Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

A REALLY dumb question!

Posts

A REALLY dumb question!

#1

Keith Tompkins

A REALLY dumb question!

Keith Tompkins

>Some woods, such as walnut or butternut are notorious for torn wood fibers on the exterior surface of bowl forms. As strange as this seems the best cure I have come up with is cutting from the rim to the base with a truly sharp spindle or detail gouge, skewing across the grain with tool rolled into the cut. This is dangerously close to the point where the tool will be pulled in to a huge catch.

Yes, I know it's the wrong direction, and I can't explain why it works. I have looked to see if this is a technique anyone has posted or written about, but have found nothing on the subject.

The result is dramatic, little or no torn grain fibers. The question is has anyone else tried this, and did it work for you? Why, since theoretically it should really lift the fibers as the cut is made?

I have tried this time after time, always seems to work...I hesitate to post this because of the responses it may generate..."You should really learn how to turn, etc." Yet the finish cutting from rim to foot is better than from foot to rim.......

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

#2

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

Phil Joines Krum, Texas

>Yes, ocationally. I made a set of scrapers just for that technique. They are 1 1/2" wide x 1/4" thick. The ends are slanted in opisite directions at about 45deg. The bevel is about 30 deg. to be very sharp. They are used standing on one edge at about 45deg. with a very light pull cut.

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

#3

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

JKJ in East TN

>>I have looked to see if this is a technique anyone

>has posted or written about, but have found nothing on the subject.

Someone mentioned this a while back in a thread about torn grain. (Was that you?)

JKJ

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

#4

Re: A REALLY dumb question! - Not

georgetroy

>I use a cut very similar to the one you expressed only with a bowl gouge. Richard Raffan a few years ago showed me this technique of laying the flute open, the rest is set at the center line and the cut is push around from rim to the bottom. I make a parting cut before I chase the tool around. I don't won't to balance into the chuck. As you get closer to the bottom the tool will tend to accelerate and one must be careful. You can also cut inside with an open flute from rim to center. We have push cuts and pull cuts all done in different ways with many tools, that is what makes woodturning so interesting as your ideas and techniques takes place right in front of you. GT

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

#5

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>Hi Keith,

I can't remember where I leaned this, but I use it all the time on natural edge bowls. I think it was John Jordan. I don't often have problems with Walnut, but it seems to keep the bark on the natural edges of any species. It is one of my favorite tecniques to get rid of the slight lifting of the grain at the bark edge.

I generally look over the top edge of the bowl when using this cut and just sneak up on it to keep from taking too large a cut. It does work great for me too!!

Dave

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

#6

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

Pascal Oudet

>Keith,

it's not with a spindle gouge, but David Ellsworth describes this cut in his bowl gouge video. and explains why it works better the "reverse" way. (but I'd need to review to video to be able to explain it here)

Pascal

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

#7

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

Bill Neddow

>I do the same thing, Keith -- and like you was somewhat reluctant to talk about it because I cannot explain why it works. I use both a bowl gouge and a spindle gouge and end up with a lot less tearout on soft or difficult woods. An added advantage is that I end up with better forms. Somehow, my eye/hand coordination works better going from the rim to the base on the outside of a bowl and I get much more subtle and pleasing lines in the shape of the bowl. As a matter of fact, I now make a pass "the wrong way" on almost all bowls as I near the final shape, just to establish the lines I want. Maybe it is because I am left handed!

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

#8

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

John Lucas

>Well I must be doing something different or not holding the gouge right but I tried running against the grain on a maple bowl I was having trouble with and no improvement at all. Even shear scraping didn't clean it up much. I tried my stewart Batty grind of 40 degrees and shear cutting as cleanly as I could. I'm not sure I totally understand the cut your are talking about.

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

#9

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Keith,

I have your answer - go back to segmented turning where you are only turning side grain. That way you can go either direction.

;)

Mark

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

Keith Tompkins

>HI Dave, I know David Ellsworth does the same technique also to keep the bark on.

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

Keith Tompkins

>HI john, the best way to describe it is a skewing cut, where the cutting edge is at quite an angle to the wood.

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

Keith Tompkins

>Very Funny! Seriously Mark, I have a couple of segmented pieces in the works.....they have been simmering on the back burner for a while.

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

Keith Tompkins

>HI John, possibly, but I didn't think I mentioned it...

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks everyone for your responses...I feel better now!

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

#15

Re: Keith--- don't say...

JamieDonaldson

>...skewing!!! Someone might think you meant you were using a skew! I hate to even consider the consequences!!!

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Keith--- don't say...

Keith Tompkins

>hmmmm, a SKEW! that gives me an idea! I'll be back. LOL:)

Just kidding! I didn't mean to imply that I use a skew chisel, if anyone mis-read my post. Thanks, Jamie.

Re: A REALLY dumb question!

#17

Re: Keith--- don't say...

JKJ in East TN

>Funny you mention the skew with cutting the "wrong" way. I was turning spindles in walnut tonight and was having a lot of trouble with one spot. I turned the skew chisel around and went "uphill" in that spot instead and the cut was smoother. Maybe it's the cooler weather.

JKJ