Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Which small lathe??

Posts

Which small lathe??

#1

Which small lathe??

Guy in Cuba

>The industrial arts teacher and I are ready to purchase lathes. He has a very large delta and I have a mid-size central machine, but both are 25+ years old and we are both into smaller projects. We both want to purchase smaller lathe to turn pens and small bowls.

He wants to purchase the midi-delta now on sale at Amazon, but everything I have read in reviews and in other recommendations indicates the Jet is the better deal. I have also used the Jet in several classes I have attended and like it very much.

What does this experienced group recommend for a smaller benchtop lathe in the midi or mini range?? Especially, one that is on sale right now when we are in the buying mood!!!

Thank-you,

Guy

Teacher

W.T. Sampson Unit School

Naval Station Guantanamo Bay, Cuba

Re: Which small lathe??

#2

Re: Which small lathe??

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Guy,

I have a Jet Mini on a Jet stand, I simply love this lathe, I have turned hundreds of pens on it and many small wood projects, I would not trade it for anything..

Go Jet Mini!!

take care,

Jim

Re: Which small lathe??

#3

JL

Re: Which small lathe??

JL

>Variable speed Jet mini of course. Better resale value, excellent machine with plenty of accessories and aftermarket stuff available. Yes, it's more. If I were getting a small lathe, that would be the one I'd get (I have a Jet 1642 EVS). There are some less expensive lathes out there - but the Jet has a nice 1/2 hp motor. I have used the belt drive, and it's also a good machine. The Delta LA200 is also supposed to be reasonable and is comparable. My $0.02.

Re: Which small lathe??

#4

Re: Which small lathe??

John Lucas

>Go with the jet single speed. It's a good solid lathe with plenty of power. On a small lathe you won't miss the variable speed and there's a lot less to go wrong with it. My second choice would be the Fishe mini.

Re: Which small lathe??

#5

Re: Which small lathe??

JimQ

>I'm going to recommend the Delta Midi. I just thought it was a better deal when I got mine. Pass on the Variable Speed. Those that I know that have them wish they had gotten the belt drive.

The Jet mini and the Delta midi castings come out of the same foundry in Asia, and the motors have the same manufacturing marks. While I can't say for sure, I would not be surprised to find that both had their final assembly done in the same factory.

The biggest difference between the two is the location of the switch. And the color of the paint.

JimQ

Re: Which small lathe??

#6

Re: Which small lathe??

Barry Turner

>I'd go for the Jet mini......in fact I did, about four (4) years ago. I have used it hard.......turning bowls up to 9+"in diameter, small lidded boxes, ornaments, paperweights, winestoppers and a few pens. Variable speed is a nice option.....especially in larger lathes. In this size lathe, I think variable speed control is of limited benefit. I turn 90% of the time on one of the intermediate speeds and never change it. Swapping belts to obtain different speeds is quite adequate and easy enough to accomplish.

Re: Which small lathe??

#7

Jet

Carole in VA

>I kept mine when I got my Nova. I am not about to get rid of it! It's a smooth little lathe. Most of the "specs" listed for the Delta and Jet Minis are about the same except the Jet has a little more travel in the tailstock ram. Look for plastic on the new Deltas...belt cover, locking handles, etc. I understand they are sneaking quite a bit of it in there. Also check for alignment. My Jet is not VS and I don't mind that at all. It's a snap to flip the belts to the next pulley and you don't do it that often anyway when you are turning small stuff.

Re: Which small lathe??

#8

Re: Which small lathe??

JKJ in East TN

>I went through this recently and researched the Jet and Delta mini lathes. I have a Jet 1642 and needed a smaller lathe for a demo.

After comparing, I bought the Jet mini plus stand. Although I would hate to be without variable speed in my larger lathe, I was advised by several people to stay away from the Jet variable speed as unnecessary and actually counterproductive.

I'm quite pleased with the Jet. If you have a local dealer, talk to them real nice and tell them what great advertising they will get from your use. Mine cut me quite a deal even with no advertised sale.

JKJ

Re: Which small lathe??

#9

Re: Which small lathe??

