Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

AAW Goblet contest results are in

Posts

AAW Goblet contest results are in

#1

AAW Goblet contest results are in

Jim Ketron

>if you have been waiting for them!

Congrats to the winners!

Re: AAW Goblet contest results are in

#2

Re: AAW Goblet contest results are in

John Lucas

>Jim I had an entry in the competition so I was interested not only in who entered by the winners, of course. After I went through all the choices I had decided on the 4 that I thought should win. 3 of them won. Hope other people thought those were the winners as well.

Re: AAW Goblet contest results are in

#3

Re: AAW Goblet contest results are in

Jim Ketron

>John! I agree any of them could have won and those were nice that was chosen! And I could care less who won!

My point is this! How do you have a contest like this with only one judge?

Most contests that are judged have at least 3 judges Examples: Beauty pageants, dog shows, horse Shows; Even the Gong Show had 3 judges.

So I think it’s unfair to have one Judge, and one that says he is interested in nontraditional turnings! Do the guys that worked hard on their more traditional turnings matter?

Seems like the going thing for the AAW. And IMO it’s not helping get new members to join up, if the traditional turnings are just pushed away and you have to have some kind of embellishments added to be a nice turning

Re: AAW Goblet contest results are in

#4

Re: AAW Goblet contest results are in

Jim Ketron

>Dont get me wrong I like embellishments! But I also like the natural beauty of wood also.

Re: AAW Goblet contest results are in

#5

Re: AAW Goblet contest results are in

John Lucas

>Jim I agree with you to a point. I learned a long time ago that if you enter a contest ideally you should find out who the judge is and gear your entry toward their work. Most of us don't do that of course but people are biased by nature and will pick things they like.

I also agree that ideally a panel of judges would be better, more diverse with biases being less obvious. However the AAW contest is just a sort of game to make things interesting and get people to participate in the web site. I think it's been fun. Trying to put together a panel of judges would really be a pain. Now if money and big prizes were involved a panel of judges should be looked at.

Re: AAW Goblet contest results are in

#6

Re: AAW Goblet contest results are in

Ed Kelle

>I had picked #1 and 2 also. I figured no way in heck that I'd have a chance against all those great works I saw. But I entered anyway, and believe me, I am in total shock that I got third. Thrilled and honored as well.

I have to thank Keith Tompkins, because I would have never tried a goblet until I saw his demo up in Saratoga Springs in April. I learned a lot from this demo and I still have his helpful handout.

What really suprised me is that only 21 people entered the contest. I admit that quite a few times I wavered on entering, knowing the quality of works I have been seeing posted there. But I figured that at worst I would have more people see my work.

I think all the entries were really great. Congrats to all who entered.

Re: AAW Goblet contest results are in

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: AAW Goblet contest results are in

Keith Tompkins

>WOW Ed! Congratulations...Before I do a demo, I make sure the topic is one that will benefit someone in the audience, maybe help them become a better turner. If I can do that, I will have a successful presentation.

It is rewarding to see that people such as yourself attend these demos, and apply techniques that are presented. Congrats, and you just made my day!

Re: AAW Goblet contest results are in

#8

Re: AAW Goblet contest results are in

Pascal Oudet

>John, it was especially difficult to please the judge, since they changed it at the last minute ;-)

but would I have done my goblet differently, had I known Trent was the jury, instead of Alain Mailland ? probably not.

to answer something that has been said here and on the aaw forum, the journal was featuring some examples far away from a

"classical" goblet (I'm especially thinking of a piece by S Gleasner). many others were enhanced (thorns, piercing, ...).

so for me creating a "different" goblet was completely in line with the article.

anyway, that was fun, and I'm ready for the next contest ;-)

Pascal