Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Sorby Hollowmaster

Posts

Sorby Hollowmaster

#1

Sorby Hollowmaster

Carole in VA

>Someone posted a while back for help with the Hollowmaster. One person pointed out that his tip was mounted on the wrong side. I remember that I was having a heck of a time with that tool (I had assembled it according to the instructions) until one day I reground the tip and all of a sudden I could use it. Tonight I took the tip off to grind it, started to put it back on and couldn't remember which side it went on so I dug out the instructions which showed it on the left side looking down at the top of the tool. OK, that didn't look right, but I put it back on that way anyway since that's what the instructions said. Guess what? Back to the same old terrible dig in and grab problems I had had before! I switched the tip to the right side and voila! Cutting easy as pie! I figure I must have inadvertently put it on the right side when I reground the tip before and mistakenly thought the grinding was what was responsible for the it being much easier to use. Does anyone else use this tool with the tip mounted as the instructions indicate? If so, try switching it. Makes a big difference.

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

#2

Brian McKearney

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

Brian McKearney

>Interesting post - I actually purchased the Sorby Multitip tool last weekend as an early birthday gift from the family. I believe that the Multitip tool is the little brother of the Hollowmaster tool. Both are featured in the "Focus on Robert Sorby Specialist Woodturning Tools - Part 1" CD. I just took a quick peek at that CD again to refresh my memory. It's rather interesting that the photos of the tools as they would be purchased show the cutter mounted on the left side, but in use, the cutter is always on the right side.

The video demo on the Hollowmaster tool provides reasoning behind mounting the cutter on the right-side. Essentially, as you pivot the cutter tip to the left, the tip that contacts the wood remains supported by the 3/4" tool shaft. As they indicate in the video, as you become more comfortable with the tool, it is possible to pivot the cutter tip further to the left - perhaps beyond support of the shaft. By "support", they imply that the cutter tip is supported as long as it doesn't extend beyond the support of the tool shaft, thus reducing/eliminating the tendency of the cutter to spin the tool during use.

I'm not sure why, but I think that my Multitip tool had the cutter mounted on the left side when I got it home. I switched it to the right side based on watching the video and, while I only tried it out on a small 3" hollow vessel/bowl, it worked fine for me and I was satisfied with it.

Brian

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

#3

Its because your lathe is from Down Under.

Barry Irby

>Doesn't it run in the opposite direction of Northern Hemisphere lathes?

I bought a Sorby scraper (Hollow Master?) for using inside bowls. It has several tips including a hollowing tip. The shaft is about 3/4" and semicircular or half round. I was about to regrind the scraper when I finally realized they intended for the shaft to be flat side down when using the hollowing tips and round side down when using the sort of tear drop shaped scraper. Makes sense after you figure it out and makes it a double purpose tool.

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

#4

Re: Its because your lathe is from Down Under.

Carole in VA

>LOL Nope it's not quite that bad...they only make chucks keyed to turn in the opposite direction! ;)

The multi-tip is similar in that it has a flat side to the shaft, but Hollowmaster is longer and has a cranked shaft. I think the multi-tip is meant to be used shaft flat side down for regular scraping (heavier stock removal)and round side down for shear scraping. As I recall, I saw a guy using a multi-tip at Woodcraft and to do finsh shear scraping he had the tool shank on it's rounded side (with the cutter on top of the tool vs on the bottom for regular scraping) and held at various angles depending on the cut he wanted to take. I think the scraping cutter for the multi-tip must be ground at 90 deg?? This obviously wouldn't work for scraping with the cranked shaft Hollowmaster.

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

#5

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

Ed Kelle

>yup that would have been me. I have not had a chance to get back to using that tool but I am going to try mounting it like you said. I remember switching back and forth with the mountings but can't recall if one worked better than the other. Thanks for the info

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

#6

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

RK in Milw

>Carole, you had me going there. I had to dig up my Hollowmaster instructions and sure enough, they are showing the cutter placement backwards.

A year ago I struggled with the Hollowmaster; couldn't get it to work for beans. Then a Sorby Rep did a demo at my local Woodcraft store and cleared everything up. The cutter should be on the right side when the flat is down. Putting the cutter on the left takes it way off center and things can get ugly fast.

