Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

criticing bowl shapes

Posts

criticing bowl shapes

#1

criticing bowl shapes

John Lucas

>I thought this might be useful to some. I'm going to discuss the shapes of the bottom of some of my latest bowls. I took away the color and tried to make it so you could see the outside shape.

The first is an Ogee shape. I think this is fairly good. I find that if you do this shape the bottom part of the ogee needs to be 90 degrees to the table. If it's not it doesn't look right. The curves need to be smooth with no straight areas. I like the size of the foot. A smaller foot would make it look tippy.

The next bowl is a continuous curve that continues through the foot. I think this is the way a bowl should meet the foot unless you do something like an ogee. This shape is just part of a circle with no flat areas. I like the size and height of the foot.

The third bowl has a problem of the curve not being continuous down to the foot. It starts down with a gentle curve but then changes fairly abrubtly about an inch from the foot. If your going to do this I think it should be a more gradual curve at that point. This is a totally different shape than a circle. I think the foot is about right although the bowl would have more lift with a slightly longer foot.

The 4th bowl is harder to see but has the same problem as the one above. The curve goes from the foot out and then changes too sharply as it heads toward the lip. It's not a bad bowl. In fact it's already sold. I have to ship it as soon as i get the finish job done. I would prefer the foot to be a bit smaller from an appearance point of view but the customer is going to use this as a soap dish so it needs to be stable.

Bowl #5 is a catalpa bowl. I like this curve a lot. It flows from the lip all the way through the bottom and back up.If I did it again I would shorten the foot a little. I think it's just a hair to tall. T

Bowl #6 has the same problem as bowl #4. The curve changes too abrubtly about 1" from the foot. I think the foot is too wide. If I shrank the foot and made the curve smoother I would really like this one.

Hope this opens up some conversation. This is just my point of view and is definitely not the only way to do it.


img

Re: criticing bowl shapes

#2

Re: criticing bowl shapes

Carole in VA

>Interesting, John. I like #2 and #5. I ran into the same problem as #3 and #6 on two NE bowls I did. I disliked the abrupt change in the curve so much that I put them back on the lathe and tried to "resuscitate" them! One of them it worked and one of them it didn't. I tend to make my feet shorter and sometimes I like practically no foot at all - just about 1/16" to barely lift it.

Re: criticing bowl shapes

#3

Re: I'm not a fan of tall feet or bases.

Al Crandall- NE of Indy

>Christian Burchard critiqued a couple of my pieces when he was demoing at our club. One thing he liked was that the curve of the outside could be imagined to have passed through the foot and just "kiss" the table top at the center of the foot before it started to exit the foot. This geometry would have helped, in my opinion, the "problems" you cited with bowls number 3 and 4. I really like 1, 2 and 5. Thanks for sharing.

Re: criticing bowl shapes

#4

JL

Re: criticing bowl shapes

JL

>Thanks for sharing. I think that #2 should have a little wider foot. I like the height, but I think a wider foot would give it more visual balance.

Re: criticing bowl shapes

#5

Re: criticing bowl shapes

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>John, good examples and critiques.

I think it is important to also consider the "style" (functional, decorative, whatever) when critiquing a piece, especially if it is someone else's work.

I recently saw a bowl that was a very old / classical functional form. My first impression was: YUK! But looking at it again, the shape is actually quite pleasing, almost sensuous. So, even though I didn't (and still don't) like the bowl, the shape is flawless. And I think that is an important point to consider in critiques.

Re: criticing bowl shapes

#6

Re: criticing bowl shapes

Bill Howatt

>I like flowing curves with no abrupt changes. If the bottom "foot" looks like a sanded and polished chuck tenon I don't like it period! I would like number 6 if the foot had a curve that flowed into the curvature of the bowl perhaps similar to number 1.

Bill

Re: criticing bowl shapes

#7

Re: criticing bowl shapes

Barry Turner

>Bowls #4 and #6 seem to have feet that are too large and heavy. That wouldn't be true if these bowls were large utility or salad bowls that need a large foot for stability. Just my opinion.

