Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

More accuracy

Posts

More accuracy

#1

More accuracy

RJ

>Hello all;

I am making custom finials for my clocks. I have some that only have photos of what the finials are suppose to look like.

I can zoom up the image (make larger) and have the image printed pretty much on scale of what is expected size wise.

But I find that my cutting techniques are not that accurate. For one I have been holding up a ruler to measure where cuts are suppose to be. I have found that even though I measure I wind up a little off.

Is there a method any of you know to be more accurate?

Here is photo of my latest clock finial.

Thanks

RJ


img

Re: More accuracy

#2

Re: More accuracy

RJ

>Here is what it's suppose to look like. I'm about 3/4" off.

RJ


img

Re: More accuracy

#3

Re: More accuracy

John Lucas

>RJ YOu just have to sneak up on it. I use inside and outside calipers that I bought from Grizzly. I set them to size using a Dial Vernier Calipers. I think you can get those from Grizzly as well. Don't tell anyone but I use the skew on it's side like a scraper to really fine tune a finial that has to be exact. If you take really light cuts and the skew is sharp it won't leave any bad tearout. On straight sided beads get reall close with the parting tool and then clean up the tearout and reduce to the final size with the skew.

Mostly now I use the toe of the skew to get my beads exact. It's a good technique but does take practice.

Re: More accuracy

#4

Re: More accuracy

Barry Irby

>What John said. I still use my skew as a skew/scraper.

Here are some other things you might try. If you don't have numerous calipers, you can make gages for each critical dimension. I have some scraps of 1/8" plywood I use. I just cut out the "jaws" like a wrench. If I need an 1 5/8, I cut out a rectangle out of the piece that is 1 5/8 by about that deep and mark it. I have been known to make them out of card board. Then you can stop the lathe and try your homemade "caliper". Be very delicate with these because they will break or wear easily. Obviously, you can use Plexiglas or even sheet metal. The sheet metal ones will cut your work and your hands. Tape the edges.

You can also use a wrench. If you want a half inch, use a half inch wrench. Our club had a chair turner demo and he used a wrench. This is a little tricky also, because if you get the diameter just right, the wrench may grab if you use it with the lathe running. It will either take the wrench away form you and throw it around, or it may break your turning or rip it out of the drive centers.

You can blow your printed piece up to exact size and cut it out very carefully and save the piece you cut off one side and make a total pattern. You might glue it on cardboard and then cut the white part off one side of the picture and use it against the piece you are turning. Again, a delicate touch to avoid wearing the pattern, You can compare and cut off any parts that are fatter than the pattern.

Keep in mind also that your finials may not have to be identical to the pattern unless you are duplicating an existing one. If you need two or three all they really have to do is be stylistically similar to what may have been on the clock originally and very similar (identical) to each other. I once had to reproduce two of four that were on a bed. My stock was about an eighth undersized and I tried to make them from it anyway. It was obvious they were smaller. I just made four that were the same and used them. I told the client and actually offered to give the two originals back. This was not an antique or heirloom bed. They did not care and actually claimed they could not tell the difference.

Your turning really looks good. Aren't you just getting started with turning?

Re: More accuracy

#5

Re: More accuracy

Ron in Drums PA

>John Lucus gave some you good advice and you seem to have a good head start. Accuracy does not happen right away, you just need to practice a little more.

Re: More accuracy

#6

Re: More accuracy

Stuart Johnson

>Rather than trying to measure each point with a ruler make up a story stick. Use a 1/4" piece of plywood an inch or so wide. Measure each point exact which is much easier than holding a ruler up to the piece. You can then hold the story stick to the piece and make your marks. You have alread received some good advise on how to cut to exact measurements with calipers and wrenches.

Re: More accuracy

#7

Re: More accuracy

John Lucas

>Barry mentioned something that I use but forgot. Cutting out a silhouette is the best way to see exactly where you need to remove material to match the original. I use the colored plastic report covers that you buy from staples. They are strong enough to last a long time and thick enough to stay stiff while your measuring with it.

