Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

PM 3520 Vibration Problem

Posts

PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#1

PM 3520 Vibration Problem

George Van in WI

>Has anyone had problems with vibration/wobbling, after adding the weight box to their 3520? I had the lathe move on the floor before adding the weight with anything other than a perfectly balanced blank. I added the box and raised the lathe on 4x4’s with trestle connecting the two as Dominic had shown. My lathe now is stationary but the vibration and wobble are still present. Even a 15” maple rough that was trued but has spalt heavier thus denser on one side will at 450 rpm cause the light to fall off the lathe. A 8-10 inch chain sawed rough blank will do the same.

I lowered the lathe so it sat flush on the 4x4, then I adjusted the levelers slightly so the vibration is minimized. If I put a perfectly balanced bowl on I can turn at any speed without wobble and only a slight vibration that I have to concentrate to notice. This holds true with all chucks. The worst movement occurs at 450-550 rpm.

Any ideas will be appreciated!

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#2

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

John Lucas

>Spalted wood is particularly bad about creating vibration. I was turning a fairly small bowl the other day that vibrated at most speeds on my 3520. I turned right around and turned a 12" green bowl that was deeper than the other one. You could have balanced a nickel on the headstock.

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#3

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

George Van in WI

>Maybe that is the problem John, I have been turning a lot of spalted maple and yellow birch. I did notice on the mentioned blank that the bowl would swing to the bottom each time I let go of it because of the denser wood.

Do you have this happen when you first mount a chainsawn blank till you true it up? Does this seem to happen within a certain speed range on your machine muck worse than at other speeds, at times I can go through the mentioned range and get it to smooth out somewhat. Most of the time it is too dangerous to spin at that speed.

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#4

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

Gerry in Maryland

>Geroge,

I have several friends that have a 3520 and they have built ballast boxes too. I have had some problems with vibration with mine on occasion but I either slow the lathe down or speed it up and it goes away. I never found the need to build a ballast box. I work with splated timber a lot and have found that if it starts out with vibration it probably will have it until the blank has dried after rough turning. If the lathe is not moving across the floor I just keep turning with the speed up. I hate turning too slow and having the gouge jumping all over the place. I like to "git er done".

Hope this helps,

Gerry

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#5

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

John Lucas

>George, that's what clued me in as well. The bowl would rock toward one side telling me this side was heavy. I also noticed that all the tearout was on the light side meaning this side was punky and usually this means very light weight. The opposite side was quite solid and therefore much heavier.

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#6

Dick Hines

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

Dick Hines

>George, when the blank starts to get the vibs play with the RPS. Up or down a 100 will useily smooth every thing right out.

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#7

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

George Van in WI

>Yes Jerry, I hate turning too slow and having the gouge tap on the next high spot, I was just worried about the lathe vibrating badly and causing damage to myself or the lathe. I was taught to not stand in front of the bowl while I am turning which has been helpful on occasion.

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#8

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

George Van in WI

>Thanks Dick, I will have to try that with the more balanced bowls

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#9

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

JKJ in East TN

>>Spalted wood is particularly bad about creating vibration.

Related to that, don't waste time turning a spinning top from spalted wood! (from experience)

JKJ

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#10

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem, hijack

JKJ in East TN

>I meant to add:

If not alread done, someone should devise a counterbalance ring that could be added behind a chuck, faceplate, or even spindle. A counterbalance could be adjustable with a mechanism or replacable weights and would be useful for off center as well as blanks with voids and density variation.

The ultimate lathe might even have that built in, with dynamic detection (similar to a tire balancing machine) and automatic internal correction that could even adjust itself as an off-balance blank was trued. Anyone ever heard of such a thing? (If not and you create one, I want shared royalties on the license. :)

JKJ

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#11

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

Nelson

>Remove the levlers and your problem should go away, if you need the height add wood foot across like on a workbench.

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#12

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem, hijack

John Lucas

>John Someone did and I think it is the guy who makes the high end tools and whose name escapes me at the moment. It is a weight suspended on an arm and attached to the headstock or nearby. The weight is adjusted to compensate for out of balance pieces. If I remember right he listed a special type of threaded rod because standard threaded rod had a tendency to break. I think this was written up in More Woodturning 3 to 5 years ago. I believe there have seen another article somewhere on the web on this as well.

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#13

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem, hijack

George Van in WI

>I think the world is waiting for YOU to respond to the challenge…….And for $29.95.

May be able to pay for R&D from proceeds on the spalted tops!

Watching for the ad,

George

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#14

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

George Van in WI

>Thanks Nelson,

I got the same suggestion from Dominic, I will be down to the shop as soon as this coffee cup is refilled.

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#15

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem, hijack *LINK*

Rick Allen

>Kelton makes the "Balancer".


Kelton Balancer

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#16

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem, hijack

JKJ in East TN

>Nice, looks like a good manual solution.

JKJ

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#17

George, I don't know anyone who...

Jay in TX

>George,

I don't know of anyone who may have done this %~), but was your headstock possibly not locked down when this occurred? I've heard of people who were in to big of a hurry accidently forgetting to lock it back down...just pointing it out...for others...not me (ahem, whistling)...

Re: PM 3520 Vibration Problem

#18

Re: George, I don't know anyone who...

George Van in WI

>Not THIS TIME Jay, but I have done that!