Goblet
tek-Brunswick, Ohio
>I made this for my daughter and her husband for their first wedding anniversary! It is made of Red Elm (aka Slippery Elm). I tried to make the captured rings look like wedding bands.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Goblet
tek-Brunswick, Ohio
>I made this for my daughter and her husband for their first wedding anniversary! It is made of Red Elm (aka Slippery Elm). I tried to make the captured rings look like wedding bands.
Re: Goblet
kevinT in T Bay
>those rings look very danity... Time consuming I would think. Nice gift.
Subjective comments
tek-Brunswick, Ohio
>These are purely my opinions and aren�t meant to offend anyone. I�ve been looking at goblets lately. I think the base looks too clunky when its diameter is as large as the top diameter. I made my base smaller, but maybe by too much. I�m not usually a big fan of captured rings. I think most of the time they don�t really fit in with the design and are usually too large. Here I think they serve a purpose and don�t overpower the rest of the piece. Feel free to comment on how I could improve this design or tell me your opinions differ from mine.
Tom
Re: Goblet
Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario
>Very Nicely Done!
take care,
Jim
thanks
tek-Brunswick, Ohio
>
Re: thanks Jim
tek-Brunswick, Ohio
>
Re: Goblet
Dick Parr
>Beautiful job and some pretty wood. Those rings had to take some time to get them down that size.
I really like the overall proportions of the goblet and the rings really set it off.
Dick
Re: Goblet - Nice, and such delicate rings!
JL
>
Re: Subjective comments
John Lucas
>That is a really nice goblet. Well done. I would agree with you on the base. I would like to see it a hair larger in diameter but possibly thinner. Sometimes you can add a little raised detail about a 1/2" in from the outside. This makes it look more delicate while still leaving the mass. The goblet bowl bothers me a little and I can't quite put my finger on it. I think maybe it's too short. The shape is perfect.
I like that you tapered the stem and I absolutely love the rings.
Re: Subjective comments
Ed Kelle
>I think it is a good looking goblet. I hope you put their names on the bottom and wedding the date as well. I just did that for a pair of goblets for a wedding present and it made them a big hit. Great work!
Re: Subjective comments
Barry Turner
>Well, I don't claim to be an expert by any means, but I'll express my opinion. I like the captive rings.......they look like Wedding Rings, I'm sure that was the intent. I agree the base is too small. Maybe.......the goblet bowl would look better if the sides weren't so straight. It's a very nice looking goblet. I find them very difficult to do........maybe that's the reason I have done a grand total of one! (If you're wondering, "No", it didn't look nearly as good as this one!)
thanks (gloat)
tek-Brunswick, Ohio
>Thanks to all of you for your input. More comments/ideas are still welcome. I also got an opinion from a professional. Al Stirt is demoing at our club (The North Coast Woodturners) this weekend. He critiqued my piece along with the other pieces on the club show and tell table. He thought that the curve from the side to the bottom of the bowl part of the goblet needed a slight amount of refining. The Inside of the bowl follows the outside and has the same problem. I think I made the transition from side to bottom a little to abrupt. He didn't think the base was too small, but I'm still not so sure. He is fun to watch demo. He has been turning bowls since the early 70's. If you are not familiar with his work he does a lot of carving and texturing on his bowls. I was able to get in on a group lesson he gave on Friday. I think it improved my tool technique for bowls and I got to try some texturing techniques.
Re: thanks (gloat)
Keith Tompkins
>Hi tek, nice piece! I tend to make my stems thinner, so to me your stem seems a bit heavy. The foot may be a touch small, but a thinner stem would make it seem more balanced.
Goblets are fun....they are what I turn for practice.
Al Stirt
John Lucas
>Al is one of the nicest turners I've met. He has come to the Craft center twice and I try to drive out and at least eat dinner with him and the class. He is so knowledgeable about form and design.