Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

*OT* HVAC *OT*

Posts

*OT* HVAC *OT*

#1

*OT* HVAC *OT*

W.C. Turner

>I'm pretty sure I've seen some HVAC contractors on here before, so, here's my question.

My 4 ton, natural gas, HVAC central heat & air has died. At least, I've just discovered that the heat has died. Considering the ridiculously high price of gas (all forms), we are currently experiencing, I'm not sure if I should replace the unit with another natural gas, or maybe go to a heat pump, something that I would never have considered in the past.

What do the experts say? Oh yeah, let's hear from the non-experts also.

Thanks,

W.C.

Re: *OT* HVAC *OT*

#2

Re: *OT* HVAC *OT*

Stuart Johnson

>I like a heat pump because you don't have that hot blast that I associate with other types. Remember though, you will have a much higher electric bill. So when it comes to dollars and cents you need to factor in your local electric rates. From what I understand electric rates here are lower than natural gas but we are still going to get a 24% increase because the rates are based on the natural gas rates.

Personally, I think the high rates are caused by a combination of profit greed and politics and not so much a result of supply and demand. If I'm right I think they will be coming down. If I'm wrong 90% of us are going to need more coats in the winter and fans in the summer.

Re: *OT* HVAC *OT*

#3

Re: *OT* HVAC *OT*

JimQ

>The biggest factor in that choice is, "Where do you live?" In Phoenix, AZ, a heat pump now beats natgas. In NJ it is the other way around. A heat pump cannot generate enough heat from subfreezing outside temperatures to maintain comfortable temperatures inside for any length of time. And as was pointed out in the previous post, you need to look at your local electric rates, but you also have to compare your local natgas rates. Then factor in the relative efficiencies of the 2 units you are considering, (ie. BTU output per KW or Therm) then you can compare the operating costs per BTU of heat produced.

JimQ

Re: *OT* HVAC *OT*

#4

Re: *OT* HVAC *OT*

Claudia Hayward

>I'm not an expert but I did install a heat pump several years ago. There are basically 2 systems; one removes the heat from the air, the other removes heat from the ground. If you get heat from the air, the pump becomes less efficient as the temperature drops (around freezing and below) although the heat can be supplemented by electric heating coils. This is what I have and find that in cold weather (not really cold since I live in the Pacific NW)) I am much more comfortable if I fire up my wood stove (with all that turning scrap). The other alternative is the geothermal variety where the fluid is pumped through a system of tubes buried in the ground. Since the ground (if you go down far enough) is always at a constant temperature this system is suitable for cold climates. This system is expensive however and probably should only be considered if you are planning on staying in your house for quite a few years.

I really like the heat pump system and even though natural gas is relatively cheap where I live, glad I chose it.

Hope this helps...

Re: *OT* HVAC *OT*

#5

Re: *OT* HVAC *OT*

W.C. Turner

>Thanks for all replies.

I was able to get a very good deal on a natural gas unit,so, I took advantage of it.

Re: *OT* HVAC *OT*

#6

They have come a long way, baby

John Trant (Baltimore/DC corridor)

>Almost two years ago, I replaced my 20 year old heat pump and air handler with a new ones. The new technologyies are remarkable. I HATED the old heat pump and swore I would not get another. However, the volitility of the petrochemical market and the new advances in heat pumps/air handlers made me rethink my position. With the new system, the electric bills are reduced substantially and the comfort level in the house is vastly improved. My recommendation would be to get a modern heat pump and new air handler.

John