Red Oak
Doug Reynolds in Seattle
>Is red oak a good turning material? Pretty common here in the pacific northwest.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Red Oak
Doug Reynolds in Seattle
>Is red oak a good turning material? Pretty common here in the pacific northwest.
Re: Red Oak
John Lucas
>It turns well, looks great when your done, rusts your lathe like you wouldn't believe. Coat it well with wax or WD-40 before, during and after turning the stuff.
Re: Red Oak
GaryG in MD
>John, Is red oak one of the woods whose grain sands away faster than the remainder? I've had a problem like that -- where the surface has rolling waves with the grain marks in the troughs. ...Gary
Re: Red Oak
John Lucas
>Gary I don't remember that problem. Is does have really deep pores like you would think. I use more of a satin looking finish unless I fill the pores with something. It is really fun to fill the pores with contrasting waxes for accent.
Re: Red Oak
Barry Irby
>I don't know if red oak is particularly prone to this, but it helps to use really sharp sandpaper. Dull paper tends to dig away the soft part before you have a chance to smooth the hard parts. A hard or at least firm backing pad helps some too. Someone said you should use sandpaper like you bought it with somebody else's money.
Re: Red Oak
William Duffield, on the Cohansey
>Red oak doesn't have that problem. Unlike softwoods with alternate hard and soft areas, red oak is of consistent hardness throughout the year. The problem is the rings of large earlywood pores, with can have a tendency to "tear on dotted line". When sanding red oak, I find much less problem with earlywood erosion than with other ring porous hardwoods like ash and chestnut. However, it does have a strong tendency to split along the rings, especially if you get a catch or your turning tools get dull. That's the same set of working characteristics that makes it imperative to predrill screw holes when doing flat woodworking with it. You will probably want to find a method for filling pores, because they are large. Lots of techniques and materials work, depending on the effect you are looking for. French polish with a pumice filler is another good way to show off the pores and ray flecks, and is easy to apply on the lathe.
Re: Red Oak
The Wood Spinner / Bill Hale
>Doug, John mentions turning your lathe black but do not forget to also clean your tools. The acid in the wood turns all metal black and will pit the ways on the lathe if left there.
I pre oil and every time the shavings pile a little I blow off everything. When finished I wipe down all of the metal, re oil and wipe down again.
Also, it turns great.
Good turning and be safe
Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.
Re: Red Oak
GaryG in MD
>John, Barry, William,
Thanks for your comments; they are very informative. I have several red oak bowl blanks roughed out and dry (significant warping!), so I'll be experimenting with techniques, such as various pore fillers and darkening with ammonia or iron-soaked vinegar. I love to play. I've been filling some small worm tracks with brass key filings and CA, and find that it complements the red oak color very nicely.
Gary
Re: Red Oak
Philip Duffy
>Let me suggest you use Dave Smith's Denatured alcohol to start the drying of your oak ruff bowls. Follow his drying method and in a couple weeks you will have some nice stock to bring to a smooth finish. Phil