Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

This went poorly....

Posts

This went poorly....

#1

This went poorly....

Marc Phillips

>Heya all....

This has me scratching my head....

I made this bowl bottom jig, glued a piece of maple to the walnut funnel I made yesterday, let it dry for about 5 hours, then tried to turn the thing... I liked the funnel, so I thought attempting a save was worth the effort...

.... what a fiasco...

No matter which tool I used, it would catch... spindle gouge, bowl gouge, small scraper, larger scraper... nothing... finally I had a catch large enough to handgrenade the entire bowl into small pieces....

So...

I am gonna guess that the maple was oriented long grain... and that is how I cut it... so I was thinking it should have turned like a spindle eh??...

.... and the bowl bottom jig... every little catch would send the bowl out of center... I can see this working for finishing a bowl bottom though... I will try that later...

I am sure I did not follow the "correct" procedure for gluing and then turning a block on the bottom of an existing bowl... but I am clueless as to what is the right way to do this...

All help appreciated!!


img

Re: This went poorly....

#2

Re: This went poorly....

John Lucas

>That type of jig will work. I'm guessing you were not affectively rubbing the bevel. I played around one day and tried cutting against the grain with several tools just to see, because I used to get catches just like you are talking about. I didn't have any problems. The wood didn't cut cleanly and left tearout but I was able to control the tool and didn't get catches.

What I do in a situation like that is to place the tool on the wood so the bevel is rubbing and the cutting edge is not near the wood. Then slowly rotate the tool or lift the handle to make the cutting edge start cutting.

Re: This went poorly....

#3

Re: This went poorly....

JKJ in East TN

>>I am sure I did not follow the "correct"

>procedure for gluing and then turning a block

>on the bottom of an existing bowl

I've never done that, but I think I would try this: Cut a waste block disk to size with the bandsaw then mount on a faceplate and turn round to fit the bowl bottom. If desired, also turn a tenon sized to fit a 4-jaw chuck. Turn a dimple in the middle and/or bring the tailstock up to mark the exact center. Remove the disk from the faceplate, mount and align the bowl the donut chuck, then apply glue and use the dimple with the tailstock to align the waste block and keep a bit of pressure applied until the glue dries.

If a waste block is already turned round but glued to the base a little off center, I guess another way to true it gently in the donut chuck without tool catches is with 30 or 60 grit sandpaper on a rotating sanding disk.

To hold the bowl better in the donut chuck, you might try some double-sided tape between the rim and the back plate. Good tape (Woodcraft carries some) will hold even a large bowl securely to a faceplate so I suspect some on just the rim would help keep the bowl from being knocked out of alignment accidentally. Some non-skid rubbery material between the bowl and the donut disk of the chuck might also help. (Perhaps try the stuff sometimes used for shelf liners or the foam tape intended to keep throw rugs from sliding around on wooden floors)

JKJ

Re: This went poorly....

#4

Re: This went poorly....

albertabob

>That old lathe of yours wont go slow enough for you to take slender shavings off with a small bowl or spindle gouge.

I had one and it is one thing I don't miss.

Were I you, I would bring in your tailstock and part off the tennon close to the bowl. Also consider sawing it off with a decent hand saw while you have it mounted.

You could finish up with a chisel and a sanding disk after that.

I trimmed off this one today and had some problems too.

regards

bob


img

Re: This went poorly....

#5

Re: This went poorly....

Don Henthorn

>Marc, I had a problem like that and was really puzzled about what was going on. Finally figured out that the bolts holding the doughnut to the base were giving a little bit throwing the work out of concentricity (if that is a word.(G)) I solved the problem by running nuts onto the bolts up against the doughnut and tightening them so the bolts were rigid to the doughnut. I always do the now when I use a dougnut chuck and I haven;t had any more problems. Might give it a try.

Re: This went poorly....

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: This went poorly....

Keith Tompkins

>HI Marc, It appears that the rim of the bowl is much thicker that the area approaching the base....you may not have enough wood left for good support, especially trying to remove such a large mass of maple. the tailstock would give more support in a case like this.

I sometimes make a groove in one disc that the rim sits in, that way the bowl cannot move.

I don't try to repair funnels......bandsaw it up, and start over. Analzye what went wrong, and make a new piece. It takes more time to repair a piece than it does to make it over, and you will seldom be happy with a repaired piece...and, you will find yourself constantly fixing piece after piece.