Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Green Wood?

Posts

Green Wood?

#1

Green Wood?

Mike G. in SC

>Can you turn green wood? It's been 20 years since I turned anything on a lathe and I can't remember.

Thanks, Mike G in SC

Re: Green Wood?

#2

Re: Green Wood?

Carole in VA

>Definitely! I prefer green wood...turns easy, no dust (with some woods you may need a rain coat!). Rough it out and dry before finish turning. See the Dave Smith's article in the articles section about using denatured alcohol to dry rough turned blanks.

Re: Green Wood?

#3

Re: Green Wood?

JKJ in East TN

>Green wood is a favorite of turners since it turns so easily. It is also usually free. Finished turnings made from green wood will shrink and warp which some use to advantage while others handle as Carole mentioned by turning rough and thick, drying, then finish turning. To prevent cracking while drying, I coat roughed turnings with Anchorseal and let them dry on the shelf for some months. Others in more of a hurry use soap soaking, boiling, alcohol, paper bags, or magic incantantations.

There is an excellent book Turning Green Wood by O'Donnell covering all aspects of turning and handling.

JKJ

Re: Green Wood?

#4

Re: Green Wood?

Curt Fuller

>I've tried most of those drying techniques with varying degrees of sucess. Could you please expand on the 'magic incantantations' though.

Re: Green Wood?

#5

JKJ is too old to learn new magic incantantations

Dave Smith, Longview, WA

>

Re: Green Wood?

#6

Re: Green Wood?

JKJ in East TN

>>Could you please expand on the

>'magic incantantations' though

I�ve read a great deal about drying wood and of various methods for drying roughed bowls. Air dry on a rack, paint just the end grain with anchorseal, paint the entire bowl, wrap in paper bag, paint the ends and bag, soak in alcohol and air dry, soak and bag, soak and wrap the outside, microwave, soak in soap solution, boil in water, boil and bag with sawdust, etc., etc., etc.

The purpose of any of these drying methods is to enhance and/or accelerate the stabilization process. Each method has supporters who state the evidence of their experience. One method may indeed work as well or better than another method for a given piece of wood, but the point is no one knows for sure - a magical incantation may have worked just as well for that blank.

Lacking are careful scientific studies. The evidence I�ve seen to date is simply reported successes, but without proper controls it is unknown whether another method would have worked as well or better. "I�ve used method X for a year and lost very few pieces." How can we know if method Y would have worked as well or better? Perhaps doing nothing at all would have worked as well for those particular blanks under those drying conditions. Funny thing - I personally know a turner who rough turned many bowls over the years and air dried them in boxes with no treatment - guess what, he lost "very few pieces."

The variables to consider are staggering: variations between wood species, variations between trees, the orientation within the tree, the starting amounts of free and bound water in the wood, wood density, moisture and density gradients inside the blanks, the ambient temperature, relative humidity, variations in temperature and RH during the drying process, the roughed wall thickness, the roughed bottom thickness, treatment times (for soaking, boiling, etc), treatment solution variations (i.e., the amount of water in the alcohol or soap), etc. Most turners are "artists" rather than "scientists" and we don�t want be concerned with all those details. If something appears to work we will use (and promote it) even without understanding.

Don�t misunderstand, I�m all for using what works or even appears to work. I do not personally have enough data to promote or detract from any specific method. But I suspect many others like me would like to see (or do!) more study and try to understand the mechanisms behind these methods.

It may be from my science/technical background, but without understanding, any method seems not far removed from voodoo!

JKJ

BTW, my only experience with alcohol drying was not positive but it also proves nothing. I air dried a number of pieces of a certain kind of wood cut a certain way, first soaking about half in alcohol for a certain amount of time. Both sets warped a certain amount, some badly.

Re: Green Wood?

#7

Re: JKJ is too old to learn new magic incantantati *LINK*

pmb

>The latest New Zealand Creative Wood magazine has published Dick Veitch's findings about soaking wet-turned articles in soap/detergent solutions. If you don't get the publication, he may be able to provide you with the details. He can be reached via www.sawg.org.nz

pmb


http://wood.org.nz