Re: criticing bowl shapes

#8

Re: criticing bowl shapes

Ruth Niles

>Brian,

I've had similar reactions to old classic forms but I think we get aclimated to what's being turned at the moment; moment being year, season or posted on WC! I've turned exact duplicates of classic forms that look great in ceramic, glass, pottery, etc. but just are not appealing in wood.

Ruth

Re: criticing bowl shapes

#9

Re: criticing bowl shapes = no color!

Ruth Niles

>John,

This is a great thread and I especially like the fact that you took out the color. Too many times the wood grain or natural voids distract our eye from the shape of the turning. We don't see the flat spots or curves that don't follow through to the foot because our eye keeps going to the beauty of the wood itself. I've often wondered if every turning (bowl, box and hollow form) were painted black, would we still oooh and aaah the same pieces?

Your personal critique is right on in my opinion with each piece.

Ruth

P.S. With school, dog, demonstrations, laundry, photo shoots, cooking, posting here, house cleaning, turning shows, food shopping... WHEN do you find the time to do all this?!?

Re: criticing bowl shapes

#10

You are exactly right.

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>I agree. That bowl was an Asian design, Tibet if I remember correctly, and not what my Western eyes are accustomed to seeing.

Re: criticing bowl shapes

#11

Re: criticing bowl shapes

John Lucas

>Ruth In reality I think you have look at the grain and details in the wood to really fine tune the shape. Sometimes you have a bowl shape in mind but it just doesn't work with that piece of wood because the grain can make the shape look different or your eye may travel to a defect in the bowl and take away from the shape at that point. Unfortunately that can be a difficult thing to see when the bowl in on the lathe and not sanded. I guess experience would help.

Re: criticing bowl shapes

#12

Re: criticing bowl shapes = no color!

John Lucas

>Ruth Look at some of John Jordans early pieces if you can find them. He dyed them black and it really forced your eye to look at the form. I think it's a good learning experience.

How do I find the time? I've always wondered how a woman finds the time to take care of the kids, run errands, cook, work full time and still have time to do anything else. I get frustrated sometimes, like last night, when I just get too tired to do anything or if I sit around and watch a TV show when I should be working. Like right now for instance. I need to finish the tips pages and get them to Carl. I'll do that later today. Sometimes I think I should be an efficiency expert instead of a photographer because I spend most of my day trying to plan how I'm going to get everything done.

Re: criticing bowl shapes

#13

House cleaning? What's that?

Carole in VA

>

Re: criticing bowl shapes

#14

Re: I'm not a fan of tall feet or bases.

Barry Irby

>Al and Christian stole my thunder. I also like a foot that appears as if the curvature of the bowl flows right through it and kisses the table.

John, On the ogee, you mentioned that the ogee should turn vertical where if touches the table. I think you are correct. Somewhere along the way I got the idea the ogee should consist of two curves joined so that one is vertical to the table and the other is vertical to the rim and there is a line between them that is a tangent to both, if that makes sense. This may not be a hard and fast rule and I guess its obvious that it is not, but I wonder if they wouldn't look better if they were that way. Maybe the tangent lines at the two ends should be parallel to each other? Hmmm?

Form is a funny thing. I turned some green bowls of Bradford Pear and thought I had the foot exactly as they should be. Then they dried and warped and shrank a bit and I threw them away. I have another bowl that I turned as a piece of treen. Just a 11" bowl of nondescript Bradford Pear again. I let it sit a few days to finish drying and happened to look at it from across the room, realizing there was something very good about the shape. My son, who is a better turner than I am, spotted it and picked it up and brought it to me, saying "you should keep this one and do it again, you got it right." Nothing special and yet special.

Thanks for your post.

Re: criticing bowl shapes

#15

Re: criticing bowl shapes

Bill Howatt

>I quite agree the grain influences what we do and what we see. However, if the shape is very grain dependent what is the piece going to look like 10 yrs later when the grain pattern has likely darkened and subdued and we are left with just the shape?

Bill