Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Dust Protection Question- Long *LINK*

Posts

Dust Protection Question- Long *LINK*

#1

Dust Protection Question- Long *LINK*

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I have been wearing a North 7700 Series Half Mask Respirator in the sawmill for over 18 years. It fits very well and the filters have 99.97% minimum efficiency. I also have and sometimes wear the same in the shop. My face shield for turning can be worn when wearing the respirator.

I got the notion that I needed a better system (i.e. forced air) but because of arthritis in my cervical vertebra I am unable to handle the weight (Triton- 2 lbs). There are some lighter weight options however I started thinking why do I want to encumber myself like that when the North is doing a good job.

So, my question to everyone who has an educated opinion is - do the forced air respirators have any advantages over the North for those of us who do not have a beard?


North Respirator

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long *LINK*

#2

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long *LINK*

Danny Wells

>I recently purchased the new Triton respirator from Craft Supplies. It has a built-in visor and ear muffs. It is rather light weight, probably because the battery pack and filters are on a waist belt. It is comfortable, fairly quiet and the battery is long lasting between charges. The visor is kind of a bubble and the view is just slightly distorted. That's the only thing that bothers me a little because of the detail work I do.

I wasn't sure I would like a respirator, but I never did like the half mask unit I had (different brand) and my dust-b-gone just wasn't getting the job done.

The Triton is working well for me at the lathe and the rest of the shop. Here's a link from Craft Supplies website. Other catalogs also have the Triton.


Triton Respirator

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long *LINK*

#3

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Actually it was the Triton that I tried. Aside from the weight I found it rather bulky.

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long *LINK*

#4

Re: Dust Protection Question

Danny Wells

>Sorry, Barbara, I didn't notice that in your first post. Well, that's the only experience I've had.

I hope you find something that works for you.

Danny

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long *LINK*

#5

It's in the filters!

Bill Howatt

>Hi Barbara,

The real issue is "How good is the filtration?". Whether the air is forced or not is of no consequence if you aren't getting too hot or fogging the face shield. HEPA filters are considered the best I believe. So all other things being equal you have to look into the filter specs of your unit. You may be able to upgrade the filters for your respirator if you think it necessary.

I understand your concern about the weight of the Triton. I have one and use it all the time but I am also one of those people who tend to ignore things that others might find annoying. I do like its full-face shield and integrated hard-hat for flying blank protection.

Bill

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long *LINK*

#6

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long

Duane C.Leach

>Barbara- I think the main difference is that the filter you are useing does not have a face shield to protect your face,or eyes against chunks of wood flying off the lathe.

Duane

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long *LINK*

#7

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>My face shield fits over the mask.

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long *LINK*

#8

Re: It's in the filters!

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>That is a good point. The filters will filter out 99.97%. I will call North and get technical data.

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long *LINK*

#9

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long

Doug Trembath

>Hello, Barbara!

Compare the filtration of your respirator filters to that of the Triton, for example. With a proper fit, even HEPA filtration isn't much, if any, better than that, is it? Maybe they have HEPA cartridges for your present respirator?

My sense is that three hundredths of one percent is a pretty small number. Sometimes we forget, when we're comparing efficiency, that at least that much stuff is flying around in the ambient air, anyway, in pollens, normal dust, and so forth. Taking care of your lungs is important, but it seems to me that we run the risk of approaching the point of diminishing returns as we approach perfection. Sounds to me like you've been doing a lot better job of protecting yourself than most for a long time now, and I applaud your efforts.

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long *LINK*

#10

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Thanks Doug. I feel the same way about that .03%. There is more dust than that flying around when I change out of my dirty cloths. I have written North to ask them how the 7700 mask compared with the forced air systems, specifically the Triton and Airmate.

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long *LINK*

#11

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long

Fog Tanner

>The real key on the percentage is what is it a percentage of. If the numbers are based on 50 micron size particles, that isn't that great. Your body will stop that size particle. Its when you get into the under 40 micron size, especially the submicron partciles. Basicily, if you can see it, it is not going in your lungs. The dust on your cloths would fall in this catagoery. the really harmfull stuff is still floating around in the air out in your shop/studio/garage (depending on price of sales).

The Airstream has a rating of around 99% of .03 microns. The .03 micron is a fed standard. Whether its an Airstream or a half mask, if you get that kind of filtration, it will be somewhere into the next lifetime before you would have to worry about lung problems.

I am still saving for an Airstream and plan on buying one before the end of year. 3M will raise their price again next Feburary, so I need to get off top dead center. The reasons for the Airstream is 1) filtration - I have bad allergies and sinus problems, especially when I work with cedar (allergic to cedar, oak, and elm). 2) the helmet. I figure it is only a matter of time before another piece of wood comes off the chuck. The last one hit my Powervisor dead center on my nose. That faceshield really does work. Its just a matter of time before it hits my head. And that is one area of experience I will leave to Raffan, I have no desire for thirteen stitches in my scalp. 3) Its cheaper than a new set of lungs.

The Triton unit has an Australian rating which is comporable to the U.S., but I doubt that you will see a federal rating on it. I called 3M and talked to some of their tech guys. All those respirators, powered or not which carry a federal rating, are recertified every year. That costs for the certification, and one reason the Powervisor, Trend, and Trition all have ratings for nusience dust only. There are some other factors like airflow that figure into the rating also. Which puts it back on you to find what they will filter, percentage of filtration, and if you can live with it. For me its simple, if I put on the filtration unit (respirator or powered air), turn some cedar and not get a bad sinus headache - then its working. Even the fine particles will set off my allergies.

Fog

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long *LINK*

#12

Re: Dust Protection Question- Long

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Wow Fog, great information. Thanks!