Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

Posts

Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

#1

Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

Brian Dz

>I am in the early stages of deciding which would be a better purchase, a Legacy Ornamental Mill or a regular lathe (brand undecided). The cost of the mill is quite a bit higher than a lathe but the assorted knives for the lathe I feel will balance that argument out. I haven't done any turning before but that doesn't mean I won't ever incorporate it into anything I haven't made before. It just seems like the next logical progression.

Let me hear your thoughts and opinions. I would like to hear pros AND cons to both sides since I know there are owners out there of both sides.

I look forward to your info and opinions! Thanks!!

Re: Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

#2

Re: Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

Rick Allen

>Hi Brian

The Legacy Ornamental Mill will require you to become an operator.

A lathe will require you to become a woodturner.

Do you want to be a Ornamental Mill operator or a woodturner?

Good Luck

Re: Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

#3

Re: Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

Eduardo Sarmiento Hall,lima peru

>Well I agree with Rick but you will have to learn to turn is one hell of a lot faster to do the spindles on the lathe then use the legacy to decorate the turning I know that because I started the same way ,with a sears routercrafter,it just took too long to make the spindle so I bougth a sears lathe (tube kind) and start to turn and make lamps and it did pay my travels for a while around the continent

remember you can use both and be a more complete craftman ED

Re: Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

#4

Re: Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

JimQ

>Remember that an ornamental lathe is for decorating the a cut piece of wood. They used to be called watchmakers' lathes or rose milling machines. The Ornamental lathe has a much steeper learning curve and requires much finer attention to details. Two of the members of the AZ Woodturners Assoc brought an antique one in for the last meeting, and they mentioned that they spend more time on setup and maintenance than they do on using it.

JimQ

Re: Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

#5

Re: Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

John Lucas

>Brian I looked at the legacy mill and decided that I could do most of what I would want to do with that machine by using my lathe, a router and building a few jigs. Now If I was going to make 50 of that same item the Legacy would pay for itself. There are some things it won't do without buying custom made router bits. I would say it depends a lot on what you plan to do with it.

Turning spindles requires a learning curve but if you really got on the machine and made 50 or 100 of something you would pick it up pretty quick. The legacy on the other hand requires more skill in setting up the machine but then anyone could operate it.

Re: Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

#6

Re: Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

Sean Troy

>The lathe that was seen at the Az. Woodturners meeting is something completly different than the Legacy. They showed a Rose Engine. sean

Re: Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

#7

Re: Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

Vicmarc.fan

>We have a member in our group who has a Legacy mill. I think he has it because the skew always cut spirals in his wood at the last step. I have seen him set it up a couple of times and he spends hours finding the right piece and then checking paperwork to make sure what to do next. I think by now he has spent a ton on extra attachments to do something else. I would rather have two 24" throw lathes for the same money. Looks like a production machine to me. Not something to make 4 legs for a project.

Re: Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

#8

Re: Legacy Mill or traditional lathe?

JanManuel

>Well, I have both so here's what I think. I've been a production spindle turner and full time woodworker for almost 20 yrs now.

I had my lathes long before I got the Legacy. I have an older Rockwell lathe, and a Delta DL-40. The "big" lathe can take a spindle 54" long. I saw the Legacy machine at a woodworking show when it was a brand new thing. I had a long good look at it, and went home.

I had a Sears Router Crafter that I pushed beyond it's limits too many times. When I started turning down work on a regular basis that the Legacy would have let me do, I got one. It paid for itself long before I finished the 3 yr lease I used to get it.

I've never done "turning" on it, rather use it for fluting, reeding and spiral work. There is a learning curve to setting it up, but once you do it a few times, it gets easier.

My suggestion, get a lathe and learn to use it. Time and practice are the only things that will make you a good turner. If all you need to do is flute a few sets of table legs now and then, a home-built router jig will get that done.