Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Live cone center question

Posts

Live cone center question

#1

Live cone center question

Mike Recchione

>As part of getting ready for the recorder making class I mentioned in another post, I need to get a live cone center (at least I think I do). It would be used to true up the blank after boring it out, and then also to do the shaping and finishing of the instrument.

I've been looking at various options on the web, and the prices seem to go from not too much to more than I'd like to spend. I would be using this on a Delta Midi lathe, probably not more than a few dozen times altogether - if I really get into making woodwind instruments, I'll probably start thinking about retooling in a number of ways - bigger lathe, metalworking lathe, etc. But for now I'm taking a minimalist approach, or trying to anyway.

I'm currently looking at the cone center from Enco at http://www.use-enco.com/CGI/INSRIT?PMAKA=251-4002

and the one from Packard Woodworks at http://www.packardwoodworks.com/Merchant2/merchant.mvc?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=packard&Product_Code=110402&Category_Code=lathes-acc-rtc-rcc

Does anyone have any experience with either of these?

I have the live center that came with the lathe, and while a lot of people said they don't like it, it's more or less done the job for me so far. So another option I was considering was making a cone from wood, that would slip over my current live center. Has anyone done this? Is it a reasonable way to go?

Thanks in advance for any replies.

- Mike

Re: Live cone center question

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: Live cone center question

Keith Tompkins

>HI Mike, I have made all sorts of wooden cones. They work allright, but may need occasional trueing up. I think the one-way center with the reversible cones is the way to go. It will also fit your new lathe if you decide to upgrade.

Re: Live cone center question

#3

Re: Live cone center question

JimQ

>With the Midi Lathe the live center has a small metal cone that can be knocked out. Then you can turn a taper on a dowel to fit and use that to mount a larger wooden cone. That's what can I use for a steady after doing the center of a goblet, but with styrofoam instead of wood.

JimQ

Re: Live cone center question

#4

Re: Live cone center question

Mike Recchione

>That's very much like what I had in mind - I was thinking of using a brass or aluminum rod instead of the dowel, but your way sounds easier and better. I also like the styrofoam idea.

- Mike

Re: Live cone center question

#5

Re: Live cone center question - watch out

JKJ in East TN

>Mike,

Be careful with using a cone center on a blank that has been bored down the center. The cone can act as a wedge, and depending on the wood it is very easy to split the tube while applying enough pressure to hold things properly, ESPECIALLY when turning a thin tube. HDIKT? - I split several pieces before I learned.

Consider using a mandrel in the bored hole instead of a cone. For small holes, a steel rod held in a Jacob's chuck in the tailstock is perfect. For a larger hole, you can turn a wooden mandrel to fit a few inches into the hole and hold it with a standard center. Turn a shoulder on mandrel to press against the end of the tube.

I guess you could also make the tube extra long and wrap the end with reinforcement (nylon string and glue), then cut it off when finished.

JKJ

Re: Live cone center question

#6

Good advice!

Mike Recchione

>I hadn't thought of that. Based on postings on the MIMF, it looks like a lot of woodwind makers true up and shape their instruments between cone centers. But your point is excellent - maybe they don't advertise their failures. I really like the idea of the turned mandrel with a shoulder to fit larger or tapered holes. (I'm not sure if it's the right way to do it, but I was thinking that the final shaping of the outside of the instrument should wait until all the step boring and reaming has been done. Seems like a lot less frustrating in case you mess up on the bore if you haven't put a lot of time into making the outside beautiful yet. So you might be dealing with a strange shaped hole by the time you need to turn the outside to the final shape.)

What do you do on the drive side? I was thinking that a similar mandrel held in my 4-jaw chuck would be a good way to go instead of a cone.

Thanks,

Mike

Re: Live cone center question

#7

Re: Good advice!

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>The mandrel is an easy and less expensive way to go. I just made one to turn a pepper mill after it was bored out. I chucked a piece of 2" by 2" pine in my talon chuck. Set my live center in the other end and turned it to jamb fit the 1 1/16 hole bored through the blank. A mandrel turned between centers would probably be easier to remount so it runs true. That would be easier if it was going to be remounted multiple times.

Tom

Re: Live cone center question

#8

Re: Good advice!

JKJ in East TN

>Mike,

Everything I've read says to drill first then turn the outside. This makes sense to me. The bits will often drift a little which would be OK with oversized stock but a disaster otherwise.

You'd probably be safe with what the others are doing today, but I'd personally go for a second mandrel in the drive end. (Driving a mandrel is the way many hollow things are turned, for example pens.)

BTW, I notice that some people have used cone centers on both ends. An article in Fall 77 Fine Woodworking suggests using a cone-shaped abrasive wheel for gripping one end and a non-abrasive cone on the other end. (Because good lathe chucks were not available in the '70s?) At the moment I can't locate the '84 FWW #44 I mentioned in the earlier thread, but if I do find it I'll see what they recommended.

The '77 article mentioned above is on making a Flageolet, a whistle similar to a recorder. The author is Kent Forrester from Murray State U in Kentucky who built medieval, Renaissance, and 18th century woodwind instruments. Perhaps he is still around or has written more on the subject. Starting with a 1" turning square, the author bored a 1/2" hole, cut off the end, removed as much of the corners as possible by hand, then turned the tube. Excellent article, with precise dimensions and lots of tips. I'll bet one of these would look great in Cocobolo.

JKJ

Re: Live cone center question

#9

Re: Live cone center question

James McClure

>I didn't see your other post on recorder making, but I am very interested in learning how you go about making them. Do you have a web link or some instructions on how to make them?

