest assured, I do not turn when I'm even remotely tired, I'm just a bit of a night owl. I turned a couple of small bowls from the wood that I'm pretty sure now is indeed cottonwood. Here are a couple of pics.

My wife will most definitely not be amused at the smell in the basement tomorrow morning. I stripped to nothing, and threw the clothes in the washer, then took a shower myself afterwards. I'm sure she'll tell me she can still smell it on me.

Also would like to comment that the posts on respirators last week paid off. I bought a North 7700 to replace the lousy cannister mask I had - first time I think I've ever been in the shop where I didn't walk out with a little bit of a sore throat. Saving my pennies for proper dust collection to boot.

Now to topic. This wood turned really, really, really well. I did not experience tearout at all, and it cut like a dream. The biggest problem was the growth rings versus the valleys, as the tool really wanted to fall into the valleys. Not so much a problem as just something to be aware of. I turned two bowls (cups, whatever) just to see how it would look. I think the figuring in the wood is gorgeous, and the pics don't really do them justice. They have that fine sort-of feathering between the growth rings, which reminds me of a cottonwood burl I did over the summer (that piece was bone dry, so no smell at all). I think this is visible in the pic. The one on the left I turned the wall thin enough to see light through it. Both are in paper bags now, and I can't wait to see how much they warp, hopefully a lot, but I guess we'll see. These pieces are very far from the pith, so there might not be much working to distort them. By the way, these did not move at all during turning. Round remained round until I got to the point where there was very little wood left on the wall. It really held its ground, which makes a pretty forgiving environment in which to work.

My method (of experimentation) with this is to sand my green pieces to finish sand 600 grit, then stick them in paper bags. My idea, such that it is, is that finish sanding will help slow the drying process. I haven't lost a piece yet doing this, but I also haven't gotten the collosal warping I'm after either, though I've only done it maybe a half dozen times.

Anyway, thanks very much to everybody. I really appreciate it. I couldn't figure out how it was possible for a piece of wood to stink of manure short of having Bessie cut loose on it for thirty years which didn't seem to be the case, and felt pretty silly writing this post - I envsioned everybody telling me this wasn't naturally occuring, and you better move the poop wood back to the discard. Guess not! But I still may get asked to move it out of here...

David B.


img

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#20

stinky wood UPDATE!

David Breth

>I know it is pretty late - rest assured, I do not turn when I'm even remotely tired, I'm just a bit of a night owl. I turned a couple of small bowls from the wood that I'm pretty sure now is indeed cottonwood. Here are a couple of pics.

My wife will most definitely not be amused at the smell in the basement tomorrow morning. I stripped to nothing, and threw the clothes in the washer, then took a shower myself afterwards. I'm sure she'll tell me she can still smell it on me.

Also would like to comment that the posts on respirators last week paid off. I bought a North 7700 to replace the lousy cannister mask I had - first time I think I've ever been in the shop where I didn't walk out with a little bit of a sore throat. Saving my pennies for proper dust collection to boot.

Now to topic. This wood turned really, really, really well. I did not experience tearout at all, and it cut like a dream. The biggest problem was the growth rings versus the valleys, as the tool really wanted to fall into the valleys. Not so much a problem as just something to be aware of. I turned two bowls (cups, whatever) just to see how it would look. I think the figuring in the wood is gorgeous, and the pics don't really do them justice. They have that fine sort-of feathering between the growth rings, which reminds me of a cottonwood burl I did over the summer (that piece was bone dry, so no smell at all). I think this is visible in the pic. The one on the left I turned the wall thin enough to see light through it. Both are in paper bags now, and I can't wait to see how much they warp, hopefully a lot, but I guess we'll see. These pieces are very far from the pith, so there might not be much working to distort them. By the way, these did not move at all during turning. Round remained round until I got to the point where there was very little wood left on the wall. It really held its ground, which makes a pretty forgiving environment in which to work.

My method (of experimentation) with this is to sand my green pieces to finish sand 600 grit, then stick them in paper bags. My idea, such that it is, is that finish sanding will help slow the drying process. I haven't lost a piece yet doing this, but I also haven't gotten the collosal warping I'm after either, though I've only done it maybe a half dozen times.

Anyway, thanks very much to everybody. I really appreciate it. I couldn't figure out how it was possible for a piece of wood to stink of manure short of having Bessie cut loose on it for thirty years which didn't seem to be the case, and felt pretty silly writing this post - I envsioned everybody telling me this wasn't naturally occuring, and you better move the poop wood back to the discard. Guess not! But I still may get asked to move it out of here...

David B.


img

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#21

Big oops

David Breth

>Sorry -

the computer reconnected to the internet during my post, and three of the same exact post was the result. Oooops.

David B.

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#22

Re: stinky wood UPDATE!

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi David,

My vote goes for elm after looking at the pictures of the bowls. The feather grain on the side of the first one sure looks like elm.

Gary

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#23

Re: stinky wood UPDATE!

Barry Irby

>If you describe it as turning easy, it's not hickory. I have a blank in a bag I just turned. Got it from a friend cutting hickory for firewood. I kept looking in his trailer for the cow poop. Right smell, wrong wood. I'll post a picture if you want. It was not a "dream" to turn. Been in the bag a week and the smell is less.

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#24

Re: stinky wood UPDATE!

David Breth

>Another update. Hmmmm. Looked in the bag this morning. both pieces have mold started on the end grain. Maybe I shouldn't have finish-sanded them. Nerts.

Re: HELP - stinky wood!!!!

#25

Re: stinky wood UPDATE!

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>David,

You just need to take the bowls out of the bags for a little while. Fungus growth is primarily a function of not enough air flow, when you are dealing with green wood. The difficulty is that too much airflow is also not a good thing. It will cause the wood to crack. Fortunately, the interlocking grain of elm is working in your favor as far as checking is concerned.

There is a narrow window where the airflow around the wood provides sufficient drying to slow fungal growth without creating checking from drying the wood too rapidly. The size of that window is dependent upon the relative humidity in the area where the bowls are being stored, the moisture content of the wood at present, as well as the thickness of the wood, the shape of the bowl and probably other factors that I'm not aware of. 8^]

Gary