Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

Posts

Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

#1

Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Hi everyone. Anybody know what the life expectancy of a Oneway live center should be? I’m noticing some play in mine that is affecting some of my projects, especially my pen turning. I can actually wiggle the threaded part that the aluminum cones screw onto. Mine is about 3.5 years old. It's never been dropped, nor do I abuse it with big out of round pieces. I've always heard don't crank the tail stock down too hard for various reasons that could affect headstock and live center bearings so I'm good about watching that too. Can I replace the bearing inside? Anybody else have issues with this? I’m rather bummed. I really wasn’t planning on replacing this, this soon.

Thanks for any advice.

Jennifer

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

#2

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

Fog Tanner

>Jennifer, Mine had play in it in less that one year. It doesn't matter if there is a load on it or not. You can send it back to Oneway and the will put the same bearings in it that went away. I am looking at making a wrench for mine and replacing the bearings myself. The reatining ring requires a special wrench to gain acces to the bearings. After that, it is no big deal to remove and replace the bearings. And good bearing supply house will have a suitable bearing for you application. In the meantime I bought an Axminster live center that does not have any play. I have talked to a number of other people with the same live center as we have and they have the same problem. Some of those were new live centers too. Right now I use the Oneway for roughing and the Axminster for work that matters.

I think it is the bearings that are used, I have had other applications that had a higher lateral load on smaller bearings that never developed lateral play. If you read the Oneway site, they have a note about the play. There are some bearings with different races for different loading. But, I can crank mine down to the point that the center is buried in the wood and still move the piece from side to side. Not really what I would expect from a $100 live center.

Fog

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

#3

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

Bob Persing (Skillman NJ)

>Jennifer, My Oneway live center has a bit of play when unloaded but this is reduced quite a bit when loaded with moderate tailstock pressure. I think it could have been less and suspect that it is indeed the selection of bearings and how they are mounted. I remember reading some comments made by Oneway regarding their justification for the unloaded "side-play" in their design. I believe this stemmed from comments made by users of the JET clone live center that there was considerably less play in the JET when compared to the Oneway.

I too would like it much better if the side play in the Oneway could be reduced. I was wondring if there might be some way to pre-load the bearings by adding shims or something. I guess I'll have to take it apart to find out....maybe some snowy winter evening.

I'm interested if anyone has developed a fix for the play in the Oneway or has at least sucessfuly changed out the bearings. Anyone?

BobP

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

#4

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

John Lucas

>Jennifer I have heard that problem and also the Powermatic copy. I've had my Nova center for close to 8 years now and work it hard and it's still going strong. I have a powermatic live center now so it will be interesting to see which one dies first. I have never taken any precautions and since I change lathes to the powermatic and the tailstock doesn't slip I'm even harder on the live center.

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

#5

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

Barry Irby

>Someone in our turning club walked into a bearing shop and they replaced his bearing while he waited for under twenty bucks. Not sure it was a Oneway, but I think it was a clone. He was very pleased.

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

#6

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Jennifer,

I have thought that the OneWay live center was overpriced. This thread seems to confirm it. My first live center was a single-bearing Craftsman that I paid about $15 for, I think. While it doesn't have replaceable tips, I cranked the hound out of it for years and it never displayed any unwanted freeplay.

I guess my point is that you don't always get what you pay for. Hope you can get OneWay to help you out with this.

To answer your question, for what it costs compared to the competition, it ought to last a lifetime.

Gary

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

#7

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

Pete in Holland, MI

>What type of bearings are in this center, and others ? Standard ball bearings are great for radial loads, but bad on thrust loads, which is what a live center sees. One would think tapered roller bearings, like that on the front spindle of your car, would be optimal.

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

#8

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

JanManuel

>I have one of those inexpensive live centers from Sears too. Mine is about 20 years old and still works fine. I've turned some big mantle columns and other big spindles, and I do NOT want those coming out of the lathe. I've never been hesitant to apply plenty of tailstock pressure.

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

#9

It's a Quality Issue on Reliability

Jim Shaver, Oakville Ontario

>Hi Jen,

I guess my question is really why would anyone even think that it would need replacing at all. I would expect One Way to respond to this as a reliability issue and one I would press with them.

take care,

Jim

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

#10

Jennifer, take your question to... *LINK*

Paul in Phoenix, AZ

>...the Oneway forum. They should have an answer for you.


Oneway Forum

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

#11

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

Juergen

>I've read the same information about the end/side play in the Oneway live center. Even though mine has some play I've never had a problem with the center seating and/or aligning properly under load. It's interesting that my Nova live center didn't last a year. It has sounded like it's going to seize anytime for the last five years.

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

#12

Re: Life Expectancy of a Oneway Live Center?

Don Evans

>You've really asked a question no one here can answer. How many hours has it turned round and round with what stress loading on it would be the question? Even you don't know that probably.

Trying to keep things in perspective, what do you base your statement on it is giving trouble before you thought it should? It may be true that in woodturners eyes $100.00 for a livecenter seems a lot but it isn't really. Check out the pricing in some of the metal working sites, $100 is a very very cheap live center and I would consider $500 plus the norm there. I had one of those that my Dad purchased sometime in the 50's and it was still going till I screwed it up last year.

Oh also on the $500 one's you only get one point (one shape).

Bill Grumbine (sp) replaced the bearings in his one way so yes it can be done, you gotta unscrew the brass plate on front, one with two little holes in it.

Don