To get my dimensions close I use a metal Dial caliper and set it a little large than the final diameter. Then I use my parting tool and take it down to that dimension while holding the caliper on the back side. It works like using a wrench but is infinitely adjustable.

Re: More accuracy

#8

Re: More accuracy

Russ Fairfield

>There is nothing wrong with the finial in the photo that cannot be corrected with practice. The difference between "clunky" and "elegant" is practice because shape and tool control come with practice. There is no substitute for the practice that comes from making a lot of finisls, and throwing away a lot of finials.

There is nothing wrong with using a rule and a pencil to layout a piece of wood. Get a spring calipers for cutting to diameter. Get more than one spring caliper so you won't have to adjust the caliper for each diameter. Use box end wrenches for common diameters, they are cheaper thsan calipers, and buy cheap wrenches so you can squeeze the jaws together to adjust their opening. Use a story stick when you want to make more than one that looks alike.

Turning finials and other spindles in a matter of keeping our priorities in order, and knowing what is and isn't important. Remembering the following might help.

Except for a stair rail, two pieces are rarely seen in a side by side comparison, even on a clock. When they are, then exactness is important. Otherwise, it isn't.

Accuracy is always important for making a good glue joint when 2 pieces will be fitted together. Making tenons that will fit into a drilled hole is where the box-end wrench can be useful.

The location and sharpness of the lines between the elements are more important that the diameter and shape of the elements. And, these lines and their location are more important on vertical things like finials and legs, than they are on horizontal things. Here is where the story-stick is useful in making multiple pieces.

The diameter and shape of the elements has only to be "similar" on the separate pieces. How similar comes with practice.

And finally, only you will be able to see the difference between them. Nobody else will notice.

And, how about a photo of the finished clock.

Re: More accuracy

#9

Re: More accuracy?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>You've gotten good advise. Those are the methods I use, but I'll offer a couple more tips. If I'm making just one or two, to match an original, then setting up several pairs of calipers and a story stick takes too long. In these cases, I use a pair of dividers, set from the original, and mark the critical points, after turning the stock to round. I start from one end, lay the calipers on the tool rest and scratch the stock while it's turning. (As an aside, If you are making a lot of them with a story stick, you can lay the stick on the tool rest and scratch the roughed out stock with an awl, or even mark it with a thin lead mechanical pencil, while the lathe is turning.) Then I use a small pair of outside calipers, again using the the type with a spring and wheel, with measurements taken off the original, to get the diameters right. I use the parting tool in one hand with the handle between my elbow and ribs, and the calipers in the other, above and behind the turning. When the calipers slip over the diameter, I stop cutting. Note that you can't use calipers right off the shelf for taking measurements off of valuable antiques, because they will scratch the surfaces, and catch on the turning. You have to round over and smooth the tips. I use 600 grit w/d sandpaper, but an emery board or emery paper will work too.

Sorry, I it's a bit difficult to take a photo for you to illustrate how I do this, because I don't have a free hand for the camera, and my photos would probably only confuse you, because I'm left handed :^)

Everything else is just what you need to get to Carnagie Hall :^)

A minor rant: If you need any more accuracy than what you can develop by hand, then your original was made by a machine, in which case you might want to ask yourself if it is really worth restoring or reproducing by the methods we are discussing here.

Here is a picture of a "wine finial" I've been working on recently, previously posted on the Woodcarving Forum, alongside the original, which was hand turned and hand carved in about 1790 for a very nicely made tall case clock. At eight and a half feet up in the air, you don't even notice the glaring irregularities in the three originals. What you would notice is that mine (made by the same techniques, except the electric motor and the HSS) is black walnut, while the original was West Indies mahogany :^), but mine is not going back on the clock. I don't yet have a photo of it finished, with cork, preserving the remains of a bottle of wine.


