Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

blanks for vases

Posts

blanks for vases

#1

blanks for vases

George Fitzpatrick

>Being new to turning, I have more a lot of questions. Found this site and have been "lurking" for several months and got a lot of good info. Time for me to jump in the fray....

I have done some small plates, boxes and a lot of bud vases, mostly out of douglas fir. Grabbed a 4"x4"x8' piece and cut small into 6"-8" sections and started turning. Found out I like making bud vases. My question is, how do I cut a blank from a piece of wood so that when I turn the vase I do not have the pith runing through the middle. On the doug fir it was no problem as it was dry as a bone. But I have some nice pieces of maple freshly cut, about 6-7 inches in diameter. What's the best way to make a vase out of something this size without having it crack?

Sorry for such a long post...

geofitz

maker of fine sawdust

Re: blanks for vases

#2

Re: blanks for vases

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Hi George,

There is only one way. Cut the wood with the pith cut out.

Norm

Re: blanks for vases

#3

Re: blanks for vases

George Fitzpatrick

>Norm:

Thanks for the quick reply. My understanding then would be if I wanted to make a 3" diameter vase, I would start with a limb about 6" in diameter (in a perfect world the pith would run straight through the limb), cut it in half, eliminating the pith, then cut my blank out of one of the two halves. Do I have that right? Sounds like I need BIG limbs... :)

geofitz13

maker of fine sawdust

Re: blanks for vases

#4

Re: blanks for vases

JamieDonaldson

>George - you will have much more stable wood by not using branches. Branch wood is often reaction wood, more prone to moving and checks than the main trunk wood. And of course the branch wood will have considerable loss from sap as well as pith if trying to salvage maximum usable diameter, but don't overlook its use as practice wood- you can turn the "pith" out of it for free!

Re: blanks for vases

#5

Re: blanks for vases

Lan Brady

>George,

I had apiece of birc limb that I wante to make a vase from. I chucked it corner to corner and turned the vase with the pith running out at the bottm and the other side on the top. It had fine cracks that were filled with CA glue. There is a solution to all problems.

Lan


img

Re: blanks for vases

#6

Re: blanks for vases

John Lucas

>George if you make a vase but don't hollow it out so the wall will be somewhat thin it will still crack even if you remove the pith. To get 3or 4" pieces that won't crack you would have to seal the ends and put them up for a year or more. The rule of thumb is a year per inch but I've found you can fudge that a little depending on the shape of the piece.

I agree with Jamie. Limb stock will move quite a bit because it will have a lot of reaction wood. The stresses from hanging will compress wood on one side and it still wants to move when you start turning it even when it's dry.

Re: blanks for vases

#7

Re: blanks for vases

This site is awesome

>John: Thank you (and everyone else who replied to this) for the advice. I tried turning a vase from a piece of maple approx 3 inches in diameter, while still very green. Approx 8 inches tall. Not having a hollowing tool (just got the Sorby Hollowmaster), I drilled a hole down the center as deeply as possible. This left VERY thick walls and bottom. I left it alone just to see what would happen. After about a week, I looked and lo and behold, a massive crack down one side. Then I thought about removing the pith and filling that hole with sawdust and CA, but after seeing your post, I think I'm on the wrong track. Seems like the solution would be to start with a bigger piece of wood and use only one side. I visualize a thick piece of wood, slightly larger than the height of the vase and a little more than twice as wide. Cut the slab in half, removing the pith, and then use the two sides as blanks. Is that about right??

geofitz13

maker of fine sawdust

Re: blanks for vases

#8

Re: blanks for vases

George Fitzpatrick

>Lan:

That piece is terrific! Makes me feel even more inadequate at this stage of my turning career. But I will get there, without a doubt.

Did you remove the pith at the bottom and fill it in?

geofitz13

maker of fine sawdust

Re: blanks for vases

#9

try quarters

TDaniel

>Try a larger log and quarter it, then square up the quarters; that should give you some good end-grain turning stock. Turn to less than 3/8" thick all over, including the bottom and retard the drying by placing the turning in a paper box for a few weeks. Let us know if this works.

TD

Re: blanks for vases

#10

Re: blanks for vases

John Lucas

>Thats how most of use do hollow vessels of any type is to use half the log. You can use a whole log but you risk having checks around the pith. I have made some way back when where I hollowed through the pith by drilling as you suggested, then hollowing the vessel more. Let it warp and dry then true up the hole where the pith was and plug it. John Jordan used to do this on his early hollow vessels and that's where I learned it. He would save a scrap from the bottom and let it dry and then turn it for the plug so the wood and grain matched up.

Re: blanks for vases

#11

Re: blanks for vases

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>HI george,

You have received some excellent advice. You are on the right track by using bigger pieces without the pith. You may want to rough turn your pieces and soak them in alcohol , etc. to dry them and than finish turning. If you are interested in this process do a search on this sight for Dave Smith drying with denatured alcohol.

Norm

Re: blanks for vases

#12

Re: blanks for vases

George Fitzpatrick

>Norm...

That's my next step. Got my DNA and planning on trying that this weekend. Will let you know how it turns out. Gonna try some of the other ideas posted to this thread, too.

geofitz13

maker of fine sawdust

Re: blanks for vases

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: blanks for vases

Keith Tompkins

>HI George, welcome aboard! A couple of good things about 3" dia. branches....they are readily available. they are good to practice on while learning technique. You won't waste a lot of better wood that way...You don't have to feel guilty about wasting wood while learning.

Some, like me, actually enjoy turning reaction wood. FYI, reaction wood occurs when one part of the branch was under compression, such as occurs in the limb of a tree. The weight of the branch compresses the fibers on the lower part, while the fibers in the upper part being "stretched".

This makes for an interesting turning while it dries....such as a goblet with a twisted stem and distorted bowl. the secret to these is to locate the pith slightly off center, and turn the piece very thin to avoid cracking.

Re: blanks for vases

#14

Re: blanks for vases

JKJ in East TN

>>makes for an interesting turning while it dries....

>such as a goblet with a twisted stem and distorted bowl.

The book "Turning Green Wood" gives ideas and how-tos for these and other things to make out of branches and firewood. I think it's well worth adding to one's library.

JKJ

Re: blanks for vases

#15

Turn a limb vessel to 3/8" for best success.

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>Hi George,

I have successfully turned limbs to 3/8" wall thickness then dried using the alcohol process. The piece will dry in a few days and then can be finished turned. The pith does not crack in most cases. If you don't hollow out the inside then all bets are off.

Good luck and post some pictures of your work.

Dave Smith

Got to process some fresh silktree in Longview, WA.