Re: Live cone center question

#10

Re: Live cone center question

JKJ in East TN

>James, look for the thread "long hole boring supplies" on Oct 6 of this year.

JKJ

Re: Live cone center question

#11

Re: Good advice!

Mike Recchione

>Yes, these are exactly some of the instruments I want to make. I'm taking the recorder making course because it's being offered (these things don't come along every day), but also because a recorder is much harder to make than a flageolet - it's a chromatic instrument with a more complicated, conical bore (flageolets are diatonic and most have cylindrical bores, although there are exceptions). Besides the alto recorder the class will make, I would like to make several flageolets in different keys as well as a set of Irish flutes in a few different keys. Cocobolo or blackwood would certainly be wonderful. I'll work my way up to exotics, but I think I'll start with maple and cherry for the first couple of attempts, until I get the hang of it. Should keep me busy for the rest of my life :-)

Is it my imagination, or did FWW have much more interesting articles a long time ago? I'll try to find this one - it would certainly be helpful.

Thanks,

Mike

Re: Live cone center question

#12

Re: Live cone center question *LINK*

Mike Recchione

>James,

There's some stuff on the web, in bits and pieces. I've been poking around looking for this stuff for about a year, and you can piece together a partial story from what you find. There's also a book by Trevor Robinson (you may know him from the OldTools list if you ever lurk there), called "The Amateur Wind Instrument Maker". It's got plans for a baroque alto and a soprano, and lots of other information. Maybe it's just me, but I don't think it's possible to actually learn how to build one from reading the book - too much is taken for granted, and too much is left out.

You can learn much more about making pennywhistles and simple flutes by poking around the web - I've made a few of them using various kinds of pipe and bamboo. There are some freeware packages that help you with hole placement for cyllindrical bore flutes and whistles, none that I've found that handle conical bore hole placement - I'm actually working on one now, and will make it available on the web once it's done. Some of this general knowledge transfers to recorder making, but it isn't the complete story by any means.

This course I'm talking about is scheduled to start some time in December, and will be an online "virtual" course given through the Musical Instrument Makers Forum (MIMF). If you join MIMF (it's free) and post in that thread to indicate you'd like to take the course, it will increase the likelihood that it's actually offered. MIMF also provides a wealth of other information in their library and archives. Their focus is primarily lutherie, but you can definitely spend a good couple of days poring over their woodwind instrument making discussions.

Here's a link to the recorder course thread in case you're interested


http://www.mimf.com/cgi-bin/WebX?128@234.HbPzaEJwqfy.4@.ee8866a

Re: Live cone center question

#13

Re: Good advice!

JKJ in East TN

>>Is it my imagination, or did FWW have much more

>interesting articles a long time ago?

Some discussion about this recently. I have most of the first couple of decades starting with the very first issue and try to read a little every day. (I have a certified reading addiction!)

I find the old articles in general more intesting and with more depth. Many of today's articles are comparisons and evaluations. Some are more about the tools than the process - which tablesaw, all the glues on the market, shelves full of finishes, worldwide sandpaper options, and of course, clamps, clamps, clamps and who makes them and where to buy. It seems to me the old articles had more "how to". Even some of the earlier tool articles were on how to build rather than buy. I just reread a great article on making all kinds of clamps entirely from wood including the screw threads, even how to make a dowel cutter from scratch. The author kept a box of scraps under his bench and when full, took a day and made clamps - he said he could make about ten in one day. The ingenuity of people to create rather than buy a solution is inspiring, especially for lathe work.

Today's articles have a some great looking color photos that make the layout look wonderful. The old issues were chock full of hand-drawn pen-and-ink illustrations - I find these refreshing. The new magazines seem to have articles calculated to appeal to the largest possible audience of hobby woodworkers. Someone mentioned FWW had become more like the Popluar Science than the Scientific American or Smithsonian of woodworking. (Don't get me wrong, I still find it far better than most of the other magazines today!)

The earlier magazines seemed to have published a wider range of articles on many specialty topics that may not have as wide an appeal but are quite interesting anyway. I find the letters interesting as well.

It is fascinating to see how the attitudes and perception of what is good in design and form have changed over the years. It is also fascinating to see how much things have not changed, especially in turned forms. I chuckle at some of the new and innovative original ideas people come up with that were published 20+ years ago and probably devised long before that.

Please keep posting your progress and experiences on the wind instrument subject - I don't have the time this year but I am highly interested in accumulating info and making some in the future.

BTW, I'd gladly trade you enough quality cocobolo for several instruments in exchange for one of your simple practice pieces after you get started! (I'd like to have one for my kindergarten SS class and can't lower myself to buy a tin whistle!) I've also got some 2"+ slabs of some very dense and tight-grained woods that I can't identify (possibly tropical) that I think would make great wind instruments.

JKJ

Re: Live cone center question

#14

Re: Good advice!

Mike Recchione

>That's a great offer! I certainly won't turn down wood, and I'd be happy to make you an instrument. But don't sell tinwhistles short - I've got a couple of coffee cans full of them sitting on my desk, and they're amazingly good considering what I spent on them. What's really interesting is how each different brand sounds different and has its own character. They're definitely addictive. And it's fun to put the speakerphone on mute during really boring conference calls and pick one up and start tootling away while everybody rattles on about nothing (it's a good thing I can work at home a lot :-) ).

Re: Live cone center question

#15

Thanks JKJ and Mike!

James McClure

>