Re: More accuracy

#10

Re: More accuracy?

RJ

>Beautiful!

About the twisting an other details. My guess is that you hand carved the twist and other details out after you turned it.

Real cool!

What do you do, draw out the pattern and then wood chisel it away and sand when done?

Do you also use a template for the pattern. So you have same pattern size etc..?

Good post. Thanks!

RJ

Re: More accuracy

#11

Re: More accuracy?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>First, there are more explanations on the Woodcarving Forum. My posts, on "Flame Finial" should be easy to find, it's not nearly as busy a place as the Turning Forum. I'd like to suggest that those of you who do carvings on your turnings might want to participate in that forum as well.

Yest, I turn it first, then draw the patterns on the turned surfaces, carve with carving gouges (not chisels, and not turning gouges, either), then scrape with custom scrapers (cut and ground from hacksaw blades), and sand. There wasn't any sanding done on the original (but he had an advantage I noted earlier), and the facets made by his carving tools are quite clear. They looked a lot like mine before I scraped and sanded, which tells me that I probably did it the right way. I left out some details of the carvings on the bottom half of the ball. On the original, between each flute, there is a thin vein, with a round indentation at the top. For a while, I wondered why he bothered to put them in, since they are not obvious from a distance. He may have used them to disguise the marks from his layout tools. Since I didn't lay them out the same way he did, my flutes ended up with a slight spiral. Oh, well :^(

I don't see a real need for developing a pattern (at least not for these), but some people cut temporary patterns from card stock (manila file folders, for example). I just get the lines pretty close with a pencil and eraser (a card scraper works pretty well for an eraser), and follow them with the gouges. The shape of the gouges more or less automatically correct for any wanderings of the pencil lines.

Re: More accuracy

#12

Re: More accuracy?

RJ

>That's another issue. I need much smaller turning tools. And I guess I would like some small gouges.

Can you give me any leads on various small sized hand tools to carve and/or turn with?

I would like to get some small hand tools to do intracate carving also. I have a wood chisel set, but probably not small enough and all blades are straight. Also feel like I'm not talking about the same thing you are cause you mention that they are gouges but not for turning.

Put simply I would like to know where I can get some smaller type hand tools for hand carving AND smaller tools for turning.

Thanks for sharing your expertize.

RJ

Re: More accuracy

#13

Re: More accuracy?

RJ

>Also wondering how well dremel tool fits in the hand carving.

RJ

Re: More accuracy

#14

JL

Re: More accuracy? *LINK*

JL

>Try Craft Supplies USA in Utah. They sell "mini" tools as well as some carving stuff. For small carving tools, try over on the carving forum. They are "experts" on those. I have a small palm set that I got at LV. It's okay for the occasional small stuff, but not for too demanding carving. There are a few other places to go for small turning tools and carving stuff (Woodcraft, etc.). Pick a place.


Craft Supplies

Re: More accuracy

#15

Brad Vietje

Re: More accuracy

Brad Vietje

>You can even go one step further...

If you need to make a number of alike pieces, carefully cut out TWO silouette patterns (or cut in half a single, symmetrical image). Then mount these seperately on stiff but thin material, and mount one behind the other, in register with one another, and a few inches apart. Place this pair behind the lathe, and line up with your wood blank.

In use, you carefully place your template pair so you can look over the top edge of your spinning piece, and see the two profiles. You then line up your eye with each pair of beads, coves, and what have you, sort of like a gun site, and you should be able to make nearly exact copies. You will have to keep moving your preferred eye to exactly match up with the particular detail you're working on, and get the spacing and sizing so that all THREE images line up exactly -- the two patterns, and the real deal.

Credit for this slick method goes to DJ DeLorie of the Granite State Woodturners in New Hampshire.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Thetford, VT

Re: More accuracy

#16

Re: More accuracy

RJ

>Could you somehow show/take a picture of this? Hard to envision.

RJ