We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I am new to finials and not too good with the real delicate ones so I didn't even attempt that with this really dry walnut. But something is wrong. Is it too big period? Too Wide? The neck too big? Too tall? Help! It is not glued in yet so I can make another one but I am not sure what is wrong. I just know it's not right. Maybe I should not use a finial at all? I really don't want to screw up this little form. I love the bark inclusion which is the color of walnut.
>Carole, simply a beautiful piece. I think I agree with you, this finial is just too big all the way around. The height might be ok, but the heft is way too much. You might thin out the base as well as thin out the body of the finial. All this and a buck might get you a bad cup of coffee.
>Yeah, I think you're right Doug. The more I look at it the more I think everything needs to scaled down. I need to find some walnut that is not quite so bone dry. Seems like if I look at it is splinters. :( I will try again tomorrow. May try Cocobolo.
>I don't know Carole. It does not look "way too big all around" to me. In fact, I stared at it for a while and think that just a little faster taper from bulb to point might be just the ticket.
Sure, of course, naturally you COULD make a skinny little delicate finial like every other top you see. I like those too, but this piece, which is extraordinary btw, has a balance that works. Try keeping the fat bulb and making a long(ish) tailed raindrop shape; might be really cool.
>After yet another look, maybe just flatten the top (below the finial bulb) a bit. Like I said, you seem to be very close to an awesomely balanced composition. I like it.
Autocritic is a good thing in general, but carried to extreme becomes a problem. That piece looks good INMO, to my eye this piece is balanced, perhaps just take a small shaving from the finial, all around, specially at the bottom of the base.
I like it. I think I would like it a little more if the finial was just a little smaller. Right now it overpowers the form. The proportion of the finial is a little "fat" for the height of it. My guess is the base of the finial should be about one-third the diameter of the form and it looks to be about 40% now, so I'm not suggesting a big reduction.
This is just my opinion and it should not be confused with the opinion of someone who knows what they are talking about. ;^)
>Carole, I overall like it, Folks talk about it being too heftie etc... Cut the center out of it...Like those ornaments, would that work? KevinT in Thunder Bay
>This will be the first time I have ever made a suggestion as so far as form. For my taste the base of the finial should be be thinner so it flows in harmony with the hollow form. I also think it should be a little more delicate where it bulbs out. I think the base can support the height of the finial but I would have to see after the first two have been done. The base is really nice, very classic.
Since you have not glued it in, make an alternative top. Your thought on a more dense wood is good. I have just started turning finials and like to use dogwood and dye it black.
Put each finial in and the one that you like most is the correct one!
My opinion is worth everyting you paid for it(ha), Lan
>Carol, I'm laughing at myself for offering advice on form, but here goes....
I would cut the bottom off to make the edge thinner so that the base of the finial would flow more with the top of the form. Less of a step from one to the other. I think you want the finial to sit in the top of the form as if it were part of it. If can, eliminate the step around the edge and try to have the surfaces flow together.
I would make the bulge considerably smaller and keep most of the height.
That is a gorgeous piece of wood in the form itself and you have done a great job. I think the final should be more black than brown, to match the bark. Try dipping the finial in ebonizing solution once you get it right. (steel wool and vinegar) Or turn one out of some really black wood and minimize the grain in the finial so as not to detract form the grain in the piece.
>The height of the finial is very close to the height of the base, and this creates a tension between the two. I agree with other suggestions that a smaller version of the present top profile would give greater harmony to the overall presentation, and I really like the inclusion detail in the base. I would also agree that another choice of wood for the finial would aid in the production ease, then dye to color of choice. I usually use a hard maple when coloring is an option- its much less problematic for holding details and takes dye readily.
One good way to evaluate your options is with a sketch or, since you've already have an excellent photo, with a bit of Photoshop. I didn't take the time to do it cleanly (the background is especially hacked), but the attached image shows two simple thinning options. Note that the perspective is also trampled a bit with a simple horizontal scaling. It's harder to acually adjust the curves with Photoshop, but the Perspective and Free transforms can help some, as can the various distortion filters.
