Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Electrical Question...

Posts

Electrical Question...

#1

Electrical Question...

Peter Teubel

>I have been bringing my Oneway 1224 to various venues for demonstrations and run into a few problems. It seems that it doesn't like GFI circuits. I have used it at one venue where the GFI outlet was at the end of the cord and it worked fine. Others, the GFI was at the outlet and the lathe at the end of a regular extension cord (50' 10ga) and didn't work. Oneway confirms that variable speed AC controllers leak current thereby trip GFI circuits.

So, I was thinking of getting an isolation transformer (or variac) with sufficient amperage rating to support the 1hp motor. Would this work? My thoughts are that any current leakage will occur on the secondary winding, but won't be picked up by the primary winding, therefore negating the GFI entirely.

Yea, yea...I know the GFI is there for a reason, but that's not the point here. The object is to use the lathe with a GFI circuit without having to hardwire a pigtail into the panel (like a venue did for me once).

Re: Electrical Question...

#2

Re: Electrical Question...

John Lucas

>Peter I just bought adaptors for my chuck to fit any lathe. Sometimes it's interesting getting used to another lathe but usually not much trouble and it gives me some hands on with different lathes so I can answer peoples questions about these lathes.

Re: Electrical Question...

#3

Re: Electrical Question...

RJ

>Allot of times it's the extention cord fault. It only takes .5 milliamps to trip the gfi. That is .5 miliamps of current detected from neutral to grounding wire.

Many times though gfi recepticles are touchy anyway. An isolation transformer is a good ideal if the gfi is not the touchy type. Otherwise nothing can be done but replace the gfi recepticle or gfi breaker. Personally I think that would be a last option to try. You might even have some saftey issues with your lathe and no protection could be fatal.

I would first test your extention cord by plugging in some other load equal to your lathe. (Skillsaw with load) If it does not trip then maybe you have grounding issues with your lathe.

Ex. Grounding and neutral are tied together, or no grounding wire and micro current is passing from neutral to grounding via the earth.

Green or bare=grounding=earth. White=neutral. Other color hot.

Grounding serves as double protection from dead short. A circuit only requires hot and neutral to operate. Grounding is a saftey measure to assure that a dead short(cut, crimped, burnt etc.. wires ) will trip the breaker.

Gfi came allong later on. Taking advantage of existing grounding systems. There is no such thing as gfi without grounding system.

Grounding is tied to the earth via means of grounding rod.

The grounding system of a building is tied together with the neutral conductor of the electrical service via the main bonding jumper.

This may seem odd at first to have this point of continuity between the neutral system and the grounding system. But it does not effect the capability of the gfi circuitry because the gfi protection is on the load side or branch of the circuit.

The gfi system breaks when detecting differential between neutral and grounding.

If the hot touches grounding (dead short) gfi or breaker trips. If neutral breaks or touches grounding and current flows to grounding gfi trips.

You might also check to see if for some reason you have tied together your neutral (white) with grounding (green or bare or earth).

It is possible that while the gfi worked in one location and not another is because the circuit was not properly hooked up in the first place.

If it is earth then maybe due to water on surface or some other conducting path. If so, try a rubber matt or rubber legs...

Hope this helps

RJ

Re: Electrical Question...

#4

My high end scroll saw manual says...

Clem Wixted

>... to not connect the (electronic variable speed) saw to a gfi circuit. This saw has a DC motor, not a VFD controller.

The advice from Oneway probably has validity.

The one circuit that your lathe did work on, may not have been working (or connected) correctly.

Clem

Re: Electrical Question...

#5

Re: Electrical Question...

woodspinner/ Bill Hale

>Peter

GFI is a finiky critter. I would get a longer #12 cord and find a non GFI plug.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Electrical Question...

#6

Re: Electrical Question...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>Yes, an isolation transformer would solve the problem. But they tend to be a little heavy. (We used them for a while where I worked for that very same reason.)

Re: Electrical Question...

#7

Disagree

Bill Howatt

>I disagree with some of your statements concerning GFIs.

The typical spec for a trip is 5 milliamps and some will trip before that. A level of 0.5ma in a typical household setting would likely cause numerous nuisance trips due to dampness.

A GFI itself does not need a ground to operate and does not detect a differential between neutral and ground. It compares the current going out the hot lead with what is coming back on the neutral. If they are not equal within the spec then it will trip and break the circuit.

Bill

Re: Electrical Question...

#8

Re: Disagree

RJ

>Yeah your right about what you say. I had just been quoting from memory about what I had been told long ago.

The 5 milliamp verses .5 (I just remembered 5).

But in link below says 2 mili amps.

http://www.codecheck.com/gfci_principal.htm

Your right also about the gfci detection of current differentials. I was surprized. (Funny how diagram shows both conductors going through same coil, you think they would cross cancel each other...?)

But there are issues over using 2 wire circuits.

Again this is what I remembered from long ago of what I was told. Being an electrician over 30 years, never really bothered to look into the specifics (we just installed...).

But I still stand by checking the extention cord first by putting load on it. (Wet cord drawing extra current to grounding)

--- From link -----

>>GFCIs and safety ground:

Despite the fact that a Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter (GFCI) may be installed in a 2 wire circuit, the GFCI does not create a safety ground. In fact, shorting between the Hot and Ground holes in the GFCI outlet will do absolutely nothing if the GFCI is not connected to a grounded circuit (at least for the typical GFCI made by Leviton sold at hardware stores and home centers). It will trip only if a fault occurs such that current flows to a true ground. If the original circuit did not have a safety ground, the third hole is not connected. What this means is that an appliance with a 3 prong plug can develop a short between Hot and the (supposedly) grounded case but the GFCI will not trip until someone touches the case and an earth ground (e.g., water pipe, ground from some other circuit, etc.) at the same time.

Note that even though this is acceptable by the NEC, I do not consider it desirable. Your safety now depends on the proper functioning of the GFCI which is considerable more complex and failure prone than a simple fuse or circuit breaker. Therefore, if at all possible, provide a proper Code compliant ground connection to all outlets feeding appliances with 3 wire plugs.

------

Internet is great aint it!

I'm always refining what I know.

I like looking up old song lyrics. Always wanted to know what the Hell some of those songs where talking about...

RJ

Re: Electrical Question...

#9

Good info

Bill Howatt

>Interesting link you provided. I didn't know that they also detected downstream neutral/ground faults.

While the diagrams posted are obviously simplified the cross-cancelling of the effects of the current in each wire is the basis of how the GFI works. If all the current doesn't return on the neutral then there isn't sufficient current to cancel the field produced by the hot wire and the GFI trips.

I totally agree that although the GFI will trip on an ungrounded circuit a proper safety ground wire should always be provided and used.

Bill