We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Someone asked why he was told not to use a goughout gouge on a bowl blank. A lot of people said the tang was too small and might break. This is true but what makes the gouge tang break is the force created on the outer diameter of the blank. Most spindle work is limmited to about 4" or less and a roughout gouge can handle this. The force on a blank to make a 12" bowl is much greater with the lathe running at the same speed. I am sure there is a formula for this but you can see and feel the difference the size of the blank makes as you turn up the speed. My lathe will take a blank almost 24" across and I start roughing so slow you can almost see each corner as it passes.
>I think you are right but I think there are other reasons as well. When roughing out a bowl it's not unusual to have the tool hanging over the tool rest by several inches. This is due to rough chain saw marks, limb protrusions, uneven bark ets. The rough out gouge just can't take that much force when you have several inches hanging over the tool rest.
The other problem I think is that it is very easy to get a catch on one of the wings because they stick up so prominently compared to a side ground bowl gouge.
>One other problem, it's possible to split the end grain as it comes around and have a 4" splinter come down the flute and stick in your hand. I would recomend NOT using the tool for bowls the chance for a problem is too great.
>Anthony touches on another problem with the roughing gouge: the shape invites you to present it straight on to the wood. That works fine on a spindle but on a bowl it will dig straight into the end grain. At minimum it wll split a big chunk off the blank.
Try to come in at any kind of angle to avoid that and you'll find you can't do it while keeping the point of support from the toolrest directly under the cutting part of the edge. The tool will twist and catch.
>Sounds like there are a number of people out there who, like me, have experimented with roughing bowls with a spindle roughing gouge. I solved the tang problem quite simply. I sawed it off, got a piece of 5/8" drill rod and had my local garage man weld the rod on the tool as a new tang. As for being dangerouis -- it is if you try knocking the corners off, working as you would with a piece of spindle work. NEVER tackle the out of round material first. This is what has caused accidents. If you try to knock off the corners on the edge of the bowl blank first, you are cutting into end grain. This is where most of the big splinters come from -- and the bent tangs. Instead, start dead center on the bowl blank. Then cut toward the outside edge. This means you are now removing the wood by cutting across the grain -- just as you would if you were using the spindle roughing gouge for spindle work. You are using the tool as it was meant to be used. As for the big rough corners on the outer edge -- sneak up on them from behind. Keep cutting from the center of the face of the bowl blank out toward the outer edge and the big out of round areas will disappear with barely a whimper. Ii would not recommend this technique to a beginner -- or to anyone turning small bowls. But my small bowls are 14 to16 inches in size and my large ones are over 30 inches. I need to remove large quantites of wood in a hurry and this does it. And I have never had an accident doing this in seven years and multiple transport truck loads of wood. (touch wood!) Two other things worth mentioning. If you grind back the top corners on the tool about 1/4 inch, you reduce the potential for the corners to get caught. Also, I have found the most effective size of gouge, for use on my 3hp Oneway is a 1 1/2" (outside measure) roughing gouge (1 1/4" flute). I am still using the old Sorby I modified years ago and have modified a Oneway gouge to replace it when the time comes. I have also modified a larger gouge I had and found it does not work nearly as well. I also bought a P&N gouge which is the perfect design, but is a quarter inch too small. Just does not take of the wood as efficiently. Also, once the corners are gone, revert to a bowl gouge. It cuts faster than a roughing gouge once you are actuallly cutting wood. The roughing gouge works better when there is a lot of air under the tool.