Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Anniversary captive ring goblet - my 1st

Posts

Anniversary captive ring goblet - my 1st

#1

Anniversary captive ring goblet - my 1st

David Breth

>On Friday my wife and I will celebrate 5 years of my being held captive, so I thought I would turn a captive ring goblet - my first, as a gift for ourselves. This is one of those ones where you don't want to blast it off the lathe because your wife will read something into that. Great care was taken. I definitely made some mistakes with this - there is some minor tear out in the bottom of the cup (I struggle with that in endgrain cups/boxes), and there are some tool marks on the rings that are effectively un-fixable once you cut the rings loose - I knew it was going to happen when I did it, but I was so intent on learning how to cut the rings I kind of ignored it. I also learned a little something about flexing, as the stem started to come apart on me, and I ended up using a suggestion from this site to fill the gaps with ca and charcoal. So, it is far from perfect, but I'm really happy with the way it turned out. The wood is cherry, and I finished it with Minwax Antique Oil Finish - 6 coats but I may have lost count. Don't know how well the picture will look, but the finish really does pop out at you.

The biggest things I was looking for were overall shape/proportion, especially with the stem so it wouldn't look like a tree trunk, a good finish, and captive rings that weren't so big they fell off the bottom, and rings that were a pretty good matched set size-wise. On those counts, I'm pretty happy.

My happiness aside, I'm very interested in your comments and criticisms - that's how you learn - so please fire away.


img

Re: Anniversary captive ring goblet - my 1st

#2

nice work!

e

>david--

one suggestion is to taper the stem a bit ... carry the curve of the cup through the stem -- just a very slight adjustment so the stem doesn't look like a straight stick.

Re: Anniversary captive ring goblet - my 1st

#3

Re: nice work!

David Breth

>Thanks very much for taking the time to comment. Hard to believe that 220 something people looked at it without comment. Maybe nobody had the heart!

Anyway, I like your suggestion a lot - a slight taper all the way down to the base would look really nice. Many of the goblets (captive-ringed or otherwise) I've seen have these giant fat stems that just look out of proportion. That's a good way to approach it. I've got a piece of thorn apple I'm reserving for a long stemmed goblet, and it may get on the lathe sooner rather than later just to try that out.

David B.

Re: Anniversary captive ring goblet - my 1st

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Anniversary captive ring goblet - my 1st

Keith Tompkins

>Hi David, nice piece....yes, it's frustrating when you post something and few people reply! Looking at your piece, the bowl form of the goblet has a distinct break in the flow....the line starts from the rim, and there is an abrupt change in direction midway to the stem. Then, an almost straight line to the stem.The viewer's eye tends to focus on that change, rather than the overall form of the piece. Also, the foot could be a bit smaller to improve the balance.

Not criticisms of your work, rather, ways to help improve with your form. Thanks for posting and happy anniversary!