Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

More on the bandsaw wars

Posts

More on the bandsaw wars

#1

More on the bandsaw wars

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi all,

I am in the process of putting an old Delta 14" bandsaw back in service. I have made a 6" riser block, bought my long bolt and a couple more dowel pins and ordered a couple of 1/4" 4 tooth 105" blades from McMaster-Carr. ($10.98 ea.) I think the tires will do O.K. for now. They are not as hard as I originally thought. I'm not sure why the original owner thought that they needed to be replaced. Anyway, I am now looking for a suitable motor.

Today I found a used 1 HP GE motor. It's rated continuous duty. It starts and runs good, but sounds like it has a little bearing noise. I can get it for $60. Should I buy now or hold out for a 1 1/2 HP, if I can find one? I am going to primarily be using it to cut turning blanks from wet wood.

Thanks,

Gary

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#2

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

Jay in TX

>Gary,

Slicing all that thick/wet wood? I have to be very gentle on mine (Jet 14") for most of what I'm cutting 5" or more in thickness. It has the stock (1 hp I think) motor and I use a 3/8" 3tpi timberwolf blade. If I'm not patient enough, I'm forced to dislodge the blank (usually to its demise) from the blade or vice-versa. I think Dominic Greco put a 2 hp on his after his shop got flooded a couple years back, and loves it. I'd hold out for a 2 hp unless you need to saw's services immediately.

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#3

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Thanks, Jay,

I was wondering if 2 HP was too much motor for this saw. I had forgotten Domenic's story, but I remember now how happy he was with the big motor. I guess you just can't have too much power. 8^]

I still haven't contacted the local motor repair guy or the local used woodworking tool guy, so the possibility is there that I could find a good price on a 2 horse.

Gary

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#4

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

ALBERTABOB

>If you go 2 hp you will need 230 volts x 9-10 amps on 14ga wiring to your saw.

If you go 1-1/2 you can get away with 115 volts at 20 amps on 12 gauge wire.

Depends on how far you are from the box and how many slots are available.

regards

Bob

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#5

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Thanks Bob,

Wiring is not a problem. I have 220 available if necessary. I'm looking now at a 3HP motor that I have on an old tablesaw. It let some smoke out sometime back, but I'm going to see what the repair cost would be.

Gary

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#6

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

The Wood Spinner / Bill Hale

>$ 60.00 for a motor with bad bearings sounds like a no brainer to me.

NO NO NO

Also hold for the 1.5

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#7

Ixnay on the reethay

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Don't go to 3hp, Gary. The Delta (and JET) castings and componants are not built to take the stain. It was reported in a thread on AAW that Delta tech states "nothing more than 2hp" for an upgrade.

M

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#8

ask Trent Bosch

Bob Elliott

>Contact Trent Bosch. It seems that once while demonstrating he mentioned that he put a 3 hp on a Delta or Jet (with riser blocks) and seemed to be happy with it.

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#9

just wondering

JKJ in East TN

>Gary,

This doesn't address your motor question, but...

I was cutting blanks last night and rough turned some of those red maple crotches. While bandsawing, I had an idea. It seems to me the blades we use, even those made specifically for resawing, are precision made specifically to cut things as nice and smooth as possible. Has anyone tried giving the teeth a bigger set? This would make a rude and crude blade and likely cut much less smooth. But for our purposes, who would care?

I wonder if it would cut better through green wood. It would at very minimum create a wider kerf. A wider kerf would allow more clearance for the blade, especially one with some junk sticking to the sides. In fact, since the side friction would be reduced, the junk may be less likely to "bake" onto the sides and be less a problem overall. A wider kerf should also allow cutting tighter curves with the same blade, perhaps let you use a 1/2" blade instead of a 3/8". It would be nice if we could get a more efficient cuts in wet wood from the same horsepower motor.

Perhaps just some teeth could be given the increased set to more evenly distribute the cut, perhaps alternating sides but skipping every other tooth already set.

Do any blade manufactuers specifically make a blade for cutting thick green slabs on a standard bandsaw? Seems like this use would benefit from blades similar to those optimized for band sawmill use. I haven't examined one of those blades, but my WoodMizer is on the way so I should be able to soon.

What do you think? I may experiment with this on my Delta.

JKJ

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#10

3Hp! Yikes!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Gary,

As much as I love MORE POWER, I'll have to agree with Mark on this. I always thought that I was pushing the envelope with a 2HP. Think of the extra torque you'll be putting that bandsaw's shaft under, not to mention the size (and weight) of the 3 HP motor!

