Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Turning 2X4 question

Posts

Turning 2X4 question

#1

Turning 2X4 question

ken chase

>A contest for my woodworking club requires making something

from a 2X4. I plan to make five candlesticks in grduating heights.

What would turn the best, redwood or doug fir?

Thanks

Re: Turning 2X4 question

#2

Re: Turning 2X4 question

Eric

>Are you required to use a single piece of lumber? I think it may be cool to use multiple species like fir, cedar, redwood and make a segmented blank of some sort. One thing to keep in mind with construction grade lumber is that it is likely a bit wet from the lumberyard. You may want to use one of the many good methods of drying the stock first. Hope this helps!

Re: Turning 2X4 question

#3

Re: Turning 2X4 question

John Trant (Baltimore/DC corridor)

>Both are soft and will turn but you need to be careful: soft woods tend to have torn grain and your design will have to accomidate the general general lack of strength and inability to hold fine detail. Otherwise, the choice is more of what you want for the look. Redwood will be darker (and will get even darker if an oil finish is used) than fir but some pieces of fir may have more prominant growth ring figure (i.e., verticle stripes on your candlestick holders).

John

Re: Turning 2X4 question

#4

Re: Turning 2X4 question

matt fallon

>i have tried redwood that i got form an old pergola i took down. it was a very straight grained and splintery/brittle wood, i wont try usig it again probably..

my vote would be douglas fir or cedar,

im a new turner so for long thin candlesticks would probably rely alot on "80 grit gouges"

(sandpaper)

Re: Turning 2X4 question

#5

Re: Turning 2X4 question

Bruce McElhaney Spring Lake, MI

>I turned a peppermill out of a piece of 4"x4" Douglas Fir just for practice, But really liked the result and the wood. Give it a try.

Re: Turning 2X4 question

#6

Re: Turning 2X4 question

Roger H

>Hi! If you can find some old growth redwood, it will turn much better than fir in my opinion. Look for a high ring count. Most "lumber yard" redwood I've seen is second growth from fast growing trees.