Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Mulberry or Osage?

Posts

Mulberry or Osage?

#1

Mulberry or Osage?

Carole in VA

>Can't decide. Found it on the log dump, so no leaves to go by.


img

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#2

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

Carole in VA

>The first pic was of the exposed end of the log. This is of the fresh cut end.


img

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#3

Re: Mulberry or Osage? Pic#3

Carole in VA

>Long grain. Doesn't look as yellow as the mulberry I have had before. I haven't had any Osage so I can't compare.


img

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#4

Re: Mulberry or Osage? Pic#3

Gary Ljostad

>Any leaves to check? If it only has sap wood for two annual rings it might be Catalpa. Catalpa is a ring pourus wood with only two annual rings of sap wood. Browner then Osage or Mulberry, darkens with age like Osage, turns well.

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#5

Re: Mulberry or Osage? Pic#3

Carole in VA

>Never thought about that. It does look like only 2 annual rings are sapwood. No leaves at the dump, unfortunately. It had been there for a while. Do you have any pics of it after it has been turned and finished?

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#6

Re: Mulberry or Osage? Pic#3

Sean Troy

>Looks just like Mullberry I have turned before. Sean

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#7

Re: Mulberry or Osage? Pic#3

Gary Ljostad

>Here is a piece turned about a year ago.


img

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#8

JL

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

JL

>How much Osage over on the Shore anyway? I think of Oklahoma, Texas, etc. when I think of Osage Orange.

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#9

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

Kevin Gerstenecker

>Carole, I don't think it is Osage or Mulberry. The bark is not correct for either species. After looking at the cross section, I think it may be some variety of Locust. The bark almost looks "Maple-like", and the juvenile bark of a locust tree that size would look pretty much by what you have there. That is just an educated guess...........kinda hard to tell from the pic's. Sure is pretty, whatever it is! ;-)

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#10

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

Carole in VA

>Actually, there is a fair amount of Osage here. I just have to find it before someone else does! LOL

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#11

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

John Trant (Baltimore/DC corridor)

>Mulberry is softer than Osage Orange, especially the sap wood so you may be able to tell once you turn a piece. Even though we have Osage in our area, I think it is more likely to be mulberry since it is much more abundant (thinking random probabilities here). The bark is correct for older mulberry trees. I am not familiar with catalpa but I didn't think it got as dark as what you show in your photos. I think catalpa is also quite soft (especially compared to dry osage orange). So if it turns like your tools are dull, then it is osage. Otherwise, it is one of the other two.

John

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#12

Brad Vietje

Re: Mulberry

Brad Vietje

>Carole,

This is a pretty fast growing tree (so more likely Mulberry), and the bark is about right for Red Mulberry. There are a number of other Mulberry's too, such as White Mulberry. Osage and Mulberry are about the same weight when fresh (Mulberry has a lot of water in it), but O-O is much heavier when dry, because it is a much harder, denser wood.

Mulberry is pretty stringy, and rather soft, while O-O is more like black Locust -- hard, heavy, and takes a very nice polish. Mulberry is more porus, too.

Have Fun,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#13

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

Dale Stansbery

>It looks like Mulberry to me right down to and includung the crack in the pith.

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#14

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

Jim Ketron

>Carole I have 4 Mulberry Trees in my front yard that have grown in one clump of trees I took some pics for ya.

My Guess it is Mulberry


img

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#15

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

Jim Ketron

>another shoot


img

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#16

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

Jim Pugh, Ohio

>Carole, Osage is brilliant yellow when fresh cut. Just for your info, the Mulberry family, Moracea has several varieties, including Osage Orange. If you don't have a copy of the National Audubon Society Field Guide to North American Trees - Eastern Region, I highly recommend you get one. Most all books stores have them and they are < $20. It shows, bark, leaf forms, flowers, fruit/nuts.

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#17

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

John Veerkamp

>This is definitely mulberry not OO. AS was stated, oo is bright yellow when freshly cut. I have cut a fair amount of both here on my place. both turn well, but OO is my favorite .

John

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#18

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

Carole in VA

>Jim, I have that book. Most field guides rely on twig, leaf and bark stucture as well as the flowers and fruit/seeds. I'm waiting for someone to come out with a "Field Guide to North American Dump Logs - Eastern Region" ;o)

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#19

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Carole,

Not to confuse things further, but it could also be Redbud. The color tends toward brown and the bark is not far from what you're showing.

Hope this helps,

Gary

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#20

Re: Mulberry or Osage? *LINK*

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Carole, I've put a good selection of links to wood I.D. sites on our club's website, take a look at "Hough's American Woods" and the others if you want. Often the best way to identify wood is by the end grain, and the Hough's site has high-rez end grain pics of all woods.


Wood I.D. links, Coulee Region Woodturners website

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#21

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

Mike Brazeau

>Carol.

After reading all of these responses, no one has mentioned smell. About four years ao, I made a similar post when I had turned a piece of firewood from my brother-in-law's woodpile. I got very similar responses. Mulberry has a very distinctive smell and it is a while since I have turned it, so can't tell you exactly what to anticipate, but it is distinct. I would disagree with the weight of OO and wet mulberry being the same. Osage is definitely heavier. My thoughts.

Mike

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

#22

Re: Mulberry or Osage?

Ed Karch in No.VA

>Carol the easiest test for OO or Mulberry is to place a sliver of heartwood in water. if yellow dye comes out it is OO