You'll also need to buy new sheaves (pulleys) that will work with this, and your existing shaft. Finding the right combo to give me the proper speed was a slight chore with a 2HP. With it's thicker shaft, I'm not sure how easy this task would be with a 3HP.

For what it's worth, I found that the 2Hp motor gave me more than enough power to handle just about any resawing job. Last year I used my 14" Jet to resaw approx 300 bd ft of Red Oak for a friend at work. It never even flinched.

Odd you should be mentioning my old Jet Bandsaw now. This weekend I will finally be moving it out of my shop and over to my brother's. In turn, I will be getting a Chipper/Vac. Just in time to handle all those nasty leaves and branches that keep falling in my back yard!

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#11

Re: just wondering

Ed Kelle

>I got some for green wood from Suffolk Machinery. I've cut lots of blanks with it so far, seems to do a nice job. I think I have the 3/8 blade. the green wood ones are the AS models. here is their link

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: just wondering

Keith Tompkins

>Hi John, I think it would work, but would require more power to run, as the blade is removing more wood per tooth.

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#14

Re: just wondering

JKJ in East TN

>>but would require more power to run, as the

>blade is removing more wood per tooth.

Would that not depend somewhat on the feed rate?

JKJ

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#15

It works, but...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I've done that a few times and it helps. I haven't had any power issues with my 14" Delta with riser blocks, but I have found that blades with fewer teeth cut the wood a lot faster so I often reduce the blade's tpi by removing half of the teeth. Works really well for sawing/resawing thick blanks where surface appearance isn't important.

The but is: good/expensive blades have very hard teeth. If you try to give them too much set, they BREAK! Also, if you increase the set too much (more than 50%) the blade might not want to stay on the wheels. (Been there, done that!) The cheaper carbon-steel bandsaw blades are easier to set successfully, but they don't stay sharp nearly as long.

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#16

Re: It works, but...

JKJ in East TN

>>I've done that a few times and it helps

Ah, YOU'RE the one! I saved your excellent post from August 9 describing in detail how you sharpen. In looking at it again now, I see your comments about setting teeth at the bottom.

I have very much appreciated reading of your experience. With that plus Stephen Russel's article, I sharpen most of my bandsaw blades myself now.

Where do you get your diamond wheels? I found a possible source for round diamond "stones", made for resharpening sawmill band blades.

JKJ

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#17

George Balock

Re: It works, but...

George Balock

>Gary,

I recently upgraded the motor on my Jet 14" with riser from the underpowered 1 HP from jet to a Baldor 1.5 HP motor. What a difference! I decided on the 1.5 HP instead of 2 HP because I didn't want to run 220V for just that saw. I have yet to bog down the motor. I can feed as fast as it will go and not a problem. I had to cut a hole in the cabinet so that the motor would fit. It was well worth the upgrade in HP for cutting blanks. Good luck in your upgrade.

George

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#18

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

Scott Hogsten

>Go for the 1.5 and quite frankly look for a good quality motor they are usually worth the extra money. My general experience (and I am sure they are the exceptions) with electric motors is that you can pay the price now or pay it later. We ask a lot of a bandsaw and motor when we shove a big old wild grained piece of wood through. Paying a little extra for heavier windings and better brushes will pay off in the long run.

Scott

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#19

Re: It works, but...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I used the diamond burrs from Dremel and Sears. They were expensive and didn't work out very well for me. It seemed like the diamond grit got broken off until there was only stubs left and then the burr raised a huge burr in the gullet of the tooth. Definitely not good! Part of the problem might have been the speed - I was running the Dremel at full speed.

I switched to 5/32 chain saw sharpening bits, available everywhere. They are a lot cheaper and last for a good number of sharpenings, plus they don't raise a significant burr in the gullet of the tooth.

For sharpening the tops of the teeth I use a fine diamond hone. I like the Ez-Lap ones from Woodcraft, etc. They continue to work well even after the diamond abrasive has been knocked down. Probably get thirty or forty shapenings from one hone.

Re: More on the bandsaw wars

#20

Re: 3Hp! Yikes!

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Well, considering that this 3HP motor came off a fairly recent vintage aircompressor, it probably only puts out 2HP. I haven't checked the plate yet to see what the current draw is. I don't think it even has the large diameter shaft. I think I was able to use the original pulley when I put it on the tablesaw.

I'm going to pull it out of storage today and take it to the motor shop next week just to see what the cost of repair will be.

Gary