Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Jaw Chucks

Posts

Jaw Chucks

#1

Jaw Chucks

Don Tewell

>I'm fairly new at turning and am looking for ways to save $. I have seen fairly low prices on independent jaw chucks. Are these any good? Or should I wait and get an integrated jaw chuck? Thanks in advance for the help and advice.

Re: Jaw Chucks

#2

Re: Jaw Chucks

Bill Howatt

>If you are an experienced machinist with a good eye and touch then an independent jaw chuck will work for you. For the other 99% of us it is an excercise in frustration. That may be a bit strong but IMO put the money towards a scroll-chuck made for woodturning. Also, the independent chuck's jaws may not be suitable at all for holding bowls and the like.

Bill

Re: Jaw Chucks

#3

Re: Jaw Chucks

Fog Tanner

>Buying cheap tools will cost you more in the long run. As you get more profiecent in turning, your desires will outpace the capabilities of the cheaper tools. An independant jaw chuck is a pain to deal in metal turning, but usable in wood turning as you are going to make the piece round. The biggest problem is if you want to rechuck the piece and trying to get it exactly centered.

There are a number of good scroll chucks made for wood turning. You can also use a three jaw chuck from a metal lathe. You just have to watch the jaws as they can stick out farther than a scroll chuck and your hands are a lot closer to them than when operating an engine lathe.

My preference is Vicmark these days, although I do own two Strongholds. I just like the quality of the Vic, and the fit and feel. You can find variations in price, from the keyed to the "Tommy Bar" or level activated. That would be a personal prefernece, you will find feelings both ways. Mine is the keyed chuck, but I also worked in a machine shop in a previous life doing production work using a keyed chuck. Most production turners prefer the level operated chuck for switching between various sizes quickly.

I think before you waste money on a cheap chuck, you would be better served to use a face plate and save up your coins until you can get a good scroll chuck. As you get more into this addition you will probably wind up with several, just make sure they are all good. Now that you have me thinking about it, I "need" another chuck. This time I think I will opt for the smaller lever operated Vics with the shark jaws. I am doing a lot of boxes right now, and it would be nice to change blanks quickly - and that is what Raffan uses - sounds good to me.....

Just my .05 cents worth.

Fog

Fog

Re: Jaw Chucks

#4

Re: Jaw Chucks

Don Tewell

>Thanks for the feed back. That is kind of the way I was leaning anway, but it's always good to get expert advise.

PS. Fog, don't let your better half know that it was my question that made you realise your "need" for a new chuck.

Re: Jaw Chucks

#5

Re: Jaw Chucks

JKJ in East TN

>Machinists use them, but I can't imagine using one for everyday lathe work, although they might offer flexibility for special purposes. You would have to be sure it was threaded properly for your lathe. (Many woodturning chuck makers offer threaded inserts to fit all the common lathes.)

FWIW, I found this on a chuck vendor's web site:

"Four-jaw chucks have four advantages over three-jaw chucks. (1) They can be used to hold irregularly shaped parts. (2) With the use of a dial indicator, they can be used to center parts with a great deal of accuracy. (3) Four-jaw chucks can be used to deliberately hold a part off-center. (4) They can clamp stock tighter. This is a valuable asset when machining cams, crankshafts, and similar parts.

"The main disadvantage of the 4-jaw independent chuck is that the jaws must be individually set, adding considerable time to setups." http://www.sherline.com/4jawipg.htm

JKJ

Re: Jaw Chucks

#6

Re: Jaw Chucks

Don Henthorn

>Check out the scroll chucks at Griaaly and Penn State. Good chucks for less money.