Also their sharpening instructions are less than effective. I asked him why they didn't come up with better instructions and he muttered something to the effect that it was too difficult to write instructions everyone could understand.

FYI: The Sorby Multi-Tip tool outsells all Sorby turning tools 8 to 1.


img

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

#7

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

DWFII

>This has been the most interesting of threads. I have been using the Hoolwmaster with the cutter on the wrong side (and I've got and watched the Sorby video too..doh!). I've just been rough turning and I've been very cautious and have had fair luck with it. But I've also been a little nervous about trying to finish turn a couple of hollow forms that are about ready because I know dern well that I don't have mastering of the tool. I'm hoping this will help.

I did buy a set of Kelton hollowing tools with the heavy handle (that I might not have needed) because of my uncertainty with the Sorby, but...hey...you can't have too many tools!

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

#8

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

Carole in VA

>Let us know how you make out once you have switched the cutter.

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

#9

Grinding The Cutter...

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>My hollowing tool is a D. Stewart, but the cutter is the same. To grind the cutter I suggest that you grind the nose at about 25 or 30 degrees, and side grind it with a curved surface on both sides. You can then cut with a push or a pull cut.

Wally

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

#10

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

GeeSeaWhy

>I also gave up on the Hollowmaster and went with the Keltons. Every so often I'd pick up the Hollowmaster and try again but it only blew up whatever I touched it to. One characteristic the curved Keltons share with the Hollowmaster (and any other curved hollower) - they are uncontrollable unless the straight part of the shaft is over the tool rest.

Graeme

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

#11

A revelation about the Hooker Tool!

Earl Eyre

>Thanks Carole. I use the Stewart Hooker Tool a lot. I first used it at a class and loved it--no problems. Since buying it and using it at home I've had to be very, very careful and rotate it to quite an angle to keep it from catching. I dug out the catalog, and sure enough the cutter is on the right. I've been putting it on the left. Being it's the same principle as the Hollowmaster I'm sure I've been blowing it. Can't wait till tomorrow to go try it the "right" way.

Earl

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

#12

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster-Rules for use

RK in Milw

>Here are the rules for using the Hollowmaster:

Cutter must be very sharp. Forget about the Sorby sharpening instructions. Sharpen the edge of the cutter on a grinder. A Tormek works especially well. Grind the cutter to the same angle you would grind a scraper.

Cutter should be mounted on the right side when the flat is on the tool rest. See photo in my previous post.

Never, never, NEVER try to cut with the curved part of the shaft on the tool rest. Use with the straight part of the shaft on the tool rest ONLY. This puts your tool rest back away from the turning more than you are used to at first. Don't worry. The tool has a long reach.

Tool rest should be adjusted so that the tool is level when the cutter is at the center of the turning. Cut with the tool level or angled down slightly. Level is best.

Cut with the tip of the cutter; not off the side. With a sharp cutter, start by just touching the cutter to the wood. Use a light touch, especially if you start getting ridges in the wood. When the cutter is sharp, it is very efficient. If you have to apply much pressure to cut, it is time to resharpen the cutter.

It helps alot to practice on a bowl first. That way you can see what is going on while you get a feel for the tool. It also helps to practice first with the Multi-Tip tool first.

Happy Hollowing!

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

#13

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster-Rules for use

DWFII

>I have a further question...I went to change the cutter on my Sorby to the right side as you depict in your photo, but the back end of the cutter sticks way out past the shaft of the tool. This would make hollowing through a small opening extremely difficult or even hollowing "around the corner," if you know what I mean, almost impossible--under the shoulder of a tall tapered vase for instance.

What am I missing? Configured like this, the tool seems less versatile than witht he cutter on the left side...but I haven't tried using it with the cutter on the right side yet so I can't even say if it cuts better.

Please comment...anyone...

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

#14

Re: Sorby Hollowmaster

Carole in VA

>I bought a Sorby Multitip today (pn sale so I couldn't resist!) and yes, the tip was mounted on the left side out of the package. I promptly switched it to the right side.