Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Stonghold v. Talon

Posts

Stonghold v. Talon

#1

Stonghold v. Talon

Georg Waldhof

>I have an old (1972) Oliver 2159 lathe which officially has a 14" swing. I'm looking at getting a Oneway jaw chuck and wonder whether the Stronghold or Talon by Oneway would be best. Their website indicates that the Talon is best for lathes under a 16" swing, but since this machine can do substantial outboard turnings, I'm wondering if the Stronghold might be a better bet.

Suggestions? Comments from experience?

Thanks

Georg

Re: Stonghold v. Talon

#2

Re: Stonghold v. Talon

WOODNUT358

>I have a PM3520,and I'm still using my Talon.I stay away from outboard turning due to the fact that you will be replacing your bearings sooner than you think due to the weight that will be unsupported.I have a friend with a Oneway 2036 who has replaced bearings more than once.But for what it's worth,if you are going that route,and the pieces are going to be that big,I would go with the Stronghold chuck.Good luck!!!

Re: Stonghold v. Talon

#3

Brad Vietje

Re: Stonghold

Brad Vietje

>

Re: Stonghold v. Talon

#4

JL

Re: Stonghold v. Talon

JL

>What size motor? If you have a beefier motor, the Stronghold would work quite nicely. If you have 3/4 hp, I'd stick with a Talon.

Re: Stonghold v. Talon

#5

Both

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi,

I have both of them and I use them both depending on what I am turning on either my General 160 or my Jet Mini.

I probably use the talon the most on the mini due to the projects I turn on it, lidded boxes etc. But I find in my work that I go from one to the other and both chucks are usefull.

Look at the scale of your work and decide that way..

Take care,

Jim

Re: Stonghold v. Talon

#6

Re: Stonghold v. Talon

Bill Howatt

>I have a 20" General and a Stronghold and a Talon. Obviously the Stronhold is bigger and made for bigger works. The Talon is quite adequate as claimed by Oneway for your machine and the smaller chuck diameter can be an advantage in shaping what is typically the bottom of a bowl held in the chuck. I must admit that if you have a big piece and really want to tighten the hell out of the chuck the extra beef of the Stonghold is nice.

Bill