Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

Posts

Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

#1

Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

Ryan Dicker in Renfrew, Ontario

>Hi.

Im Ryan from Renfrew, Ontario. I'm 16 and just bought my first lathe about a year ago and would like to get into some bowl turning. I wouldn't consider myself to be new to turning, but maybe just inexperienced with the bowl turning aspect, so bear with me.

I had been preparing a list of things to pick up at the upcoming Ottawa Wood Show and was viewing the Henry Taylor roughing gouges from Lee Valley. It states that they are not to be used for bowl turing. So do they mean that they can't be used for bowl turning what so ever or that they should not be used for the inside part of the bowl and can be used to rough the outside?

I included the link to the Lee Valley website where the gouges are listed.

Thanks in advance,

Ryan


Lee Valley - Henry Taylor Roughing Gouges

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

#2

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks

Russell L. Babbitt Jr.

>The roughing gouge can be too aggressive on bowl blanks causing the relatively thin tang to break. Use a bowl gouge to do your bowls both inside and out.

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

#3

JL

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

JL

>Don't use roughing gouges for bowl blanks. As Russell said, the tang may break. Think of it this way - a 3/8" bowl gouge has a shaft of steel extending into the handle that is about 1/2" in diameter. A roughing gouge has a thin tang that is maybe a little bit over 1/4" in thickness extending into the handle. You might get away with using a roughing gouge many times - then again, you might "catch" it the wrong way and snap it at the tang. Then you would be out a roughing gouge. If you want to get the larger bowl gouge (1/2") for roughing and the 3/8" for finishing.


Lee Valley Bowl gouge

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

#4

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks

Jim Pugh, Ohio

>One more comment - most bowls are turned "side grain" vs "end grain" which is another reason the roughing gouge is not the tool of choice. If you should decide to turn a bowl "end grain" then you could use the roughing gouge on the outside. However, as was stated in the other replies, the bowl gouge is the way to go and you will find it very user friendly even for some spindle projects.

You will need to learn about "fingernail grinds" and how to do them. Check in the upper left hand corner on this screen to find the 'grinds library'.

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

#5

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks

Jim Pugh, Ohio

>Well, it used to be in the upper left. Now I see it in the upper right. ;o)

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

#6

CAUTION *LINK*

Glenn Hodges

>Ryan, when I first started turning bowls about 6 years ago people were taling about using a roughing gouge to rough out a bowl, so I assumed they were talking about a spindle roughing gouge. I used mine, and bamm the shaft broke because it is to thin where it goes into the handle. Bowl turners should make sure new turners do not use spindle roughing gouges on bowls. If you want a big roughing gouge to use on a bowl look at these P&N ones. I use the 5/8 and 7/8 as well as the smaller ones. You might notice the large shafts on the tools. I enjoy making my own handles for my gouges.

Glenn, Nashville, GA


P&N Tools

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

#7

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks

Barry Irby

>There is some confusion over the designation of sizes for bowl gouges. Some name them by the size of the piece of steel they are made of. Most are made from a steel or High Speed Steel rod like a dowel. If the rod were a 1/2" in diameter, some people call it a half inch gouge. If the flute were ground out to 3/8" wide, some would call it a 3/8" gouge. I can't remember whether it the English tools or the American Tools that do it which way.

I have a bowl gouge with a 5/8" diameter shaft and the Ellsworth grind on it. I like it a lot and would buy it again. I also like the round bottom flute and it's about a half inch wide. Get one with a long handle, it helps with balance.

If you are interested, you should get Bill Grumbine's video on bowl turning and also David Ellsworth's. Both well worth the money.

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

#8

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

Sean Troy

>One of the best and easiest tools I have used for roughing bowl blanks from start to finish is the Texas toothpick. With a little practice, this tool works like a charm. Also great for roughing out hollow forms.


http://www.woodturningtools.net

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

#9

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks

Bill Neddow

>Ryan, look me up when you get to the Ottawa Wood Show. I will be down at the Valley Woodturners display (where all the turning are at one end of the building) for most of the weekend. I will also be giving a demo on bowl turning just after lunch on Sunday. I will be happy to walk you through the process (with all its variations) and talk about tools with you. So will any of the dozen or so other club members. (That's why we are there!) Just for background, you can get some info about me at http://www.billneddow.com. Our club website is http://valleywoodturners.userworld.com

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

#10

Ryan...

Bill Howatt

>Personally, I don't think you will need any encouragement to look Bill Neddow up at the Ottawa Woodshow but just in case, he is a kind gentleman with a wealth of experience. The only thing scary about him is the fierce gouge he uses to rough bowls.

Talking to him is one of the smartest things you can do to learn about any aspect of turning.

Bill

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

#11

Brad Vietje

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks

Brad Vietje

>Ryan/Barry,

Generally, bowl gouges are measured by the width of the flute, while spindle gouges by the diameter of the round stock -- but, as Barry points out, not always so.

Ryan -- after you meet with the Bill's at the turning conference, get a top-quality bowl gouge, pick a grind you like (take the advice of your mentor here), and learn how to sharpen it. For swept-back grinds, such as the Ellsworth, spend the money on the sharpening jig so you get the same bevel shape every time. Then practice, practice, practice...

Lots of small bites with a sharp bowl gouge will be just as fast as fewer big bites with a big 'ole roughing gouge, will be easier on your lathe, your tools, and especially easier on you ! The bowl gouge is also a much more versatile tool for many different aspects of turning, and you can do the entire bowl, start to finish with a well-used sharp bowl gouge and some practice.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

#12

Re: Ryan...

JamieDonaldson

>and Bill makes some of the most beautiful bowls you could ever hope to make- do check him out while you have the chance.

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

#13

Re: Thanks

Ryan Dicker in Renfrew, Ontario

>Thanks for all of the speedy and informative responses.

I will certainly be over to the Valley Woodturners area to ask a question or two. Unfortunatly, I won't be around on Sunday to see Bill at the turning seminar, but I should be around to see you Friday afternoon.

I already have the 3/8" Henry Taylor bowl gouge which I can use for finishing cuts. Would the P&N 1/2" or 5/8" be a good option as a bowl roughing gouge? Is the P&N of similar quality as the Henry Taylor?

Thanks again

Ryan

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

#14

Re: Thanks

Bill Howatt

>I have a P&N detail gouge and consider it just fine and I have heard positive comments about P&N tools. Note that the P&N tools from LV come unhandled but it is a nice exercise to make a handle. Be careful comparing gouge sizes. The English method is to list the maximum width of the flute so a 1/2" gouge is usually 5/8" diameter stock which is how my Sorby measures out. P&N (Australian) sizes listed in LV are the diameter of the stock which is the typical North American way of stating size. This may be simplified as to region but you get the idea (if you didn't know it already!).

I use my 1/2"(English) Sorby to do roughing and it works very well. However I would probably consider it too light and thus slow if I were a production turner rather than a hobbyist. Remember that uou also have to have enough power in your lathe to take big cuts off big blanks.

Bill

Re: Tools for Roughing Bowl Blanks *LINK*

#15

Re: Thanks

Bill Neddow

>I cannot see any real difference in the quality of the steel between the Henry Taylor and the P&N. It used to be that all the good steel came from Sheffield, England (Henry Taylor, Sorby, etc.) but not any more. If you can swing a 12 inch piece of wood on your lathe, go for the P&N 5/8" bowl gouge. Otherwise, the 1/2" gouge will probably do. Put the money you save toward a sharpening jig -- a necessity if you are going to use the fingernail grind on the tool. Looking forward to meeting you Friday.