Nelson

>Rikon has starting making a mini, 12in swing and 16in bed length, looks good. Around $279.

Re: Which small lathe??

#10

Nova Mercury

RevDoug

>I'll go against the grain here. Nova used to make a great mini called the Mercury. They have a service rep in the states. You can find the link to his email on the Nova site. I was able to email him and have one made up from parts. Warranty and all. Variable speed on demand. 1/2 hp. I turn lots of pens and even more small bowls and plates. Nothing wrong with Jet or Delta, I just like the Mercury better.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Which small lathe??

#11

Re: Nova Mercury

theeviltwinn

>I had the Delta Midi and returned it. Too many small problems. I now have the Jet and no problems.

Mike

Re: Which small lathe??

#12

Re: Which small lathe??

Arch

>Hi JKJ,

I have a Jet mini vs at home and a Jet mini in Maine I change pulleys on the vs as often (seldom) as on the non vs. Since it doesn't go to zero rpm the vs isn't very helpful, but I haven't found it counterproductive in use, including torque. What did your advisors find counterproductive in _using the vs?

Thanks, Arch (while scratching his poison oak rash)

Re: Which small lathe??

#13

Re: Which small lathe?? *LINK*

georgetroy

>Go with the Vicmarc VL 100. I think this is the orginal Mini-Lathe that the others have just made copies of. You also get a 3/4" tool post for stronger and better tool rests. I have mine setup with a 1/2 hp motor on a board and just slide it back and forth for 10 speeds. I have turned on the others and in my opinion they just don't measure up. This lathe is for a lifetime. You can purchase from Craft Supples USA.


Vicmarc VL100

Re: Which small lathe??

#14

Re: Which small lathe??

Jorge Castaneda~Downeast Maine

>Guy,

If you can afford it, get the Vicmarc, superior in evryway to the Delta or Jet. There is a model without motor and another with a motor and variable speed, to me that is the way to go.

mis dos centavos.

Jorge

Re: Which small lathe??

#15

Re: Which small lathe??

Arch

>The first VL100s were a distinct improvement over the mini lathes of the time. The spindle size, taper, thread and thru hole were standard. The castings were robust and well machined and overall the VL100 tho small was a 'real' lathe. It was a little jewel and it still is.

Since then other more affordable good mini lathes have come on the market that perform the usual _functions of a _mini lathe just a well as the VL100. My Dodge PU transports me as well as an expensive import. The pride of ownership might not be the same, but it does its job and replacement parts and repairs are cheaper and easier to obtain.

I think the analogy applies to mini lathes and for teaching and general private use, a Jet is the best choice.

Just one turner's biased opinion, Arch

Re: Which small lathe??

#16

Re: Which small lathe??

mark heppe

>Workbench magazine just published (Dec '05) a review of 6 midis-they gave their editor's choice award to the Jet 1014. mark

Re: Which small lathe??

#17

Re: Which small lathe??

JKJ in East TN

>>What did your advisors find counterproductive

Mostly I heard what you mentioned, it was not well designed and needed belt changes anyway, so why pay extra and why bother.

I was also told that the torque suffered. I did not test this myself. (Perhaps no one else did either but were going on subjective feelings)

JKJ

Re: Which small lathe??

#18

Re: Why not a PSI turncrafter??

david coburn

>Hi,

I've been thinking about this very question for over a month now and have been leaning heavily in favor of the PSI Turncrafter bought off of Amazon.. I'm surprised that nobody has even mentioned this lathe. Is there a reason for it?

thanks,

david

Re: Which small lathe??

#19

Re: Which small lathe??

Bruce Wiseman

>Well, I would vote for the belt drive jet. I have had one for almost 10 years and t has stood up to everything. I have used the variable and it has considerable torque loss at the slow speeds. I would skip the stand and for less money get a rolling tool stand (mechcanic's tool chest with the drawers.) You can get them from Sears or Harbor Freight for a lot less than the Jet stand, you will have a nice place to store your tools, chucks etc., and it makes the 70+ pounds a lot easier to move around. Just my opinion.

Happy hunting,

Bruce