Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Burle Ives for criique

Posts

Burle Ives for criique

#1

Burle Ives for criique

albertabob

>I haveve had his wood for about a year and finally made a container from it.

The opening was too large to begin with and I am not sure how to change it.

Any suggestions?

Bob


img

Re: Burle Ives for criique

#2

Re: Burle Ives for criique

Ed Kelle

>how about putting on a collar with a smaller opening? A dark wood could enhance this a bit

Re: Burle Ives for criique

#3

Re: Burle Ives for criique

Bob R

>A dark brown top would be as designed, or as planned.

My 2 cents worth

Bob R

WestMac Turning

Re: Burle Ives for criique

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Burle Ives for criique

Keith Tompkins

>HI Bob, what makes you feel the opening is too large? We as turners have been taught that a small opening is the desirable goal...larger openings are a sign of low skill.

This may be true to a certain degree, but the size of the opening should be in proportion to the size and shape of the form. A tiny opening is not the only consideration...on your form, the opening seems just fine to me. However, to be in balance the foot must be smaller than the opening.

At a recent demo, I was asked...why do we see so many long-stemmed turned goblets? Simple..the long, slender stem is indicative of skill. It has nothing to do with balance or proportion at all. I think we see many forms hollowed through a tiny hole for the same reason. Just my opinion..

Re: Burle Ives for criique

#5

Re: Burle Ives for criique

Curt Fuller

>Amen! to your opinion Keith.

And I think it's a beautiful bowl, as is.

Re: Burle Ives for criique

#6

Re: Burle Ives for criique

kevinT in T Bay

>the picture in the other forum, show the form better. But nice job there Drew

Re: Burle Ives for criique

#7

Re: Burle Ives for criique

Jim King

>Put it up for sale and when you made twice what you think it is worth make an answer to the critics. Nice is nice anywhere. Good luck.

Re: Burle Ives for criique

#8

Re: Burle Ives for criique side view 

albertabob

>


img

Re: Burle Ives for criique

#9

Re: Burle Ives for criique

albertabob

>I Think it was an ash of some kind ???


img

Re: Burle Ives for criique

#10

Re: Burle Ives for criique side view

George Van in WI

>If this opening is too large why is this one in the Heard museum?

Nice burl Bob!


img

Re: Burle Ives for criique

#11

Re: Burle Ives for criique

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>ditto

Re: Burle Ives for criique

#12

Re: Burle Ives for criique side view

Eduardo Sarmiento Hall,lima peru

>Well It looks well balanced and good grain oh heck is ok?