Re: More accuracy?
William Duffield, on the Cohansey
>You've gotten good advise. Those are the methods I use, but I'll offer a couple more tips. If I'm making just one or two, to match an original, then setting up several pairs of calipers and a story stick takes too long. In these cases, I use a pair of dividers, set from the original, and mark the critical points, after turning the stock to round. I start from one end, lay the calipers on the tool rest and scratch the stock while it's turning. (As an aside, If you are making a lot of them with a story stick, you can lay the stick on the tool rest and scratch the roughed out stock with an awl, or even mark it with a thin lead mechanical pencil, while the lathe is turning.) Then I use a small pair of outside calipers, again using the the type with a spring and wheel, with measurements taken off the original, to get the diameters right. I use the parting tool in one hand with the handle between my elbow and ribs, and the calipers in the other, above and behind the turning. When the calipers slip over the diameter, I stop cutting. Note that you can't use calipers right off the shelf for taking measurements off of valuable antiques, because they will scratch the surfaces, and catch on the turning. You have to round over and smooth the tips. I use 600 grit w/d sandpaper, but an emery board or emery paper will work too.
Sorry, I it's a bit difficult to take a photo for you to illustrate how I do this, because I don't have a free hand for the camera, and my photos would probably only confuse you, because I'm left handed :^)
Everything else is just what you need to get to Carnagie Hall :^)
A minor rant: If you need any more accuracy than what you can develop by hand, then your original was made by a machine, in which case you might want to ask yourself if it is really worth restoring or reproducing by the methods we are discussing here.
Here is a picture of a "wine finial" I've been working on recently, previously posted on the Woodcarving Forum, alongside the original, which was hand turned and hand carved in about 1790 for a very nicely made tall case clock. At eight and a half feet up in the air, you don't even notice the glaring irregularities in the three originals. What you would notice is that mine (made by the same techniques, except the electric motor and the HSS) is black walnut, while the original was West Indies mahogany :^), but mine is not going back on the clock. I don't yet have a photo of it finished, with cork, preserving the remains of a bottle of wine.