Very pretty form, classic shape - I personally think a variety of options would "work". The dark finial ties well to the high contrast of the bark inclusion bordered nicely by the lighter sapwood band. Remember that walnut will lighten over the years when exposed to light, so another wood that tends to darken or a bit of dye might help preserve the wonderful color balance. Is this a hollow box?
Two thinning Photoshopped options, with the original in the center:
Perhaps if you spend a few hours making a bunch of finials you will find some design elements that you like.
Make sure you make a couple of test finials at the extremes. That is, one as just a collar and another as long and thin as you dare. You can also try offset finials, curly finials, winged finials. capped finials...
What's wrong with your's? I find the finial to evoke a feeling of whimsy in me. It makes me smile and think of watching old movies with a middle east desert theme.
>I like the comparison here. I feel that proportions are the most important element. The vessel itself is very attractive but the large finial catches your eye first and sort of overpowers the piece.
I suggest that the finial on the right is getting close. I'd make it a little slimmer yet. Shorten the height of the finial base. Make the thin area above the base even thinner.
Carole, I must say, you've come a long way in just a short time. I admire your ability to take on just about anything.
>This morning I have been playing with PS (as did JKJ) and found something of more pleasing proportions. The problem is to execute it. I need a different wood - one that is more dense and will hold the detail, cut cleanly and can be dyed. Don't have much that meets those standards, unfortunately. Now I am wishing I had come home with a chunk of African Blackwood I saw in Woodcraft when I was in the city! My thought at the time was this stuff is just too expensive for me to be using right now. Sigh...woulda, coulda, shoulda. Maybe I will try holly and Kiwi.
BTW this little piece of cedar was rescued from the trash just to play with. It was another one of those "corners" left from cutting circular blank. I'm going to quit throwing ANYTHING away!
>I like the one on the right best. The finial still seems to be a little "chunky", with the base of the finial a little thick. The finial itself needs to shed a little weight also, even though the diameter of the thickest part is about right.
>Thanks, Wally. You should see the boxes of stuff I've turned in the past 9 months that are tossed in the attic hidden from view forever! Yuck! LOL I will spending most of the day in the shop trying to turn something a little more delicate that doesn't overpower the base. I hope my skew chisel is in a good mood today!
>Why does this need a finial at all? The coloring and pattern of the grain speaks for itself. Anything you add takes away from what is naturally there. The focal point should be the horizontal lines of the natural wood pattern. The vertical lines of the finial just adds confusion.
Sorry, but I think you are trying to do too much at once. There are e places for finials, but this isn't one of them. There is nothing that you can do to this finial that will make it compatible with the rest of the piece.
If you insist on adding something, how about just a very small and thin collar??
This is a really cute piece. I haven't read the other posts yet but in my eyes I think the finial is a bit too chubby. The hollow is very nice, plump and lovely....but I think it needs a daintier finial to keep the eye moving up the piece. I get stuck on the chubby part of the finial. The shape of the finial looks fine to me....perhaps a smaller diameter base to it?...but over all I like the shape of the finial....I just think it might look more in tune to the form below if it were more slender.
>Russ, I just didn't like it too much with nothing or with a small collar. It looked dumpy to me. It's only 2 1/4" tall and it is so small that I had to have a larger opening for that size piece than I liked to hollow with any of the tools I currently have. The ironic thing is it is one of my better hollowing jobs, consistent wall thickness all the way down and smooth without sanding and here I am going to close it up! LOL I guess I could make it a stopper so it can be opened and displayed with or without the top.
>I'm with Wally, which I admit, given his eye for beautiful form and design, isn't a very chancy place to be! ;^) Your original was starting to look like a finial (or maybe a wine stopper) with an astounding little hollow form hung underneath it -- the slimmer finial goes a long way to showcasing that little beauty, but not quite far enough, I think. Smaller and shorter will allow the viewer to concentrate on the little H.F., while lending a little height and grace to the whole thing.
BTW: that really is a beautiful little piece -- is it Walnut, too, or just the finial ? That didn't strike me as Walnut at a glance...
I also like the comparison in Photoshop -- I have to learn how to do that.